Chimera vs. Z3 M roadster
Chimera vs. Z3 M roadster
Author
Discussion

ConorNZ

Original Poster:

73 posts

220 months

Tuesday 19th May 2009
quotequote all
I finally bought a car since arriving here, and am already thinking I need another one to keep the Aston company in the car park. I've always been partial to the Chimera, preferably in 5.0 form and yellow. Was doing some research and came accross this Fifth Gear comparison of the Chimera and BMW M Roadster: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E10HZQR1g2k&fea...

Makes for interesting viewing, although I note they forgot to include a reliability category.
Something makes me think the BMW would have taken it if they had... wink

The used price makes for a more difficult comparison as well, with the 5.0 Chimeras a good few grand more than the Beemer. The real question is, can I convince myself a BMW will be as enjoyable an ownership experience?

peaktorque

1,807 posts

242 months

Tuesday 19th May 2009
quotequote all
IMHO BMW do not deserve their reliable reputation.

When the TVR breaks down you won't be disappointed as you already expect it to happen wink

Zippee

14,159 posts

265 months

Tuesday 19th May 2009
quotequote all
ConorNZ said:
Makes for interesting viewing, although I note they forgot to include a reliability category.
Something makes me think the BMW would have taken it if they had... wink
Perceived reliability dear boy!! Too many people see BMWs, Mercs, Audis etc in a similar way to the emporors new clothes. They believe what they're told and it becomes a kind of self fulfilling prophecy for the marque - If it breaks it's just overlooked and people never hear about it!

The Chimaera is a very simple beast - ancient Rover V8 engine, Ford, Rover & Vauxhall parts plus the usual niggly TVR electrics but in the main a very reliable car and easily capable of use as a daily driver!

Chimjunkie

2,879 posts

242 months

Tuesday 19th May 2009
quotequote all
Thanks for bringing that clip to my attention! Really enjoyed it. Now where's my old set of wheels. Off to do some donuts nuts

ConorNZ

Original Poster:

73 posts

220 months

Tuesday 19th May 2009
quotequote all
Zippee said:
Perceived reliability dear boy!! Too many people see BMWs, Mercs, Audis etc in a similar way to the emporors new clothes. They believe what they're told and it becomes a kind of self fulfilling prophecy for the marque - If it breaks it's just overlooked and people never hear about it!

The Chimaera is a very simple beast - ancient Rover V8 engine, Ford, Rover & Vauxhall parts plus the usual niggly TVR electrics but in the main a very reliable car and easily capable of use as a daily driver!
You may be right, but all I can see is the obvious difference in mileages. I can only assume that the M Roadsters have so many more miles because they're on the road so much more of the time...

Zippee

14,159 posts

265 months

Tuesday 19th May 2009
quotequote all
ConorNZ said:
Zippee said:
Perceived reliability dear boy!! Too many people see BMWs, Mercs, Audis etc in a similar way to the emporors new clothes. They believe what they're told and it becomes a kind of self fulfilling prophecy for the marque - If it breaks it's just overlooked and people never hear about it!

The Chimaera is a very simple beast - ancient Rover V8 engine, Ford, Rover & Vauxhall parts plus the usual niggly TVR electrics but in the main a very reliable car and easily capable of use as a daily driver!
You may be right, but all I can see is the obvious difference in mileages. I can only assume that the M Roadsters have so many more miles because they're on the road so much more of the time...
I think you're overlooking the fact most TVRs are bought as second/weekend toys. Many owners actually tuck them away over winter. There are loads on here that are well over 100k on the clock and still going strong.
No offence but one of my real personal gripes is people who have never owned (or even sat in) one thinking they know everything about the cars. Do your homework & I think you'll find the RV8 cars are very reliable if maintained correctly!

Shabs

1,866 posts

237 months

Tuesday 19th May 2009
quotequote all
Conor... you have never heard of a Vanos? or how about the main bearing on the Z3M S54 engine? Z3M's are great cars, but realiable they are not!

slideways

4,101 posts

252 months

Tuesday 19th May 2009
quotequote all
ConorNZ said:
Zippee said:
Perceived reliability dear boy!! Too many people see BMWs, Mercs, Audis etc in a similar way to the emporors new clothes. They believe what they're told and it becomes a kind of self fulfilling prophecy for the marque - If it breaks it's just overlooked and people never hear about it!

The Chimaera is a very simple beast - ancient Rover V8 engine, Ford, Rover & Vauxhall parts plus the usual niggly TVR electrics but in the main a very reliable car and easily capable of use as a daily driver!
You may be right, but all I can see is the obvious difference in mileages. I can only assume that the M Roadsters have so many more miles because they're on the road so much more of the time...
mmmscratchchin mine has done 110000+ miles and has only needed a new cam at 860000 it only let me down once due to a corroded fuel pump connection which would have been a five minute job if i wasnt on the hard shoulder so what zippee said is absolutly spot on as far as i am concerned

ConorNZ

Original Poster:

73 posts

220 months

Tuesday 19th May 2009
quotequote all
Zippee said:
I think you're overlooking the fact most TVRs are bought as second/weekend toys. Many owners actually tuck them away over winter. There are loads on here that are well over 100k on the clock and still going strong.
No offence but one of my real personal gripes is people who have never owned (or even sat in) one thinking they know everything about the cars. Do your homework & I think you'll find the RV8 cars are very reliable if maintained correctly!
None taken Zippee. Although I don't believe I ever professed to know everything about the Chimera. In fact, the only thing I alluded to is that, on the whole, the BMW would be more reliable than the TVR (which I think even you would find hard to argue!). No offence but one of my real personal gripes is people who jump to conclusions and go for personal attacks.

AlexanderV8

1,498 posts

234 months

Tuesday 19th May 2009
quotequote all
For me, there would be absolutely no choice between the two cars.
Personally, I just could not even consider the BMW. I am not going to knock it because I have never bothered finding out too much about it. It just doesn't do it for me - maybe it's a very capable car but I have absolutely no interest in owning one.
As for the Chimaera, I wanted one for years. I just love the car and the marque and have done ever since I was a kid. I suppose nationalism plays a part, but putting that aside, to drive it is to love it. It's fly by the seat of your pants motoring. It's a lifestyle choice - do you want something which sounds as good as it looks (inside & out), is eventful, exciting, sometimes unpredictable but makes every drive an occasion, or do you want to arrive at your destination wondering if the journey could have been more involving?
Whatever you choose, I hope you enjoy it as much as I have enjoyed the Tiv so far.
If neither really floats your boat, don't forget Lotus. They seem to be coming out with some cracking cars now.

myquest

78 posts

258 months

Tuesday 19th May 2009
quotequote all
I've had my Chimaera for 7 years now and it has only let me down once, a fuel pump relay, which is nothing to do with TVR and I now carry a spare! Admittedly there are always things that need doing, I've just replaced the front ball joints, engine mounts and air filter, which isn't that hard to DIY and the result is superb! I love my car again!!!! Getting the Geo set tomorrow then off to North Wales on Thurs am to drive the Evo Triangle before palying golf at Hoylake on Thurs pm. as a golfer and a car nut it doesn't get much better and I can fit the clubs and a Hill Billy electric trolley in the boot!!!!!!!

Shabs

1,866 posts

237 months

Wednesday 20th May 2009
quotequote all
ConorNZ said:
Zippee said:
I think you're overlooking the fact most TVRs are bought as second/weekend toys. Many owners actually tuck them away over winter. There are loads on here that are well over 100k on the clock and still going strong.
No offence but one of my real personal gripes is people who have never owned (or even sat in) one thinking they know everything about the cars. Do your homework & I think you'll find the RV8 cars are very reliable if maintained correctly!
None taken Zippee. Although I don't believe I ever professed to know everything about the Chimera. In fact, the only thing I alluded to is that, on the whole, the BMW would be more reliable than the TVR (which I think even you would find hard to argue!). No offence but one of my real personal gripes is people who jump to conclusions and go for personal attacks.
Dude - do some research on the Z3M - The S50 engine has Vanos issues (£2K a pop) and it can go at any time - also, replacing it doesn't mean that it won't go again. The S54 engine has major issues with the main bearing and for some reason when BMW recalled the M3's with the S54 engine they didn't do it on the Z3M (They just limited the rev's!). If this goes you are looking at mega bucks to get it fixed, potentially upwards of £10K. In addition, the Z3M Coupe has some pretty serious suspension issues - the rear shocks detatch from the tub etc!

I was tossing up between a Chim and a Z3M Coupe. I initially went in with the assumption that the BMW was more reliable, but after looking into it I came to the conclusion that it wasn't. Also, with the TVR you have limitless access to very reasonable indies as well as with the RV8 cars they are very simple to work on yourself. My TVR costs me a lot less than my BMW 3.30d to run, and although there are small niggles with my TVR, I can fix them myself very easily (on the side of the road in London BTW). The Z3M's not only get you raped by BMW servicing (more expensive than Porshce BTW), but you pay M Tax (nice way of saying BMW slap a hefty premium on for the M badge) and you have to put up with BMW's shocking service levels.

Good luck in your search - both are cracking cars, just go into it with your eyes open

Shabs

ConorNZ

Original Poster:

73 posts

220 months

Wednesday 20th May 2009
quotequote all
Thanks for the feedback guys. I suppose another benefit of TVR ownership is the wealth of knowledge and club support out there.

I kind of agree with you AlexanderV8, and as per my original post, the biggest thing in favour of TVR (and against BMW) is the ownership experience. The TVR would probably be the more rewarding overall.

Whilst I'll be focusing my search on the Chims, I'll be sure to drive an M Roadster for comparison, just to make sure! Now to see if I can find my dream spec (4.5/5.0, yellow, perusian blue leather, original wood dash...)

dogbucket

1,256 posts

232 months

Wednesday 20th May 2009
quotequote all
Great clip, bet the Grifters will love the golf club bit biggrin

Ant.

5,254 posts

312 months

Wednesday 20th May 2009
quotequote all
Too right ! Golf clubs just slip in so easy hehe

Barkychoc

7,848 posts

235 months

Wednesday 20th May 2009
quotequote all
I don't have a Chim but a V8S - and one of friends used to have a Z3M convertible or whatever its called.

The Z3M was fast no question - and to be fair it was a nice car.
But thats what it was - a car. It could have been anything mass produced with similar spec and performance.

A TVR is an experience - you either get it or you don't - and if you don't then I don't think it is for you.

Nothing beats that V8 sound IMHO.

You have to remember TVR's are hand built specialist cars - and some of the early Chimaera's are getting on a bit now - would you be surprised if a German car of similar vintage broke down?
No - only you'd say it was unfortunate with the German car - but if its a TVR you'd say its an unreliable piece of crap. Yet the reality is that there's no difference.

Edited by Barkychoc on Wednesday 20th May 10:11

Simon Says

19,466 posts

252 months

Wednesday 20th May 2009
quotequote all
BMW reliable rofl

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Wednesday 20th May 2009
quotequote all
ConorNZ said:
None taken Zippee. Although I don't believe I ever professed to know everything about the Chimera. In fact, the only thing I alluded to is that, on the whole, the BMW would be more reliable than the TVR (which I think even you would find hard to argue!). No offence but one of my real personal gripes is people who jump to conclusions and go for personal attacks.
I'm not so sure a BMW would be cheaper or more reliable. The BMW certainly has more to go wrong and BMW parts prices are expensive and you need specialist tools to do some work. Also even the newest Z3 is now approaching that age when things will need replacing (suspension, bushes and so on).

The TVR is all nut and bolts. And assuming you buy a good one it'll only need regular maintenance rather than repairs. Ok the RV8 is an older engine so you'll want to service it more often, but that's not unreliable as its an expected cost. As an addition any good mechanic can work on a TVR, if you are handy with some spanners you could even do a lot of it yourself.

For a daily driver I'm sure the BMW is a fine performing car, but it's difficult to tell from a base model 1.9 Z3 and certainly lacks the sense of occasion. For lower mileage or a 2nd car I think a TVR would be a lot more fun and a lot more enjoyable to own.

Edited by 300bhp/ton on Wednesday 20th May 10:44

900T-R

20,406 posts

288 months

Wednesday 20th May 2009
quotequote all
BMW ownership may be more painless for the first owner but as both cars are now 10+ years old you'll find the TVR being the more long term-proof proposition for its simplicity, the fact that it shares loads of parts with old Fords and (Land)Rovers and fantastic support from indies, parts/upgrade vendors and fellow owners alike.

That said, my brother used to have a high mileage Z3M Roadster and it was a cracking car - as close to a German TVR as you'd get. OTOH he did less miles with it in 3 years of ownership than me in the Chim in the frist year after registering it here. scratchchin

Edited by 900T-R on Wednesday 20th May 10:30

scotty_d

6,795 posts

225 months

Wednesday 20th May 2009
quotequote all
It’s got to be the TVR because anything else is just a car TVR is a way of life full of passion and soul I have still to find any other cars that can give me that felling when driving .