another bad day
Discussion
just got my car back with the exhaust conversion ,its awesome sounds fantastic and a real professional job . the cherry bombs were made from scratch and new brackets etc .the silencer is not re used .i asked if he could have a look at the clatter problem and the front end clonk .i was then told the front off side wheel as had a bang at some point and is 10mm offset to the other side .he said the engine noise is a liner problem and it needs a rebuild .i am some what deflated and don`t know my next move !.forgot to say the rear drop links have split and only been on the car 12 months .
Edited by daz the plumber on Saturday 14th March 19:33
BLUETHUNDER said:
big geoff said:
i have worked on many cars over the years Alfa Romao and Rovers which had liner problems they would over heat and would loose water i very much doubt it would cause it to rattle get a second opinion Daz
Seconded.
get a combustion gases in the coolant dye test carried out Daz,most garages can do this for you about £20just don`t know where to take it , ives spent £1500 on the engine, new cam lifters and rocker set .it`s had the same symptoms but was put down to a noisey exhaust manifold .ive sent emails but they don`t seem to be interested.i thought maybe a pre engine check before commencing the work would be normal as this money could of be used towards a engine rebuild or a short engine .i need to get the car in for wheel alignment to see its the case . i can see how they can measure 10mm difference between the to front wheels .they are saying one front wheel is in front of the other !any advive taken thanks .
Daz,be carefull they are not measuring the gaps between the whels and the body,not all body's sit square on the chassis,if i guess very few do,so there might not actually be a problem? also id deff get someone proffesional who knows these engines to have a proper look at it,your going round in circles getting differing advise and throwing money at the problem, for a 4.0 engine id think liners were not an issue compared to the over bored bigger engined cars,but im no expert.....
spend said:
Don't see any connection with coolant in a dry liner engine? Eventually it is likely to crack the block.. but can't see how a loose liner would automatically have any impact on waterways at all. Later cars had them beefed up at the bottom to try & prevent this IIRC.
Spend as the liner falls away from the fire ring on the head gasket(slipped liner)you have a reduction of gasket area,you are then going to loose the sealing surrounding the bore due to reduced gasket coverage(and lack of fire ring sealing)with obvious consequences
that small area of ally around the liner is not enough on its own to retain sealing on its own once the fire ring area as breached(dropped liner)
just my cent worth 
Edited by That Daddy on Sunday 15th March 11:11
spend said:
Really?????
Well judging from your earlier post you don't seem to agree
be careful with your answer here Spend engines are not your forte
don't want you getting out your depth son
there's a world of difference between talking engines and building them,and i mean building them not putting them together 
That Daddy said:
spend said:
Really?????
Well judging from your earlier post you don't seem to agree
be careful with your answer here Spend engines are not your forte
don't want you getting out your depth son
there's a world of difference between talking engines and building them,and i mean building them not putting them together 
If you had you would not make Daft comments like that

Just my Cent worth !
daz the plumber said:
so would a failed liner have these symptoms ,the noise seems to be comming from the rocker cover.there is no change in performance .
Try the old trick of holding a shaft against the rocker cover and holding it against bone of your ear, and see if you can localise the noise. It can be difficult as there is so much general noise around the valve gear, but if you can find it, get the rocker cover off and check for possible rocker arm damage (I do beleive the hardened pads have been known to fall off). I dont know how a slipped liner would make it rattle ! the rockers were new only last year, but i can hear an individual tap.the engine sounds horrendous from cold then it subsides as it gets to temperature . im aware of it on tick over and on load then its seems to disappears after 3500rpm or the engine noise drounds the tappinig .it does not miss fire or have any loss of power, does any one know a freindly v8 specialist in the midlands thanks .
daz the plumber said:
the rockers were new only last year, but i can hear an individual tap.the engine sounds horrendous from cold then it subsides as it gets to temperature . im aware of it on tick over and on load then its seems to disappears after 3500rpm or the engine noise drounds the tappinig .it does not miss fire or have any loss of power, does any one know a freindly v8 specialist in the midlands thanks .
Does it get a little quieter after a minute or so ? ie when the oil could've pumped the follower up to make up for a missing pad ?Gassing Station | Chimaera | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff





