Employment Law Covenants - can anyone advise??
Employment Law Covenants - can anyone advise??
Author
Discussion

GraemeP

Original Poster:

770 posts

260 months

Monday 29th June 2009
quotequote all
Hi all

Not sure if anyone can help, basically my good lady works as a stylist (no MX-5) at present, and wants to leave to work from home with a salon in one of our spare rooms.

Her employment contract has 2 clauses we need to work out:

1. During your employment and within six months of termination of your employment you shall not practise for payment or reward the craft for which you were employed by the Firm within half a mile radius of the place of employment specified in your Terms of Employment

The question on the above, is that we live within half a mile of the salon! Now, if Dawn wants to work from home, would her ex-employer be able to seek damages based on the above?

The other clause states that you cannot "undertake any act or permit any third party to undertake any act likley or intended to induce a customer or client to cease to patronise the business or premises of the Firm" (there were more words in there but this is the trimmed version)

The question for this one, is can my partner advertise without mentioning her old place of work without being penalised?

we are going to see a solictor, but if anyone has been through anything similar would be good to get their experience (you can also have a free re-style if you happen to visit the isle of wight!)

Thanks in advance,

Graeme P

insurance_jon

4,099 posts

277 months

Monday 29th June 2009
quotequote all
Do they know what she's doing? If it's mutual ageement you need that in writing. If it isn't get a brief.

also it's worth pointing out the council/neighbours may have issues too, especially if there isn't much parking

Dupont666

22,973 posts

223 months

Monday 29th June 2009
quotequote all
If you want some quick advise, contact richburley on here, he has helped out loads of PHers in the past with employment law...

GraemeP

Original Poster:

770 posts

260 months

Monday 29th June 2009
quotequote all
Thanks - will try and get hold of him!

No, the boss is getting the letter of resignation today wink

As for neighbours etc, it will only be sole trade operation (ie no big footfall), our neighbours one side are too far to see the house, and the other side are cool. It is all fairly good sized houses and gardens so won't be a problem - we have parking for (soon to be) clients.

Cheers!

Snapper7

990 posts

290 months

Monday 29th June 2009
quotequote all
To run a business from your home that encourages customers to come to your home needs planning consent

griffgrog

740 posts

277 months

Monday 29th June 2009
quotequote all
My understanding is that the employer has to prove that actual damages have occurred. For example, if Mrs Batty used to be a regular client of the former employer, but since starting her business she is now a client of your better half's, then damages may be awarded.

If no provable damages have occurred then I think that restrictive covenants are unenforceable.



JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Monday 29th June 2009
quotequote all
This is most likely not be able to be enforced.

For two reasons. Firstly, the restriction cannot take away someone's right to earn money. As a hairdresser, it is not something that you can easily avoid not doing. Secondly, the fact that you live within that area contravenes this.

The other issue is what they are actually going to do about it.

The first part I am 95% sure would be seen unenforceable in court.

The second part is a reference to not using a client database or using the ex-salons name in advertising, but poorly written. It is obvious that you cannot advertise whatsoever without having the advertisement visible to some old clients, so again probably unenforceable.

Therefore a court case would have little chance of winning and at best only cover their losses. However, even to get that far would cost them thousands of pounds and months, so they will just move on.


Lurking Lawyer

4,535 posts

256 months

Monday 29th June 2009
quotequote all
I've dealt with a number of this kind of restrictive covenant claims in the past and have to agree with pretty much everything Justin says above.

Even if the contract terms were enforceable (which is in itself a very moot point), the ex-employer would need to have the stomach for a fight and the willingness to pay potentially quite substantial costs to a solicitor to pursue an application for an injunction and a claim for damages.

therealpigdog

2,592 posts

228 months

Tuesday 30th June 2009
quotequote all
Lurking Lawyer said:
I've dealt with a number of this kind of restrictive covenant claims in the past and have to agree with pretty much everything Justin says above.

Even if the contract terms were enforceable (which is in itself a very moot point), the ex-employer would need to have the stomach for a fight and the willingness to pay potentially quite substantial costs to a solicitor to pursue an application for an injunction and a claim for damages.
+1

My experience basically comes down to - they are pretty much unenforcable in employment contracts unless you are taking the pi$$. Common sense will nearly always prevail.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Tuesday 30th June 2009
quotequote all
therealpigdog said:
Lurking Lawyer said:
I've dealt with a number of this kind of restrictive covenant claims in the past and have to agree with pretty much everything Justin says above.

Even if the contract terms were enforceable (which is in itself a very moot point), the ex-employer would need to have the stomach for a fight and the willingness to pay potentially quite substantial costs to a solicitor to pursue an application for an injunction and a claim for damages.
+1

My experience basically comes down to - they are pretty much unenforcable in employment contracts unless you are taking the pi$$. Common sense will nearly always prevail.
Yes, the taking the p*** level of fairness is actually exactly right.

For example, if you are a general salesperson and you are offered a job where you are the head of sales for something specific like syringes for example, and are tasked with the strategic movement of the whole department, it might be fair to say that to move to another company which specifically only sold syringes is not a 'general' employment movement but one which is specifically contrary.

TurricanII

1,516 posts

229 months

Tuesday 30th June 2009
quotequote all
In hair dressing/styling there is usually a strong bond between client and customer because in a lot of cases once you find a hairdresser you like you don't change unless s/he stops hairdressing! My missus is a stylist and it seems to be accepted that if a stylist joins/leaves the salon then their core customers go with the stylist. Not sure if that's worth anything in court!!!

Brown and Boris

11,838 posts

266 months

Wednesday 1st July 2009
quotequote all
I wonder if we would take the same view if it was one of our employees leaving and taking customers s/he chooses with them to work from home just around the corner in a business where convenience of location is one of the key drivers. And then promoting their new business to our customers while in our pay?

I know we are only answering the original question, and expectations in hairdressing might be that loyal customers follow the stylist but I am guessing the second covenant is there to stop her handing out her business cards to clients as they have their hair done. I think any business owner would fume at the prospect of an employee setting up shop to take some of their business and using the goodwill built up in their time/business to promote the new business. I am guessing the salon owner also has a mortage to pay and mouths to feed.

Both covenants sound reasonable to me and pretty standard, if not generous (I have seen much larger exclusion zones), not withstanding that a small salon isn't equipped to take any action. If you rack them off enough they may be willing to throw good money at stopping the new business.

Don't upset the neighbours because I suspect to make a living you will need 4+ visitors a day but you may find the council find out pretty quickly what you ae doing from home once the salon owner finds out.

GraemeP

Original Poster:

770 posts

260 months

Wednesday 1st July 2009
quotequote all
All

Thanks for the responses / inputs. I think as my partner is currently only part time (3 days per week) and would only like to have enough clientel for the same at home we should be able to avoid anything getting stupid!

Equally she has worked for the same boss for 17 years, and pretty much managed the shop on the days she does work (as the staff come to her for pretty much everything.

Interested to hear more about the planning consent bit? If we don't change anything in the house surely it is just about having public liability insurance and adjusting our home insurance??

What a great wealth of intellect / supportive people we have on PH - thanks again!

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Wednesday 1st July 2009
quotequote all
Brown and Boris said:
I wonder if we would take the same view if it was one of our employees leaving and taking customers s/he chooses with them to work from home just around the corner in a business where convenience of location is one of the key drivers. And then promoting their new business to our customers while in our pay?

I know we are only answering the original question, and expectations in hairdressing might be that loyal customers follow the stylist but I am guessing the second covenant is there to stop her handing out her business cards to clients as they have their hair done. I think any business owner would fume at the prospect of an employee setting up shop to take some of their business and using the goodwill built up in their time/business to promote the new business. I am guessing the salon owner also has a mortage to pay and mouths to feed.

Both covenants sound reasonable to me and pretty standard, if not generous (I have seen much larger exclusion zones), not withstanding that a small salon isn't equipped to take any action. If you rack them off enough they may be willing to throw good money at stopping the new business.

Don't upset the neighbours because I suspect to make a living you will need 4+ visitors a day but you may find the council find out pretty quickly what you ae doing from home once the salon owner finds out.
To be fair, the sector you are in is quite a niche and would expect a stipulation to be in place in your contracts, and you would have a lot more chance actually claiming damages.

If you had a salesperson or developer leave and start up their own business doing the same niche thing, that is not their right to put food on the table, they are obviously using their position to leverage the opportunity. The salesperson could work in anything anywhere which was not sales related to your niche. The developer could develop anything they wanted, just not something in your niche.

If you are a hair stylist however, that is not exactly a niche, you are trained to cut hair, thats it. Therefore denying an employee the opportunity to do exactly what they are trained for, a quite common occupation, or to even become self employed is just totally unfair.

I could understand if the OP's other half was setting up a company with employees next door, that would be against they spirit of what was understood. All she wants to do is be self employed which is her right.

GraemeP

Original Poster:

770 posts

260 months

Saturday 4th July 2009
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
Brown and Boris said:
I wonder if we would take the same view if it was one of our employees leaving and taking customers s/he chooses with them to work from home just around the corner in a business where convenience of location is one of the key drivers. And then promoting their new business to our customers while in our pay?

I know we are only answering the original question, and expectations in hairdressing might be that loyal customers follow the stylist but I am guessing the second covenant is there to stop her handing out her business cards to clients as they have their hair done. I think any business owner would fume at the prospect of an employee setting up shop to take some of their business and using the goodwill built up in their time/business to promote the new business. I am guessing the salon owner also has a mortage to pay and mouths to feed.

Both covenants sound reasonable to me and pretty standard, if not generous (I have seen much larger exclusion zones), not withstanding that a small salon isn't equipped to take any action. If you rack them off enough they may be willing to throw good money at stopping the new business.

Don't upset the neighbours because I suspect to make a living you will need 4+ visitors a day but you may find the council find out pretty quickly what you ae doing from home once the salon owner finds out.
To be fair, the sector you are in is quite a niche and would expect a stipulation to be in place in your contracts, and you would have a lot more chance actually claiming damages.

If you had a salesperson or developer leave and start up their own business doing the same niche thing, that is not their right to put food on the table, they are obviously using their position to leverage the opportunity. The salesperson could work in anything anywhere which was not sales related to your niche. The developer could develop anything they wanted, just not something in your niche.

If you are a hair stylist however, that is not exactly a niche, you are trained to cut hair, thats it. Therefore denying an employee the opportunity to do exactly what they are trained for, a quite common occupation, or to even become self employed is just totally unfair.

I could understand if the OP's other half was setting up a company with employees next door, that would be against they spirit of what was understood. All she wants to do is be self employed which is her right.
All

The solicitor advised that the 0.5 miles for 6 month is absolute, and as it is deemed to be reasonable COULD see the exployer win damages in court (should she decide to undertake a court case). This is ok for us, as I think it will take us a good 3-4 months to get everything in place at home to an acceptable level (and teach my partner how to use a netbook and Paypal for card holding clients!).

The advertising bit is a lot more grey, but we are going to proceed with "general" advertising, and no direct marketing to clients (but if they ask the question when they bump into my partner, she will give them the opportunity to keep using her).

A related question - would Dawn get better advantage from a limited company, or being a sole trader?