Performance testing Maplin / RPI / Lucas ignition amps
Performance testing Maplin / RPI / Lucas ignition amps
Author
Discussion

blitzracing

Original Poster:

6,422 posts

251 months

Sunday 26th April 2009
quotequote all
Ive purchased one of the £10 Maplin Amps, and after a bit of giggery pokery got it to work with the signal from the Lucas pickup. Performance seems pretty good so far, with the coil output still reaching 27 + kv at 5500 rpm. There is a fundimental problem with high revving a V8 engine, as by the time you reach 6000 rpm there is only 2.5 milliseconds available for the coil to charge / discharge before the cycle repeats. The coil I used needed at least 3 milliseconds to reach full charge and 1.5 milliseconds to discharge, so the faster the engine goes the weaker the spark becomes. This is not so much of a problem as long as there is sufficent voltage to fire the plug at less than 20kv. You could alter the on / off time by altering the width of the magnetic rotor tips (much like altering the dwell angle), but I would think Lucas have already have optimised this. Ive not yet put the Lucas amp through its paces, but I have a new one on order to see how it performs in comparason. Should anyone be feeing really generious and has an RPI amp I could borrow for a day or two, I would like to test this along side the Maplin and Lucas Amp. The claims they make are pretty wild, and it will be easy enough to see if the performance is better at the higher RPM range, as I think coil performance is really the issue here more than how its switched. ( The Maplin Amp electronics switches up to 500KHZ which represents an engine at 7500,000 rpm !)

Mark

dogbucket

1,256 posts

232 months

Sunday 26th April 2009
quotequote all
loving your work thumbup

look forward to more results

Simon Says

19,466 posts

252 months

Sunday 26th April 2009
quotequote all
dogbucket said:
loving your work thumbup

look forward to more results
Seconded beer keep it coming Mark,you could also try an early Honda ign module(i have them)Mark(also constant energy)i had one working perfectly on a Ford 2.8i Bosch dizzie many years ago after the so called Motorcraft ignition tested tough module packed up(well thats what the label said)that was on the car till i sold it on,my choice for the Honda module was simple at the time i worked for a Honda Dealer(technician)and knew both systems were constant energy wink and the Ford unit was tricky to source s/hand new ones were rocket money and the pattern ones st laugh Simon thumbup

GreenV8S

31,028 posts

315 months

Sunday 26th April 2009
quotequote all
I have an RPI one here somewhere, if you want to try it.

(At least, I'm pretty sure I do - I don't remember throwing it away.)

blitzracing

Original Poster:

6,422 posts

251 months

Monday 27th April 2009
quotequote all
Let me know if you find it.

Thanks

Mark

blitzracing

Original Poster:

6,422 posts

251 months

Monday 27th April 2009
quotequote all
Simon Says said:
dogbucket said:
loving your work thumbup

look forward to more results
Seconded beer keep it coming Mark,you could also try an early Honda ign module(i have them)Mark(also constant energy)i had one working perfectly on a Ford 2.8i Bosch dizzie many years ago after the so called Motorcraft ignition tested tough module packed up(well thats what the label said)that was on the car till i sold it on,my choice for the Honda module was simple at the time i worked for a Honda Dealer(technician)and knew both systems were constant energy wink and the Ford unit was tricky to source s/hand new ones were rocket money and the pattern ones st laugh Simon thumbup
Even using constant energy, you cant overcome the basic charge / discharge time for the coil but I dont know if mis firing is ever a problem say at 6500 rpm on the stock setup as the HT voltages drop.

big geoff

387 posts

231 months

Monday 27th April 2009
quotequote all
HI Mark im a technician) old school i found your topic full of interest, on my triumph twin cylinder motor cycle its got two sets of points and two ignition coils so you get a strong spark all the time .i remember seeing a v8 with the same setup. On Race engines magnetos are used stronger spark than a electronic system i got a mate who repairs mags and been thinking if he can convert a old v8 dizzy i got to mag set up good luck with your tests Geoff

GreenV8S

31,028 posts

315 months

Monday 27th April 2009
quotequote all
blitzracing said:
Let me know if you find it.

Thanks

Mark
I've confirmed I still have it.

blitzracing

Original Poster:

6,422 posts

251 months

Saturday 23rd May 2009
quotequote all
Now having spent a few hours the the various amps, a 'scope and a HV monitor I can report the results. Basically all three amps run on the same principle in so much they are just a DC switch to switch the coil primary. If you simply use them to switch a coil on and off at slow speed, the secondry voltages and spark durations are much the same. I could only measure up to 30kv with my test gear, so had to rely on the distance the spark would jump as the ultimate HT test. Things get more interesting however as the RPM raises. As you reach around 5000 rpm the coil simply does not have enough time to fully charge and discharge between each firing stroke. So you have two options 1) Allow the coil to fully charge so you can get the maximum voltage from the coil, but cut the spark burn time short so the coil can recharge or 2) Reduce the dwell time so the coil peak voltage is lower, but allow a longer burn time. The RPI amp does this and gains gain about 1ms on burn time at 5000 rpm over the Lucas, but at the expense of the maximum HT voltage available. This is not really an issue as the voltages available are still far in excess of whats needed just to ignite the spark. Another point to notice about the RPI amp is it runs very cool, that means the transistor is being switched efficiently and not wasting power in the process. The Lucas runs a lot hotter. I interfaced the Maplin unit to fire directly from the semi sine wave from the magnetic trigger, but unfortuately it does cause the switching transistor to switch slowly, so although the HT performance was much the sane as the others, it ran too hot for long term use. It also would not trigger below about 900 rpm, so it needs additional components to the input sine wave into a square wave to make the switching cleaner.

@5000 rpm

Lucas . Spark duration: .2ms Peak voltage > 30 kv, Spark gap 11mm
Maplin Spark Duration .3ms Peak voltage >30kv Spark gap 9 - 10mm
RPI Spark Duration .4ms Peak voltage 27 kv, Spark gap 9mm


In summary, although these tests are are basic, it does show that its not simply the maximum voltage is not the only important factor, there is not a huge amount to choose between these amps.

Mark


jr6yam

1,363 posts

214 months

Saturday 23rd May 2009
quotequote all
Interesting stuff
The fact that the RPI unit runs cool would indicate
it may well last longer in the harsh environment of
a TVR engine bay.
Would it be possible to run two coils (1 per bank)
to solve the high rev charge/discharge problems?

Simon Says

19,466 posts

252 months

Saturday 23rd May 2009
quotequote all
Nice work as usual Mark thumbup been having a play with the modded air mass meter today(not finished yet)let you know outcome shortly beer

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Sunday 24th May 2009
quotequote all
jr6yam said:
Would it be possible to run two coils (1 per bank)
to solve the high rev charge/discharge problems?
Much easier to run 4 / 8 coils rofl

blitzracing

Original Poster:

6,422 posts

251 months

Sunday 24th May 2009
quotequote all
jr6yam said:
Interesting stuff
The fact that the RPI unit runs cool would indicate
it may well last longer in the harsh environment of
a TVR engine bay.
Would it be possible to run two coils (1 per bank)
to solve the high rev charge/discharge problems?
My thoughts exactly. You need a bistable circuit to take the output from the distributor and switch it alternatly to two separate amps and coils. The outputs from the two coils whould then have to be joined to feed the common king lead, and you would probibly need high voltage diodes to stop the "live" coil feeding back into the "charging" coil, A twin coil pack from a modern wasted spark system would be a neat install. Having said all that, there is quite a lot of headroom in the stock system voltage wise, and I dont know of any issues of the spark effectively running out at higher RPM. More the point is claims of 50kv sparks by certain amps are not strictly true- you would need say a flame thrower coil, and maximum dwell at all RPM to make this true, after all the amp is still just a DC switch. In terms of heat the Lucas unit I tested uses the distributor body as a heat sink, thats somewhat hot already, so Im sure thats why it was moved on later set ups.

Edited by blitzracing on Sunday 24th May 08:29

lotusandy

257 posts

302 months

Sunday 24th May 2009
quotequote all
Interesting work Mark, let me know if you want the Silicon Chip magazine amplifier to test also. I have a circuit diag to convert the reluctor output from the distributor to a square wave if you are interested.
It would be interesting to see what effect using a CDI type electronic ignition would have on the output. I am sure you already know, but a CDI is a Capacitive Discharge Ignition where a capacitor is charged up to a few hundred volts & then discharged into the primary of the coil, the capacitor of course takes some time to charge, but as you are putting say 200v into the primary as opposed to 12v, the output should in theory be somewhat higher than a standard system.
I have just found another electronic ignition hidinmg in the back of the garage, will email you the circuit diagram if you are interested.

Andy

blitzracing

Original Poster:

6,422 posts

251 months

Sunday 24th May 2009
quotequote all
I dont think the CDI systems really lived up to their claims, ok the HT was massive, but the duration was very short, not ideal for road engines that dont run really rich mixtures or special fuels. Im sure thats why you dont see them on modern cars as standard. Far as I see the RPI amp uses a voltage comparitor on the input to give a good switching signal, and the mark space ratio it generates completely controls the burn to dwell period, so this is the critical bit that gives it the longer burn but at a lower initial voltage. Im sure the amp circuit you sent me would give much the same results if you fed it with the same input signal. Please feel free to send me diagrams, but the problem is a fully mapped wasted spark system is around £450 out of the box and vastly superior, so trying to design a half decent twin coil setup may not prove viable cost wise when you are still stuck with the distributor.

Mark