Sleeved Exhaust
Sleeved Exhaust
Author
Discussion

debaron

Original Poster:

878 posts

228 months

Tuesday 7th April 2009
quotequote all

Hello all,

I know there's been numerous discussions on this but just wanted to check a couple things.


I want to get my exhaust sleeved - And from another post I believe this involves cutting open the silencer box, and wrapping (or replacing) the baffled pipe with a straight through pipe, stuffing the wadding back in to avoid tinnyness, then refitting the modified silencer.

I've spoken to 2 custom exhaust places around Bristol and both said they wouldn't do that, they would just cut out the box and replace said cut section with a straight through pipe.


All this leaves me a bit confused as to the differences. Why is sleeving done at all when surely it is easier to cut and replace box with pipe instead of messing around opening up silencer boxes?


Or is there some advantage in tone in leaving an essentially pointless silencer box on the exhaust after sleeving!?


I just want what is going to sound best and if that involves leaving the 'dead' box on there then fine - I will but surely there is also a weight advantage too by getting rid of the dead box?

Is there a chance of power loss by doing either of these mods?

Also please advise if anyone has had a 'sleeve' done as opposed to a 'chop and pipe'


Cheers


Ryan

Wildfire

9,951 posts

283 months

Tuesday 7th April 2009
quotequote all
Seeving the pipe, generally means that they take out the perforated pipe and replace it with a straight/solid piece of pipe. There's very little point in wrapping the original pipe.

The system is a "straight through" as in there are no baffles or plates in the system, so there should be no loss of power.

Sound wise it's up to you. Personally I don't like the solid pipe sound as I think it makes the car sound a bit agricultral at low revs.

Some people have the box opened and Bullet type silencers or "Cherry Bombs" fitted, which give a different type of sound.

If you do have it cut open, be sure to make sure they put the wadding back in.

I have the Ptototype ACT SS Cherry Bomb system on my car. Do a search for ACT on PHTV and you can hear it. It's pleasant crusing, but nice and loud on accelleration.

daz the plumber

14,997 posts

262 months

Tuesday 7th April 2009
quotequote all
ive just had mine done , removed the silencer box completly and had fitted two hand made cherry bombs then they fabricted all the brackets as the silencer box is not used .it sounds like the act sports exhaust with out the cost .cost me just over £200 and worth every penny .trouble is i had the conversion done in nottingham and the guy does them on saturdays .its raspy and sounds fantastic when flooring it but its quiet when cruising.

Edited by daz the plumber on Tuesday 7th April 14:36


Edited by daz the plumber on Tuesday 7th April 14:54

loud430

550 posts

214 months

Tuesday 7th April 2009
quotequote all
hi, i had a sleeved exaust on my chim when i bought it & it was very loud, the reason for leaving the silencer in place & sleeving it is so that it looks like its got a silencer on it if you get stopped by the bib for being noisey & for when you have to take the car for its mot. ive now replaced mine with the act cherrybomb system as it was upsetting the neighbours before! the act system makes it sound alot deeper on idle & still gets very loud when you get your foot down!thumbup

im

34,302 posts

248 months

Tuesday 7th April 2009
quotequote all
Wildfire said:
If you do have it cut open, be sure to make sure they put the wadding back in.
Sorry - can't agree.

locodude

510 posts

226 months

Tuesday 7th April 2009
quotequote all
im said:
Wildfire said:
If you do have it cut open, be sure to make sure they put the wadding back in.
Sorry - can't agree.
Why. The reason they put the wadding back in is to avoid any tinny sounds caused by the 'empty box' vibrating, other than that it doesn't do anything.

debaron

Original Poster:

878 posts

228 months

Tuesday 7th April 2009
quotequote all

Yes that's exactly as I thought regarding the wadding. I'm interested to know if there's another reason though?

Wildfire

9,951 posts

283 months

Tuesday 7th April 2009
quotequote all
I've heard some cars where the Wadding was removed. You get a lot of high frequency noises and a bit of a metallic "ting" sound. Not to my preference, but each and everyone to their own. I prefer the "Cherry Bomb" sound, liek the ACT system or Daz's conversion.

im

34,302 posts

248 months

Tuesday 7th April 2009
quotequote all
locodude said:
im said:
Wildfire said:
If you do have it cut open, be sure to make sure they put the wadding back in.
Sorry - can't agree.
Why. The reason they put the wadding back in is to avoid any tinny sounds caused by the 'empty box' vibrating, other than that it doesn't do anything.
I have no idea what you're talking about re: 'Tinny' sound.

I dont have the wading and indeed Austec Racing in Crawley who do this conversion (and have done lots of them) dont put the wading back - nor to does a certain independant TVR specialist I know put the wading back.

I suppose if you've got ears like some kind of high-end sampling device you might hear a difference but to the average bloke in the street its not discernable.

IMHO

Wildfire

9,951 posts

283 months

Tuesday 7th April 2009
quotequote all
im said:
locodude said:
im said:
Wildfire said:
If you do have it cut open, be sure to make sure they put the wadding back in.
Sorry - can't agree.
Why. The reason they put the wadding back in is to avoid any tinny sounds caused by the 'empty box' vibrating, other than that it doesn't do anything.
I have no idea what you're talking about re: 'Tinny' sound.

I dont have the wading and indeed Austec Racing in Crawley who do this conversion (and have done lots of them) dont put the wading back - nor to does a certain independant TVR specialist I know put the wading back.

I suppose if you've got ears like some kind of high-end sampling device you might hear a difference but to the average bloke in the street its not discernable.

IMHO
All down to preference. Like I said, I'm not a big fan of the full sleeved system.

My tip to the OP, have a listen to a few cars and decide which you prefer.

RedLeicester

6,869 posts

276 months

Tuesday 7th April 2009
quotequote all
I had the wadding taken out on my first Chim, and certainly it was a little more metallic, but did roar rather more. On my current one I couldn't be bothered so had the entire unit cut out and replaced with a single pipe for "true" straight-through. Oh, and ACT manifolds.... so it's noisy. Very noisy. Not quite on the level of my old Cerbera, but noisy enough for me biggrin

512tr

13 posts

245 months

Tuesday 7th April 2009
quotequote all
Does it change the performance? Don't you need to have the ECU remapped due to a change of back pressure?

debaron

Original Poster:

878 posts

228 months

Tuesday 7th April 2009
quotequote all
512tr said:
Does it change the performance? Don't you need to have the ECU remapped due to a change of back pressure?
Would be very interested to find out as a drop in power is not something I'd be willing to forfeit for an increase in noise - unless it was only 1 or 2 BHP

lewis_sharman

5,958 posts

222 months

Tuesday 7th April 2009
quotequote all
Ive just had my exhaust sleeved, i cut open the box myself, removed the wadding and old silencers, got a local metalworker to weld in two pieces of pipe, replace wadding and weld back up thumbup

Have yet to fit it to the car as atm i am removing the wishbones for powdercoating and the polybushes are going in. When its all back together i will get a vid and post it up.

ETA pics









Edited by lewis_sharman on Tuesday 7th April 22:43