Discussion
I'm a student but from time to time have ideas which I think would work extremely well. However I dont know how to go about taking it further. I had an advertising idea today which to my knowledge is not in effect anywhere but would be worth a fair bit of money.
How do I go about getting my ideas to the right people without them using the idea and me getting nothing.
Any advice would be greatly appreciated. I'm just trying to pay my way through university anyway possible but get some business experience too.
How do I go about getting my ideas to the right people without them using the idea and me getting nothing.
Any advice would be greatly appreciated. I'm just trying to pay my way through university anyway possible but get some business experience too.
Hi
I guess the first step would be to research the competition a little more. Find out how they do it, why they do it etc. Have a think about why no one else has done this. Knock up a business plan if for no other reason than to answer questions to yourself. Do a cash flow forecast too.
With such little info to go on, its hard to gauge what help you are after? Any more info to hand??
Cheers
Max
I guess the first step would be to research the competition a little more. Find out how they do it, why they do it etc. Have a think about why no one else has done this. Knock up a business plan if for no other reason than to answer questions to yourself. Do a cash flow forecast too.
With such little info to go on, its hard to gauge what help you are after? Any more info to hand??
Cheers
Max
It's not this http://www.turnstudio.net is it? I am looking for a place in the midlands to open a second location. Where are you based?
R1chy11 said:
How do I go about getting my ideas to the right people without them using the idea and me getting nothing.
You're right to be concerned but in reality, you'll find the vast majority of people are trustworthy and decent. You cannot tell nothing to nobody, ever and sharing ideas is what drives business.Some practical tips for added piece of mind would be:
Write a description of your idea, put in an envelope with a copy of that day's Times newspaper and send it to your solicitor / bank manager / etc, registered post, with instruction to retain it but not open it.
Sell yourself as much as your idea. The idea may be copied but you can't. Make it "yours",
Target who you speak to carefully.
HTH
R1chy11 said:
In fact I have just found out the idea is being used in London but nowhere near me in the midlands
There will be a reason for this.Ideas don't stay exclusive for long when it comes to advertising methods?
How could you keep yours that way? If you can't and given you say it has already been done, why not tell us?
Martial Arts Man said:
R1chy11 said:
In fact I have just found out the idea is being used in London but nowhere near me in the midlands
There will be a reason for this.Ideas don't stay exclusive for long when it comes to advertising methods?
How could you keep yours that way? If you can't and given you say it has already been done, why not tell us?
If it has already been done somewhere else, it isn't really unique, so to put it bluntly, what 'value' does your input have?
Contrary to popular belief an 'idea' isn't worth much, if at all. Anyone can come up with an idea and overvalue it (Dragon's Den anyone...?), it takes a lot more skill to make it work and it takes balls, risk and money to put it into practice.
Therefore the 'idea' is a small cog in the machine and worthless without the machine. If you can bring more to the table than just the concept then you bring more value and a better proposition.
StevieBee said:
Write a description of your idea, put in an envelope with a copy of that day's Times newspaper and send it to your solicitor / bank manager / etc, registered post, with instruction to retain it but not open it.
Bit of an urban myth apparently and is completely worthless in a court of law.1 said:
StevieBee said:
Write a description of your idea, put in an envelope with a copy of that day's Times newspaper and send it to your solicitor / bank manager / etc, registered post, with instruction to retain it but not open it.
Bit of an urban myth apparently and is completely worthless in a court of law.As with anything, you get what you pay for.
I understand that an idea isn't worth much but when thats all you have you want to try and get something from it so that next time you could input more than just that.
Anyway, the idea is to sell advertising space either on lcd screens or digital picture frames on buses and in taxis, obviously the transport owners will take a cut but surely this would be a steady yet certain way of making money. It's already in effect in London but I feel even in my local area it would definitely drive sales if the right audience is targeted. I.e. the right shops on buses from the right areas.
Any input would be great. Even if I cant take this idea anywhere it would be nice to learn a bit for the future.
Anyway, the idea is to sell advertising space either on lcd screens or digital picture frames on buses and in taxis, obviously the transport owners will take a cut but surely this would be a steady yet certain way of making money. It's already in effect in London but I feel even in my local area it would definitely drive sales if the right audience is targeted. I.e. the right shops on buses from the right areas.
Any input would be great. Even if I cant take this idea anywhere it would be nice to learn a bit for the future.
R1chy11 said:
I understand that an idea isn't worth much but when thats all you have you want to try and get something from it so that next time you could input more than just that.
Anyway, the idea is to sell advertising space either on lcd screens or digital picture frames on buses and in taxis, obviously the transport owners will take a cut but surely this would be a steady yet certain way of making money. It's already in effect in London but I feel even in my local area it would definitely drive sales if the right audience is targeted. I.e. the right shops on buses from the right areas.
Any input would be great. Even if I cant take this idea anywhere it would be nice to learn a bit for the future.
I think you are underestimating the cost of buying (I doubt you could lease them given the abuse they would take in a cab), installing and then selling the space on these screens. Do you not think if there was profit in it, the company(ies) behind that one you speak of in London wouldn't already be doing it nationwide?Anyway, the idea is to sell advertising space either on lcd screens or digital picture frames on buses and in taxis, obviously the transport owners will take a cut but surely this would be a steady yet certain way of making money. It's already in effect in London but I feel even in my local area it would definitely drive sales if the right audience is targeted. I.e. the right shops on buses from the right areas.
Any input would be great. Even if I cant take this idea anywhere it would be nice to learn a bit for the future.
Would a bus company (i.e. a really big firm on the whole) really do anything else, even if they thought your idea viable, than steal it and get their own advertising people, who already sell ads on buses, to do it? Nope.
I'd rather advertise on the outside of a cab than inside.
All advertising ideas sound great till it comes to try and sell the space.
I don't mean to rain on your parade.....although you did react a little sniffily to the cold hard truth of business that often gets over looked; ideas are most definitely worth nothing alone.
Nada. Zilch. Action, and action alone gives a subsequent value.
It took me a few years to realise this myself though, in fairness.
Keep the ideas coming and don't be disheartened if 99% are non-starters. That 1% is enough, provided you take the right action.
Good luck!
I've just been out for a drunken meal and wandered back to my (London) flat to see an LCD equipped bus - and this was metres from my flat such that it is still in my memory when reading this thread - only showing primary colours a la the printing colour proof things (CMYK) you get in newspapers.
So what have you got to protect against this?
<uch better idea: Line the underground with moving adverts. Should be really easy with something like the central line that is computer controlled... there shouldn't be much drift
So what have you got to protect against this?
<uch better idea: Line the underground with moving adverts. Should be really easy with something like the central line that is computer controlled... there shouldn't be much drift

R1chy11 said:
I understand that an idea isn't worth much but when thats all you have you want to try and get something from it so that next time you could input more than just that.
Anyway, the idea is to sell advertising space either on lcd screens or digital picture frames on buses and in taxis, obviously the transport owners will take a cut but surely this would be a steady yet certain way of making money. It's already in effect in London but I feel even in my local area it would definitely drive sales if the right audience is targeted. I.e. the right shops on buses from the right areas.
Any input would be great. Even if I cant take this idea anywhere it would be nice to learn a bit for the future.
The thing to pick up from this is the 'idea' has not only to be profitable, you need the wherewithall to put it into place.Anyway, the idea is to sell advertising space either on lcd screens or digital picture frames on buses and in taxis, obviously the transport owners will take a cut but surely this would be a steady yet certain way of making money. It's already in effect in London but I feel even in my local area it would definitely drive sales if the right audience is targeted. I.e. the right shops on buses from the right areas.
Any input would be great. Even if I cant take this idea anywhere it would be nice to learn a bit for the future.
First of all, there is a reason why this is done in London and nowhere else as far as I know. Guarateed viewers. A tube station may get 100 or 1000 times the viewers than on a static bus somewhere else.
Not wanting to burn the idea down, but what about this one of mine:
I get some bricks (cheap).
Some land (cheap).
Some immigrant builders (cheap).
Build posh houses and sell them for loads of money.
A perfect concept of course - what kind of cut do I get.....?
With your idea you have a few major points which alone are not insurmountable but in conjunction with eachother would make a new startup worthless and if any failed would scupper the whole business:
1) Technology to put it in place.
2) A workforce to sell the advertising space.
3) Paying advertisers - enough to make a profit - a lot.
4) Funding of a six or seven figure sum to put in place all of the above.
All of this combined with the fact there are big companies already out there to pick up on something you cannot patent with the resources to put 1-4 in place in days.
This one is not impossible but only in the same way that if your local Sunday League team are 14-0 down to Man Utd at half time it is not impossible for them to win.
R1chy11 said:
I definitely think it would be profitable, obviously not as it is London but definitely is. But like you say without the means to do so and with the transport companies easily able to do so themselves, the idea is worthless to me. Thanks for the advice. Onto the next one then.
I don't think it is definitely profitable at all.It is marginal and a hard slog at best under ideal circumstances on a big scale with huge funding.
It is very difficult to get people to give you money at the moment even if you can put something in their hand to show for it. But for the thought that a local company if they hand over money they 'might' get some extra turnover they could never prove you were responsible for, that in turn they might profit from is a big long shot.
To be honest, the biggest problem would be selling the advertising. You would be hard pressed to make the sales department profitable on it's own by getting the turnover to match the wage bill let alone worrying about the rest.
R1chy11 said:
I definitely think it would be profitable.
Clearly, or people wouldn't be doing it. They are, and unless an advertising company has just turned into a bizzare form of charity, they are expecting a return. You might call that profit.Good on you for having an idea and doing something about it, the vast majority do not.
Then they whinge when they see "their idea" on a shop shelf or in a blaze of publicity…
ETA- perfectly respect JustinP1's opinion above mine- starting something like this from scratch would be difficult to say the least. But still- someone HAS. Someone somewhere made the decision that it was a go-er, so again I applaud you R1chy11, I mean think about it- it took Edison over 1000 efforts to get a lightbulb to work. How long would the World have waited if he'd given up after the first time? Or the tenth? Or the 999th? Persistence is a very useful (some would even say necessary) quality in business.
Edited by DonkeyKong on Friday 29th May 07:08
There are already people doing it around the country:
http://news.scotsman.com/scotland/Dragons-Den-flop...
http://news.scotsman.com/scotland/Dragons-Den-flop...
Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


