Business Partnerships
Business Partnerships
Author
Discussion

beakr

Original Poster:

1,405 posts

242 months

Monday 18th May 2009
quotequote all
I have a predicament in the office which I thought I would share with the PH masses (to some extent) in order to get your general opinion.

Basically we are partners with two companies, (A & B). Company A is the market leader by far and we have had a partnership with them for some years, selling their products in exchange for leads on where we can provide consulting (we're IT). However, Company B are a new startup and they are creating a big old buzz in their own area. Company A is several times larger than B (think top 10 software companies in the world)

However, Company B's product is a direct competitor to one of Company A's products (we use more than one of A's).

Company A has told us that if we are partners with, or remain partners with Company B, they will cancel our (paid for) partnership, and give us nothing in terms of ANY of their products. Company B don't mind one bit who else we partner with.

So, question is, is Company A correct to say that? Is it even legal?

The Moose

23,709 posts

240 months

Monday 18th May 2009
quotequote all
Why not start up a seperate company to take on Company B's product if you think you have the right contacts to make a fair few £££ out of it.

You could also use a "face" of this new company?? Very effective I must say wink

Cheers

The Moose

beakr

Original Poster:

1,405 posts

242 months

Monday 18th May 2009
quotequote all
Unfortunately we're a little close to both to be able to do this. They both know us very well.

Martial Arts Man

6,703 posts

217 months

Tuesday 19th May 2009
quotequote all
It is legal; they don't have to do business with anyone (outside of contractual obligations).

The thing that first sprung into my mind is, why is A so scared of B?

I have had dealings with large LLCs before; always a nightmare, always. I know it is of no help to you here, but I will never ever deal with a PLC or LLC again; they just steamroller right over the top of you. The attitude is that they will do what they like and if you complain, expect the expensive solicitors letters to appear!

I guess you need to decide if dealing with A is going to restrict your business further down the line? Could they just decide one day to stop dealing with you, leaving you with nothing. I would be wary of only having one, LLC size, supplier. The next stop after removing their competition is to drive down your profit at the expense of theirs.

bds the lot of em!


Landlord

12,689 posts

288 months

Tuesday 19th May 2009
quotequote all
Martial Arts Man said:
The thing that first sprung into my mind is, why is A so scared of B?
Very true. Is B the first company you've partnered with along side A? Can you afford to drop A and take a punt on B?

Tough decisions but MAM makes a very good point re:steam-rollering.