Real world performance
Real world performance
Author
Discussion

jsr

Original Poster:

1,155 posts

281 months

Friday 1st May 2009
quotequote all
I recently watched an Autocar clip on YouTube of a Focus RS matching a Nissan GTR on a twisty, bumpy B-road, and it's got me thinking about what cars are comparable to a Chimaera (400,450,and 500) on a typical country road.

The GTR would demolish the RS on a track or open road, but the advantage is apparently less on real roads. The review said the GTR's size limited confidence and it couldn't deploy always deploy all its power. The RS was said to have a much better front end, inspiring total confidence.

So what about the Chimaera? My 400 doesn't handle bumps too well, has a lot of grip but doesn't feel chuckable like a hot hatch, and is only slightly faster than the RS in a straight line (judging by Evo's test data this month). But, it does manage to put its power (183bhp @wheels) down with little fuss, probably something the bigger torquier engines struggle with(?)

What do you reckon would match a Chimaera?
I reckon a Clio Cup would be a match for my car

scotty_d

6,795 posts

225 months

Friday 1st May 2009
quotequote all
I came from a subaru impreza and in My opinion is one of the fastest B road cars out there it can use all its power through the 4wd and is very easy to drive quick and I know one could have me in my chim in the real world on our bumpy roads. It was quick but its plastic and jap with no soul and it did not put a biggrin every time i drove it

Edited by scotty_d on Friday 1st May 13:01

MrChips

3,299 posts

241 months

Friday 1st May 2009
quotequote all
On all but the smoothest country roads, my Cooper S would be a lot quicker (in my hands at least) as it's easier to drive close to the limit and inspires a bit more confidence. It's one of the most fun cars I've ever driven!

If you're talking rwd (i.e. similar type of car to the Chim) then even an mx5 would keep up for the most part!

I just don't think the Chim is a quick point-point car, it's more about the torque, noise and the emotion of driving it.

blueg33

47,025 posts

255 months

Friday 1st May 2009
quotequote all
When I was looking to buy my car I wanted V8 noise and sharp handling. I drove a Chim and it sounded great and was comfortable but certainly in standard set up was not a sharp drive and didn't corner quickly, at the time i tried my BMW 525d on the same roads and it felt at least as fast, but still sounded like a tractor. On the straights the chim was quicker.

I opted for the Ginetta G33, V8 engine, sharp handling and easy to set up, but there are days when i long for chim style grand touring ability.

Chimjunkie

2,879 posts

242 months

Friday 1st May 2009
quotequote all
Great topic! I have done a fair bit to my car, Nitrons, stiffer springs, 300bhp (fly) and the car does go really well. Unfortunately my bird is a bloody good driver and i always find it a challenge to keep up with her cars! Ford Focus ST, Mini Cooper S Works, Lotus Europa... General rule is - If you are following you have a massive advantage and may be able to keep up. If you lead, then hope for a straight bit of road! hehe


jsr

Original Poster:

1,155 posts

281 months

Friday 1st May 2009
quotequote all
When i did a Car Limits training day shortly after buying my car, i discovered there is a lot of grip even in standard setup, but at road speeds you would never know it. You have to push past it to the point where the tyres really start to work. It is an unnatural feeling even on a smooth airfield. On a road, i've never chucked my car around to anywhere near the limit. My Fiesta Zetec-S that i had previously was completely different, loads of feedback and steering feel.

village idiot

3,227 posts

298 months

Friday 1st May 2009
quotequote all
a well peddled mini cooper s will make a mockery of your 'averag' tvr chim... BUT... a mini cooper is an over-styled hatchback that sounds like a demented hair-dryer, whereas the tvr chim is a true burly muscle car with a soundtrack to match....

it's not all about straight line speed OR going round the corners... sometimes, it's about sensation and feel... in this capacity, the TVR wins hands-down.

just my 2p's worth of course

Zippee

14,159 posts

265 months

Friday 1st May 2009
quotequote all
I agree with all the above. A 400 Chim is a quick car but by todays standards no longer a fast car.
I've been head to head with a Cooper S in the Alps and whilst I could pull away on the straights he was all over me on the twisties.
I've also had trouble shaking a hot spec Avensis. My modern standards the Chim is cumbersome, especially around bends but it does evoke a feeling most modern cars cannot provide!

Speed isn't everything, pleasure, driving enjoyment etc far out weight all out speed and the fact that a Focus ST, Cooper S, GTR etc has god knows how many computers helping keep you on the road means the Chims is more fun. Especially in a self satsifying, I did that, kind of way!

locodude

510 posts

226 months

Friday 1st May 2009
quotequote all
village idiot said:
a well peddled mini cooper s will make a mockery of your 'averag' tvr chim... BUT... a mini cooper is an over-styled hatchback that sounds like a demented hair-dryer, whereas the tvr chim is a true burly muscle car with a soundtrack to match....

it's not all about straight line speed OR going round the corners... sometimes, it's about sensation and feel... in this capacity, the TVR wins hands-down.

just my 2p's worth of course
Went out last night with two mates in their caterfields and even the 2.0 pinto powerered one can really 'hockey on' let alone the one with cosworth power, the Chim is never embarrassed but it's hard work. I recently lost my job and the Chim was at the top of the hit list. One of the lads said 'you've got to get a job, cos I love following that thing, it sounds and looks mint'. Nuff said. Got a new job starting tues. The Chim is staying put.
p.s. we're off to the ring in July, wonder who'll be the fresher when we get there?

scotty_d

6,795 posts

225 months

Friday 1st May 2009
quotequote all
But when you get on the ring i think the chim will come in to its own

Kitchski

6,552 posts

262 months

Friday 1st May 2009
quotequote all
I have a little saying for TVR's when this very subject arises....

It's not how fast it goes, it's how it goes fast that makes you love it!

Wildfire

9,951 posts

283 months

Saturday 2nd May 2009
quotequote all
With a little more power, my Elise would have the TVR in a real world scenario.

locodude

510 posts

226 months

Saturday 2nd May 2009
quotequote all
Wildfire said:
With a little more power, my Elise would have the TVR in a real world scenario.
On the roads that we go out on for a Hoon I'm sure your elise would leave me for dead, but as has been said repeatedly it's how it does it that makes it for most of us I'm sure. It's the only car I've had for a long time that always put's a biggrin on my face everytime I turn the key.

Blown2CV

31,662 posts

234 months

Saturday 2nd May 2009
quotequote all
It's a difficult question. I think with comparable 'average driver' skills, even a relatively modest sports car or hatch could hold on to a Chim, even a 500. They require a far greater skill level to extract the potential speed. Most modern sports cars have traction, ESP, ABS and so on and are just a bit of a case of point and squirt. I would not want to get into a race with an AMG or a fast bimmer. Also, forgiving suspension and ride on moderns mean you are less concerned about pushing faster, esp on unfamiliar roads. I have found myself backing off more than a bit in the Chim for fear of hitting pothole or lumps and bumps.

Hoover.

5,993 posts

273 months

Saturday 2nd May 2009
quotequote all
you would be doing well to shake an s2000 or may be a an MX5 dependant on how twisty the roads are.

jdl1981

299 posts

214 months

Saturday 2nd May 2009
quotequote all
Chims are old hat these days, the engine, chassis and suspension are all ancient so i'm not suprised modern cars are faster. You do need a bit more driver skill and care to drive one fast. I've debated enough about how slow my 400 is, but i'm starting to get over the lack of performance car crudentials and just use it an open top cruiser, which is much more fun than driving around in a clio sport or similar. One thing i will say though is that the first thought in my head after nearly being embarassed by a turbo diesel family saloon in a straight line, was not 'ah but it looks and sounds great and is full of character'!

nawarne

3,181 posts

291 months

Saturday 2nd May 2009
quotequote all
Kitchski said:
I have a little saying for TVR's when this very subject arises....

It's not how fast it goes, it's how it goes fast that makes you love it


BLOODY QUOTE OF THE YEAR!!!!!!
Sums it all up so succinctly.
Nick

rigga

8,808 posts

232 months

Saturday 2nd May 2009
quotequote all
In reality,my impreza will murder the Griff over anything other than straight smooth flat roads,its a lot more stable,has more grip being 4 wheel drive,and just does not scare me as much as the tvr does,its very predictable,poss even slightly boring in the way it just works ........ which do i prefer to drive though?






Not even close really,fire the Griff up and all thats irrelevent,as a driving experience with the rush of brute force,the sound of thunder and the whole package makes the Griff a wonderfull place to be....








Tyre_Tread

10,697 posts

247 months

Saturday 2nd May 2009
quotequote all
I maintain that my 993cc Charade GTti is quicker on a back road than the chim but show them a straight and the Chim goes byebye

The Chim for me is all about grunt.

Mate of mine has a S200 and the first time we were out in our respective cars and I was following him we went into a roundabout together and as we came out he began to slowly pull away. I couldn't believe it at first but then saw the nose of his car dip a few times and realised that he's dropped it 3 cogs and I'd only had to go down one. hehe

f@-pots

204 posts

234 months

Sunday 3rd May 2009
quotequote all
Dunno about you guys ,but I find there are two things that slow me down on twisties. Number one for me is the power steering not giving me the 'feel' to nuance every little bit of grip in the corner (in comparison to my other cars) and I'd say the other thing is the (relatively) cumbersome gearchange which has caught me out a few times , resulting in lots of revvs but no drive!
I know what you mean when you say you only changed down 'one' gear for the roundabout , I reckon if you could do it quick enough and with much less physical effort you probably would. We dont do it cos the engines are torquey and normally thats enough, but during 'spirited pursuit' I've often wished I could use another gear.