Free Money?
Author
Discussion

SimonMaidenhead

Original Poster:

2,650 posts

232 months

Monday 9th February 2009
quotequote all
Not sure if this would work or not?
Currently need to lay my hands on 40 to 50k, so been talking to the knowledgable chaps on here about taking out a mortgage.
Now, this got me thinking, with the interest rates so low over here, why not instead of borrowing 50k borrow 250k instead (sounds mad, but wait a sec). Now use the 50k for the bits I need which leaves 200k, now invest that 200k in a Turkish bank account who are offering a return of 12.25% at the moment. If it were an interest only mortgage, I could use the interest on the 200k to pay the mortgage plus have a bit left over to re invest.
By my reconing I'd have earned enough in interest to have paid the full amount back within 3 years, therefore a free 50k.
Must be something bloody obvious I'm missing here so am prepared for the backlash.

Cheers

G'kar

3,728 posts

215 months

Monday 9th February 2009
quotequote all
And when the Turkish currency tanks?

RichardD

3,608 posts

274 months

Monday 9th February 2009
quotequote all
Look up "Yen carry trade" to find info on a similar idea.

It seems a sound idea apart from the risk of bank and currency collapse!


Soovy

35,829 posts

300 months

Monday 9th February 2009
quotequote all


rofl

You know what they say about a fool an his money!!

Tell you what, I'll pay you 20% pa. Cable me the money.


[footnote]

Start the car

[/footnote]


SimonMaidenhead

Original Poster:

2,650 posts

232 months

Monday 9th February 2009
quotequote all
Soovy said:
rofl

You know what they say about a fool an his money!!

Tell you what, I'll pay you 20% pa. Cable me the money.


[footnote]

Start the car

[/footnote]
my cars quicker wink

Exige77

6,523 posts

220 months

Monday 9th February 2009
quotequote all
What might happen to your plan if the exchange rate between the UK£ and Turkish Lira were to change against you ?

I know a few people that took out Euro mortgages when pound was £1 + €1.45.

It went down to €1.03 at it's worst but has recovered a bit. It means they have to pay back a hell of a lot more money.

It's a big risk unless you know what the exchanges will do and at the moment no one does.

ex77

Fittster

20,120 posts

242 months

Monday 9th February 2009
quotequote all
They key is to do it with a huge amount of money so when it goes wrong the taxpayer will step in because you're 'to big to fail'.

Edited by Fittster on Monday 9th February 14:34

cs02rm0

13,816 posts

220 months

Monday 9th February 2009
quotequote all
See Iceland 6 months ago?

sleep envy

62,260 posts

278 months

Monday 9th February 2009
quotequote all
SimonMaidenhead said:
Not sure if this would work or not?
Currently need to lay my hands on 40 to 50k, so been talking to the knowledgable chaps on here about taking out a mortgage.
Now, this got me thinking, with the interest rates so low over here, why not instead of borrowing 50k borrow 250k instead (sounds mad, but wait a sec). Now use the 50k for the bits I need which leaves 200k, now invest that 200k in a Turkish bank account who are offering a return of 12.25% at the moment. If it were an interest only mortgage, I could use the interest on the 200k to pay the mortgage plus have a bit left over to re invest.
By my reconing I'd have earned enough in interest to have paid the full amount back within 3 years, therefore a free 50k.
Must be something bloody obvious I'm missing here so am prepared for the backlash.

Cheers
can I have the number of your IFA please

I could do with a laugh

hairykrishna

14,492 posts

232 months

Monday 9th February 2009
quotequote all
It's one of those investments that makes sense when exchange rates and the world financial system are stable. Just like at the moment obviously...what could possibly go wrong?

Chris_w666

22,655 posts

228 months

Monday 9th February 2009
quotequote all
SimonMaidenhead said:
Not sure if this would work or not?
Currently need to lay my hands on 40 to 50k, so been talking to the knowledgable chaps on here about taking out a mortgage.
Now, this got me thinking, with the interest rates so low over here, why not instead of borrowing 50k borrow 250k instead (sounds mad, but wait a sec). Now use the 50k for the bits I need which leaves 200k, now invest that 200k in a Turkish bank account who are offering a return of 12.25% at the moment. If it were an interest only mortgage, I could use the interest on the 200k to pay the mortgage plus have a bit left over to re invest.
By my reconing I'd have earned enough in interest to have paid the full amount back within 3 years, therefore a free 50k.
Must be something bloody obvious I'm missing here so am prepared for the backlash.

Cheers
I am sure you're very right, what we could do with the spare when you have paid your mortgage back is start this company call arse ticklers faggots fan club and take out an ad in the back of ...............................

Exige77

6,523 posts

220 months

Monday 9th February 2009
quotequote all
During last 12 months Turkish Lira has varied between a high of 2.74 to the pound to a low of 2.13 to the pound.

It would be a mega risk.

Maybe a couple of extra lottery tickets might be a safer bet !

Ex77

jammy_basturd

29,778 posts

241 months

Monday 9th February 2009
quotequote all
Spread the £200k over a few different, less risk, less return investments? Would still make money, but less of it or it would take more time. Or am I falling into the same trap as the OP?

I did wonder one thing. Who is going to lend you a mortgage for £250k when you only need a fifth of that?

Neil_H

15,418 posts

280 months

Monday 9th February 2009
quotequote all
Yep it's a foolproof plan, I mean look what happened when people invested in high-interest Icelandic accounts, they're all millionaires now AFAIK.

jeff m

4,066 posts

287 months

Monday 9th February 2009
quotequote all
Actually if its a Lira loan and the Lira fell (its at 12% for a reason)the cap repayment in sterling would be a lot less at the end of the balloon.

With a bit of luck and a couple of options it is probably possible, but do you think you can get a 250k unsecured loan.

off_again

13,917 posts

263 months

Monday 9th February 2009
quotequote all
Let me see:

1) Exchange rate
2) Fluctuating interest rates
3) Difficulty in getting a foreign interest bearing account
4) Transferring money abroad
5) Getting a mortgage and spending the money elsewhere (unless its a remortgage)
6) Tax on profit
7) Limits on foreign transfers
8) Investigation by TWO governments tax people for potential fraud

Other than that, seems a foolproof plan to me.

Horse_Apple

3,795 posts

271 months

Monday 9th February 2009
quotequote all
SimonMaidenhead said:
Not sure if this would work or not?
Currently need to lay my hands on 40 to 50k, so been talking to the knowledgable chaps on here about taking out a mortgage.
Now, this got me thinking, with the interest rates so low over here, why not instead of borrowing 50k borrow 250k instead (sounds mad, but wait a sec). Now use the 50k for the bits I need which leaves 200k, now invest that 200k in a Turkish bank account who are offering a return of 12.25% at the moment. If it were an interest only mortgage, I could use the interest on the 200k to pay the mortgage plus have a bit left over to re invest.
By my reconing I'd have earned enough in interest to have paid the full amount back within 3 years, therefore a free 50k.
Must be something bloody obvious I'm missing here so am prepared for the backlash.

Cheers
There is definitely free money involved in this scenario. But it is likely to be your 200k that is free for someone else. wink

LeeThePeople

1,302 posts

212 months

Monday 9th February 2009
quotequote all
It'll never work, credit suisse uk offered me 12% on savings, but after tax and exchange rates (they invested in currency) i was left with a 2% return.

There's also that american fella who has made billions of dollars with currency investments who recently said he had sold all his sterling and investing in currency is the riskiest thing to do at the moment - he is seen as some sort of god in the finance world and people have made money on his words alone so if he is saying its risky, then its risky.

Sending £200k overseas and hoping exchange rates are going to work in your favour is very naive.

Edited by LeeThePeople on Monday 9th February 15:52

Soft Top

1,493 posts

247 months

Monday 9th February 2009
quotequote all
Unlikely to work for the same reason that companies used to pay bonuses in a similar fashion so that there was not tax to pay:

Banker Bob gets a £500,000 bonus
To pay this Big Bank loans Banker Bob 1000,000,000 Turkish Lira
Banker Bob immediately turns the money into Sterling giving him £1,000,000
Banker Bob waits 2 months for the Turkish Lira to drop like a stone, (it always does/did)
Banker Bob buys 1,000,000,000 Turkish Lira for £500,000 and repays his "loan" leaving him with £500,000 tax free bonus

Lovely, unless you are HMRC who were not very impressed with this. Pretty sure they have closed this loop hole.