Purchase of an established business...
Purchase of an established business...
Author
Discussion

timbobalob

Original Poster:

364 posts

273 months

Sunday 7th June 2009
quotequote all
Hi all,

I'm considering the purchase of a business and thought I would ask the brains of Pistonheads your opinions! smile

I can't go into too much information about the details of the business (confidential information etc) but to outline:

  • wedding and conference centre
  • established profitable business of 7 years
  • healthy profit (acid test ratio 0.4 not including dividend)
  • bookings into 2011 with deposits paid
However, the purchase price is substantial and the business mortgage brokers require additional security (i.e. freehold at 25%). The only property that is available with the required amount is my grandmother's home (she's 83)... having spoken to her and explained the situation she is obviously concerned that if we mess everything up she could lose her home (or 70% of it as the lender doesn't require the full value). Having said that, she is very keen to help! The security is only required for the amount of time it takes to pay off (just over four years on my forecast). My grandmother has spoken to an old influential family friend (previously an annuity risk advisor who is pretty business astute) who has categorically dismissed it as being too risky at her age and frustratingly has refused to see any figures!

Ultimately, I'm trying to investigate what contingencies I could have in place to reduce the risk of her home being compromised - so far I've got:

  • income insurance
  • mortgaged amount includes property that would be sold (85%)
Obviously these are pretty much last resort other than keeping the business profitable in every way possible.

In no way do I want her to feel pressurised and uncomfortable in this venture, but delving into the figures it seems to be a great opportunity and pretty* secure (or as much as it could be in these times).

So am I asking too much? And am I a complete g1t for asking this of my family? whistle

Many thanks for any feedback! smile

Tim


Edited by timbobalob on Sunday 7th June 22:40

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Sunday 7th June 2009
quotequote all
Dude...

If you have to risk your grandmother's house, it ain't worth it.

Just think what would happen should the business you are buying have gremlins you don't know about and/or it is not as profitable as your think, and the bank get cold feet and call in the debt. Would you ever forgive yourself - and would your family?

I run a business with the knowledge that although I take risks, at the end it is my assets at risk. That allows me to sleep well and take risks and be flexible. There is no way I could do that in the situation you are explaining - it is my idea of a nightmare, seriously.



Pobolycwm

330 posts

211 months

Sunday 7th June 2009
quotequote all
Bookings into 2011 confirmed with deposits, depending on how much of your actual turnover that represents ie not just a couple here and there but substantial business and that the bookings / deposits are not accounting fabrications there to make the business more attractive then I don`t think you`re asking too much of your grandmother, as long as you`re certain the risks are all transparent.

Obviously better to raise the capitol on your own risk but that isn`t always possible

I bought my own business putting a lot on the line, house/savings/pension etc do you trust the sellers ? An annuity risk assesor will be pretty risk averse, goes with the territory

eps

7,161 posts

300 months

Sunday 7th June 2009
quotequote all
Initial thoughts, it is risky for your grandmother.

If it all goes wrong, how much does she stand to lose (financially) and where will she live? Surely you're asking her children to forego their inheritance as well.

Saying that if the order book is full until 2011... I think you need to sit down and work out how healthy the order book is and also if you can succeed in pushing that kind of business through 2010 - 2014.. If the current owners leave, is the business going to see a downturn? Are they likely to move to a competing business close by? I'd be looking to put in a competition clause, stopping them from taking business on the books away and also from competing against you for future business not yet on the books. I'd also try and identify the key areas where the business succeeds and make sure that those key areas, be they a few people or advertising or marketing remain in place and you have their "buy in" to what you intend to do with the business. They may also be looking to either move on, or possibly take the opportunity to jump ship.. Again ensure that the current owners cannot pinch the staff. I'd also be looking to identify areas where they aren't maximising their potential and expand it. I think it's quite a tough business to get right, but easy to get wrong and sit there and ask yourself why it's going wrong but not be able to see why it's going wrong..

I think you need to stay with your positive look on the business, but also realise that it's not you taking the risk. You need to have a firm idea about the payback to your grandmother and stick to it, effectively she'll own it / earn all the profits for the first four years.

I'd also have to look at the order book and take a worst case scenario, what if a high number of bookings cancelled or dropped out, what then? How many weekends are booked up, with what.

From a personal perspective the setting / grounds make a big difference to these kinds of places. The backroom staff need to be good. Ideally a very good pair of chefs, if not at least one good chef. Excellent front of house, brilliant reception staff and outstanding events co-ordinator. These people are key, if they aren't up to scratch or leave, you need to be able to replace them with comparable staff. Otherwise people will go somewhere else, or expect to pay less for the service they receive.

Offers and deals need to be offered to tempt people to stay there and then rave about it to friends, etc... The food needs to be of excellent, outstanding quality and ideally a large proportion sourced locally.

Wacky Racer

41,414 posts

278 months

Monday 8th June 2009
quotequote all
timbobalob said:
So am I asking too much? And am I a complete g1t for asking this of my family? whistle
In a word yes.

Sorry.

timbobalob

Original Poster:

364 posts

273 months

Monday 8th June 2009
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
Dude...

If you have to risk your grandmother's house, it ain't worth it.

Just think what would happen should the business you are buying have gremlins you don't know about and/or it is not as profitable as your think, and the bank get cold feet and call in the debt. Would you ever forgive yourself - and would your family?

I run a business with the knowledge that although I take risks, at the end it is my assets at risk. That allows me to sleep well and take risks and be flexible. There is no way I could do that in the situation you are explaining - it is my idea of a nightmare, seriously.
Thanks for your reply - I think to be honest I might have charged into this and not thought really what I am asking of her/the family, though it seems such a shame to miss out on this potentially fantastic (though also risky!) opportunity

smile

timbobalob

Original Poster:

364 posts

273 months

Monday 8th June 2009
quotequote all
Pobolycwm said:
Bookings into 2011 confirmed with deposits, depending on how much of your actual turnover that represents ie not just a couple here and there but substantial business and that the bookings / deposits are not accounting fabrications there to make the business more attractive then I don`t think you`re asking too much of your grandmother, as long as you`re certain the risks are all transparent.

Obviously better to raise the capitol on your own risk but that isn`t always possible

I bought my own business putting a lot on the line, house/savings/pension etc do you trust the sellers ? An annuity risk assesor will be pretty risk averse, goes with the territory
Cheers Pobolycwm - that's really what I'm trying to ascertain at the moment from all of the figures/business - the amount of risk I am asking of her, and what there is possible to minimise it (insurance etc).

smile



Edited by timbobalob on Monday 8th June 07:46

mrmr96

13,736 posts

235 months

Monday 8th June 2009
quotequote all
I see a lot of these types of transactions (I work in corporate finance helping people buy and sell businesss) and I have to say that I've never seen anyone willing to put a relatives house on the line to fund an acquisition. There's a reason for this.

As such my personal advice would be not to proceed with her house as security.

timbobalob

Original Poster:

364 posts

273 months

Monday 8th June 2009
quotequote all
eps said:
Lots of helpful stuff
If it all goes completely wrong, she would stand to lose 70% of the house's equity - so potentially it could be mortgaged out. Funnily enough my mum and aunt are completely behind it and said that they would step in if things got bad (I'm pretty lucky really!).

That is the other risk is if I would see a downturn because the owners leave - I think it's arrogance to think that I can go in and do it better than someone who's been doing it for years! They're looking at retiring from the business so taking customers is slim.

Luckily they've got no staff, and all catering is done by an external company so salaries are an absolute minimum. The grounds are incredible and a real selling point of the venue - having mystery shopped several in the surrounding area it stands out as having the most character/charm, and also being one of the cheapest!

Thanks again for your lengthy input - especially at the time of night that you posted!

smile

timbobalob

Original Poster:

364 posts

273 months

Monday 8th June 2009
quotequote all
Wacky Racer said:
timbobalob said:
So am I asking too much? And am I a complete g1t for asking this of my family? whistle
In a word yes.

Sorry.
I fear that you may be right... wink


timbobalob

Original Poster:

364 posts

273 months

Monday 8th June 2009
quotequote all
mrmr96 said:
I see a lot of these types of transactions (I work in corporate finance helping people buy and sell businesss) and I have to say that I've never seen anyone willing to put a relatives house on the line to fund an acquisition. There's a reason for this.

As such my personal advice would be not to proceed with her house as security.
That's a very fair point mrmr96 - just out of interest would you see this as a complete no-goer, or do you think that there is another way that I could raise the captial?

I like to think that there is always a way...

siscar

6,887 posts

248 months

Monday 8th June 2009
quotequote all
timbobalob said:
Luckily they've got no staff, and all catering is done by an external company so salaries are an absolute minimum. The grounds are incredible and a real selling point of the venue - having mystery shopped several in the surrounding area it stands out as having the most character/charm, and also being one of the cheapest!
It's lucky in one sense but not in another. Having no staff means that when the keys get handed over you are entirely on your own reliant just on what handover you've been able to have. If you've not run such a place before there is going to be a huge learning curve.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Monday 8th June 2009
quotequote all
timbobalob said:
mrmr96 said:
I see a lot of these types of transactions (I work in corporate finance helping people buy and sell businesss) and I have to say that I've never seen anyone willing to put a relatives house on the line to fund an acquisition. There's a reason for this.

As such my personal advice would be not to proceed with her house as security.
That's a very fair point mrmr96 - just out of interest would you see this as a complete no-goer, or do you think that there is another way that I could raise the captial?

I like to think that there is always a way...
If your mum and aunt are serious and have the funds to help you out, why not make them sleeping partners from the start?

The concept and issues of going into business with family aside, rather than a one-sided favour which could go disasterously wrong, a partner or investor knows from the start they are taking a calculated risk.

I just don't think there is going to be an insurance policy that would guarantee your personal income from it. Thinking logically, if it were that easy I could just get this policy and sit on my hands!

David87M3

1,470 posts

265 months

Monday 8th June 2009
quotequote all
have you looked at the goverment loan garuntee scheme? they will garuntee upto 75% of a loan for a 2%fee

thats assuming you have a deposit.

Cheers


dave

Stitch

933 posts

248 months

Monday 8th June 2009
quotequote all
David87M3 said:
have you looked at the goverment loan garuntee scheme? they will garuntee upto 75% of a loan for a 2%fee

thats assuming you have a deposit.

Cheers


dave
Depends what you are buying - the new enterprise scheme is supposed to be used to replace existing/in place short term working capital financing with something longer term (for example - you could get a loan to replace an existing overdraft).

It is not available to be used to buy shares in a company.

timbobalob

Original Poster:

364 posts

273 months

Monday 8th June 2009
quotequote all
Thanks for all of your replies so far!

It's back to the drawing board for me now (I've written off using my grandmother's house) - I'm meeting with some banks tomorrow to see if I can finance this somehow (100% business mortgage using the property as security). It's a bit of a long shot admitedly (especially in the current climate)

If anyone has any ideas on avenues to gain backing other than going to high street banks I'm all ears! ears

Thanks again

Tim

smile

David87M3

1,470 posts

265 months

Monday 8th June 2009
quotequote all
Stitch said:
David87M3 said:
have you looked at the goverment loan garuntee scheme? they will garuntee upto 75% of a loan for a 2%fee

thats assuming you have a deposit.

Cheers


dave
Depends what you are buying - the new enterprise scheme is supposed to be used to replace existing/in place short term working capital financing with something longer term (for example - you could get a loan to replace an existing overdraft).

It is not available to be used to buy shares in a company.
I was going to use it to buy a franchise recenly but decided against the idea for various reasons, however some of the points below may have been useful.

maybe were talking about different schemes "replace existing/in place short term working capital "????????
see below


Enterprise Finance Guarantee benefits
Variable or fixed interest rates- giving you the choice you need £1,000,000 maximum loan- the minimum amount is £1,000 (£26,000 for Fixed Rate Loans) 3 month minimum term- and a maximum term of 10 years Drawdown options to suit your business- you can receive your funds in stages, to suit the cycles of your business Payment holidays- you can ask for a capital repayment holiday of up to three years. During the holiday period, interest will continue to accrue and be applied quarterly. You will be required to lodge funds to meet interest applications during the agreed capital holiday period.



Full link
http://www.natwest.com/business/borrow/loans/g1/go...

Stitch

933 posts

248 months

Tuesday 9th June 2009
quotequote all
Buying a franchise may be OK as it is not the same as buying shares.

However, the scheme is in place primarily to help businesses that are being squeezed by their banks and struggling cashflow-wise as a result. Hence, the need to demonstrate that the loan is to some extent replacing some other form of financing.

In its current form the scheme is still relatively new - every time I have spoken to a banker about it, something new has come out of the woodwork.

OP - have you considered Business Angel investment?

Murray993

1,515 posts

264 months

Wednesday 1st July 2009
quotequote all
Explain to grandma how she is holding you back, and failing you. You will never lose the house, everything will be fine.

skwdenyer

18,707 posts

271 months

Wednesday 1st July 2009
quotequote all
timbobalob said:
Thanks for all of your replies so far!

It's back to the drawing board for me now (I've written off using my grandmother's house) - I'm meeting with some banks tomorrow to see if I can finance this somehow (100% business mortgage using the property as security). It's a bit of a long shot admitedly (especially in the current climate)

If anyone has any ideas on avenues to gain backing other than going to high street banks I'm all ears! ears

Thanks again

Tim

smile
Out of interest, any updates on this? It raises some very interesting questions in the current climate.