Any Patent Experts
Discussion
I'm confronted with a perplexing and very frustrating problem in that I invented something whilst at University roughly 8 years ago. I detailed the invention in my Master's dissertation as an appendix and the University have stated in writing that they recognise the IP for the invention is solely mine, so that is clear.
Where the confusion arises is that a group in the USA have now announced something virtually identical and are being widely lauded for it by the international media. It looks like what is in fact my invention from years ago is going to make them a great deal of money, by which I mean potentially tens or hundreds of millions. Of course, they have a patent in the US at least I'm sure.
I would like to investigate whether my documented design counts as prior art in the USA or elsewhere. Initial investigations suggest that it must have been included in a printed publication but I am unclear as to whether my dissertation meets this requirement. Further, I did also present my dissertation to a review panel of three University lecturers, plus my tutor, and a random assortment of students.
Could anyone advise please?
Where the confusion arises is that a group in the USA have now announced something virtually identical and are being widely lauded for it by the international media. It looks like what is in fact my invention from years ago is going to make them a great deal of money, by which I mean potentially tens or hundreds of millions. Of course, they have a patent in the US at least I'm sure.
I would like to investigate whether my documented design counts as prior art in the USA or elsewhere. Initial investigations suggest that it must have been included in a printed publication but I am unclear as to whether my dissertation meets this requirement. Further, I did also present my dissertation to a review panel of three University lecturers, plus my tutor, and a random assortment of students.
Could anyone advise please?
roadsweeper said:
I would like to investigate whether my documented design counts as prior art in the USA or elsewhere. Initial investigations suggest that it must have been included in a printed publication but I am unclear as to whether my dissertation meets this requirement. Further, I did also present my dissertation to a review panel of three University lecturers, plus my tutor, and a random assortment of students.
Could anyone advise please?
For a US patent to be valid it has to be novel Worldwide, as such if information which was made available to the public demonstrated such an invention, it will be invalid.Could anyone advise please?
Your presentation was behind closed doors, so is unlikely to count. Your dissertation if it not just disclosed the invention, but disclosed it in such as fashion that someone with skill in the same field would be "enabled" to put it into practise (there is a difference there), again, the patent may not be valid.
If there are differences, however trite, the patent may still be valid.
Quite why this helps you, I do not know. Invalidating a US patent will not suddenly grant you riches, nor any claim as to any commercial success such a company may have, so what's your motive here? Any formal action you may wish to take will cost you in excess of I would estimate £400 per hour, + VAT. So what are you hoping to gain?
Unless your disclosure was confidential (it seems unlikely given the nature of the disclosure and audience, but don't know really about the status of such presentations and it may be difficult to prove one way or the other) then it should count as prior art. This assumes that they didn't file their patent before you did your dissertation - in which case it won't form prior art.
Does the uni library or your supervisor get a copy of your dissertation for reference by future students? Did you distribute handouts at the presentation? Does anyone else have a copy of your dissertation? These could also form prior art against a later filed patent.
As noted above, although you may have knock out prior art the value to you personally is minimal unless you want to knock out their patent and compete with them - blackmailing them really isn't a sensible option! Also, their patent may cover an improvement or modification to the process which may not be disclosed in your project and so their patent may be valid.
If you are interested you can try looking for their patent (or patent application) here: http://ep.espacenet.com/advancedSearch?locale=en_E...
Alex
Does the uni library or your supervisor get a copy of your dissertation for reference by future students? Did you distribute handouts at the presentation? Does anyone else have a copy of your dissertation? These could also form prior art against a later filed patent.
As noted above, although you may have knock out prior art the value to you personally is minimal unless you want to knock out their patent and compete with them - blackmailing them really isn't a sensible option! Also, their patent may cover an improvement or modification to the process which may not be disclosed in your project and so their patent may be valid.
If you are interested you can try looking for their patent (or patent application) here: http://ep.espacenet.com/advancedSearch?locale=en_E...
Alex
DonkeyKong said:
For a US patent to be valid it has to be novel Worldwide, as such if information which was made available to the public demonstrated such an invention, it will be invalid.
Your presentation was behind closed doors, so is unlikely to count. Your dissertation if it not just disclosed the invention, but disclosed it in such as fashion that someone with skill in the same field would be "enabled" to put it into practise (there is a difference there), again, the patent may not be valid.
If there are differences, however trite, the patent may still be valid.
Quite why this helps you, I do not know. Invalidating a US patent will not suddenly grant you riches, nor any claim as to any commercial success such a company may have, so what's your motive here? Any formal action you may wish to take will cost you in excess of I would estimate £400 per hour, + VAT. So what are you hoping to gain?
If my dissertation constituted prior art and could invalidate a patent held by a company then it would be in that company's interest to reach an agreement with me whereby I would agree not to invalidate the patent in return for, say, royalties on sales of what is, in fact, my fully-documented invention preceding their patent by some 8 years. In a nutshell, that is what I see as the potential gain here. Is that kind of approach common practice - I had imagined it was quite standard?Your presentation was behind closed doors, so is unlikely to count. Your dissertation if it not just disclosed the invention, but disclosed it in such as fashion that someone with skill in the same field would be "enabled" to put it into practise (there is a difference there), again, the patent may not be valid.
If there are differences, however trite, the patent may still be valid.
Quite why this helps you, I do not know. Invalidating a US patent will not suddenly grant you riches, nor any claim as to any commercial success such a company may have, so what's your motive here? Any formal action you may wish to take will cost you in excess of I would estimate £400 per hour, + VAT. So what are you hoping to gain?
AlexB said:
Unless your disclosure was confidential (it seems unlikely given the nature of the disclosure and audience, but don't know really about the status of such presentations and it may be difficult to prove one way or the other) then it should count as prior art. This assumes that they didn't file their patent before you did your dissertation - in which case it won't form prior art.
Does the uni library or your supervisor get a copy of your dissertation for reference by future students? Did you distribute handouts at the presentation? Does anyone else have a copy of your dissertation? These could also form prior art against a later filed patent.
As noted above, although you may have knock out prior art the value to you personally is minimal unless you want to knock out their patent and compete with them - blackmailing them really isn't a sensible option! Also, their patent may cover an improvement or modification to the process which may not be disclosed in your project and so their patent may be valid.
If you are interested you can try looking for their patent (or patent application) here: http://ep.espacenet.com/advancedSearch?locale=en_E...
Alex
The presentation was not confidential - anyone could walk in and indeed a significant number of students from my department attended. My presentation and dissertation pre-dates their patent by roughly 8 years.Does the uni library or your supervisor get a copy of your dissertation for reference by future students? Did you distribute handouts at the presentation? Does anyone else have a copy of your dissertation? These could also form prior art against a later filed patent.
As noted above, although you may have knock out prior art the value to you personally is minimal unless you want to knock out their patent and compete with them - blackmailing them really isn't a sensible option! Also, their patent may cover an improvement or modification to the process which may not be disclosed in your project and so their patent may be valid.
If you are interested you can try looking for their patent (or patent application) here: http://ep.espacenet.com/advancedSearch?locale=en_E...
Alex
My project professor still has a copy of my dissertation but, as far as I know at the moment, the only other paper copy is with me.
As stated in my previous post, the only financial gain for me would be some kind of royalty arrangement but I don't see that as being blackmail at all - it's just sensible business practice as far as I'm concerned.
It may well turn out to be that the only thing I can do is at least get some kind of recognition as the original inventor as it was, I'll admit, painful to see these guys being touted as the next big thing and 'geniuses' when in fact the invention was thought-up and documented by me in an academic document years before.
stuthemong said:
You may have a lot more joy if you offer 50% IP to your uni if they are williing to help fight for royalties. You can't afford to alone.
I fully intend to offer them a percentage in fact, but I do have significant financial means as I own a company so going alone (in terms of pursuing royalties) may be an option. At this stage though, I really want to see if I may have a case or not.What steps did you take to protect your idea eight years ago?
Someone commercialising a similar idea to yours may not give you automatic rights to challenge any patent they hold - rational product devlopment means that people come up with similar ideas to solve similar problems all the time, it's who protects these ideas that have the advantage.
Someone commercialising a similar idea to yours may not give you automatic rights to challenge any patent they hold - rational product devlopment means that people come up with similar ideas to solve similar problems all the time, it's who protects these ideas that have the advantage.
Windsorphil said:
What steps did you take to protect your idea eight years ago?
Someone commercialising a similar idea to yours may not give you automatic rights to challenge any patent they hold - rational product devlopment means that people come up with similar ideas to solve similar problems all the time, it's who protects these ideas that have the advantage.
Apart from posting the design to myself via recorded delivery (something I was told at the time would be of value but now believe to be of little value) I didn't protect the idea. There are several reasons for this:Someone commercialising a similar idea to yours may not give you automatic rights to challenge any patent they hold - rational product devlopment means that people come up with similar ideas to solve similar problems all the time, it's who protects these ideas that have the advantage.
1. My University tutor told me the idea was not practical. As a world-leader in a related area I assumed he was correct.
2. Despite point 1, I still believed the idea could work so I included it in my dissertation thinking that as it was formally documented I would have some kind of protection.
3. Because of point 2, I thought the University would claim the IP but they have stated it is in fact mine.
4. I also included another invention in my appendix which I actually thought had greater potential. I did discuss doing a PhD on this second invention with my professor but it came to nothing in the end.
5. I was a student inexperienced when it came to patents, prior art, etc.
roadsweeper said:
Windsorphil said:
What steps did you take to protect your idea eight years ago?
Someone commercialising a similar idea to yours may not give you automatic rights to challenge any patent they hold - rational product devlopment means that people come up with similar ideas to solve similar problems all the time, it's who protects these ideas that have the advantage.
Apart from posting the design to myself via recorded delivery (something I was told at the time would be of value but now believe to be of little value) I didn't protect the idea. There are several reasons for this:Someone commercialising a similar idea to yours may not give you automatic rights to challenge any patent they hold - rational product devlopment means that people come up with similar ideas to solve similar problems all the time, it's who protects these ideas that have the advantage.
1. My University tutor told me the idea was not practical. As a world-leader in a related area I assumed he was correct.
2. Despite point 1, I still believed the idea could work so I included it in my dissertation thinking that as it was formally documented I would have some kind of protection.
3. Because of point 2, I thought the University would claim the IP but they have stated it is in fact mine.
4. I also included another invention in my appendix which I actually thought had greater potential. I did discuss doing a PhD on this second invention with my professor but it came to nothing in the end.
5. I was a student inexperienced when it came to patents, prior art, etc.
The problem with all of this though is that if these US guys did there job properly they will have done a patent/IP check and not turned up anything relating to your invention, so legally they will most likely have follwed the correct protocal, which in turn makes your case harder.
If you ndecide to speak to a specialits send me a PM and i can refer you to a company that has done work for some of my clients and have always proven to be very good
You think this patent is worth tens or hundreds of millions.
The company in the states you speak of will then have value in spending up to a few million defending against you - can you stump up that level of cash?
I'd say that any approach to them coming via a university will be a lot more scary than an approach by an individual, even if that individual has the means to fight on some level, a university will surely have much larger reserves, unless you are doing very very well indeed and this is a point of principle for you.
Stu
The company in the states you speak of will then have value in spending up to a few million defending against you - can you stump up that level of cash?
I'd say that any approach to them coming via a university will be a lot more scary than an approach by an individual, even if that individual has the means to fight on some level, a university will surely have much larger reserves, unless you are doing very very well indeed and this is a point of principle for you.
Stu
RJDM3 said:
I think without your IP being registered somewhere it will make the case more difficult. But as you can show a paper trail predating the US company this will be the difference between winning some kind of recognition or financial gain. That said i believe that if you speak to a specialist IP lawyer you will have a case of sorts, even if that only means recognition for your invention.
The problem with all of this though is that if these US guys did there job properly they will have done a patent/IP check and not turned up anything relating to your invention, so legally they will most likely have follwed the correct protocal, which in turn makes your case harder.
If you ndecide to speak to a specialits send me a PM and i can refer you to a company that has done work for some of my clients and have always proven to be very good
It would at least be nice to have some kind of recognition. The problem with all of this though is that if these US guys did there job properly they will have done a patent/IP check and not turned up anything relating to your invention, so legally they will most likely have follwed the correct protocal, which in turn makes your case harder.
If you ndecide to speak to a specialits send me a PM and i can refer you to a company that has done work for some of my clients and have always proven to be very good

I will give your comments some though - thanks for taking the time to post.
Edited by roadsweeper on Friday 3rd July 19:12
stuthemong said:
You think this patent is worth tens or hundreds of millions.
The company in the states you speak of will then have value in spending up to a few million defending against you - can you stump up that level of cash?
I'd say that any approach to them coming via a university will be a lot more scary than an approach by an individual, even if that individual has the means to fight on some level, a university will surely have much larger reserves, unless you are doing very very well indeed and this is a point of principle for you.
Stu
Put it this way, the US military, Navy and several major international organisations are all getting involved. Even a single application in which it can be used and selling to only a single company could generate recurring sales of millions of dollars.The company in the states you speak of will then have value in spending up to a few million defending against you - can you stump up that level of cash?
I'd say that any approach to them coming via a university will be a lot more scary than an approach by an individual, even if that individual has the means to fight on some level, a university will surely have much larger reserves, unless you are doing very very well indeed and this is a point of principle for you.
Stu
I take your point regarding actions potentially costing millions and I don't have that kind of money to put behind something that would be quite risky.
I may consider going to my University to see what they have to say. The team that have re-invented my idea are from another University and mine might have some issue with them getting the international recognition for this I suppose.
Interestingly, I do have an idea, though just at the germination stage at the moment, which may achieve the same end result but at lower cost and with greater reliability. It's obvious enough (to me) that I fear they will already have thought of it but just in case I think I'll look into patenting that now!
The really irritating issue about all of this is that I was incredibly excited when I invented this thing - I really believed I was on to something. However, I let my tutor's negative comments affect me and, despite never quite giving it up, I didn't pursue it as I now know I should have done. Ultimately, I have nobody to blame but myself I suppose.
In fact, as I write this, I recall there was another application for my second invention (on which I nearly did the PhD) and I don't think it's out there either! I'm getting excited again!
The really irritating issue about all of this is that I was incredibly excited when I invented this thing - I really believed I was on to something. However, I let my tutor's negative comments affect me and, despite never quite giving it up, I didn't pursue it as I now know I should have done. Ultimately, I have nobody to blame but myself I suppose.
In fact, as I write this, I recall there was another application for my second invention (on which I nearly did the PhD) and I don't think it's out there either! I'm getting excited again!

roadsweeper said:
Interestingly, I do have an idea, though just at the germination stage at the moment, which may achieve the same end result but at lower cost and with greater reliability. It's obvious enough (to me) that I fear they will already have thought of it but just in case I think I'll look into patenting that now!
Oh joy, it was patented in 2004. 

It seems the patent for my invention is pending, not actually granted. Apparently, if someone else submits a patent during this process or before a year has passed after the patent was granted it is classed as, "interference." Does this alter my position at all?
I think I'm going to have to take professional advice...
I think I'm going to have to take professional advice...
roadsweeper said:
It seems the patent for my invention is pending, not actually granted. Apparently, if someone else submits a patent during this process or before a year has passed after the patent was granted it is classed as, "interference." Does this alter my position at all?
I think I'm going to have to take professional advice...
The US works on a first to invent system and if there are conflicting claims to an invention (the situation you suggest above) than an interference can be instigated - both parties will then have the chance to provide evidence of their date of creation - However, a long delay (more than a year or so) can be considered as not being diligent in trying to protect your invention and I believe in such circumstances the system can revert to a first to file like in the rest of the world.I think I'm going to have to take professional advice...
However, you already admit that you disclosed your invention publicly 8 years ago so you will not be able to obtain a valid patent and would not be able to get a patent granted without committing fraud at the US Patent Office (you have to disclose all publications that might be important).
If you go ahead and contact them there is a problem - due to the duty of disclosure the company have to submit any relevant document to the USPTO when they become aware of it - in order for you to evidence your claim you would have to provide a copy of the disclosure to them and they would not be able to keep that secret....so any damage would be done and there would be no need for them to pay.
The option of a competitor who is being kept out of the market by the patent may be better as some companies, if they really want to break a patent, are prepared to pay reasonable money in order to be informed of invalidating prior art - it is also likely that you would need to be deposed for any court case and you can charge a consultancy rate for that.
Good Luck!
Alex
roadsweeper said:
If my dissertation constituted prior art and could invalidate a patent held by a company then it would be in that company's interest to reach an agreement with me whereby I would agree not to invalidate the patent in return for, say, royalties on sales of what is, in fact, my fully-documented invention preceding their patent by some 8 years. In a nutshell, that is what I see as the potential gain here. Is that kind of approach common practice - I had imagined it was quite standard?
Is this kind of approach common practise? Yes, of course. Frequently small companies or independents believe they have the first move and wish to seek all manner of things- recompense, recognition, outright hell-bent retribution. Business to business even more so- the most litigated patent in the World is Viagra, because others are effectively suffering from Pfizer's commercial success, and they want a slice of it. The problem is as civil law, pursing matters will be expensive, particularly given the need for experts and the language barrier (and I’m not joking- I’m a part-qualified UK/ European Attorney, patents are written differently here to US ones, how you read the words will be different to how a US court interprets the patent I can 99.9% guarantee). This puts most people off. You may not be in the same position.
To get a reasonable indication of whether your disclosures would anticipate the patent as filed, you are realistically looking at costs of somewhere between £1,500- £10,000. No-one will give you a detailed opinion for free, the work involved is simply too great unless the matter is completely straightforward. If you go to www.cipa.org and find an attorney close to you, you will most likely get a free 30- 60 minutes, perhaps a little more if the extra work is trivial, meritous or they’re quiet, but whoever you speak to in this country is extremely likely to be reliant on US attorneys based IN the US to make final decisions, which inevitably cost, so any free opinion during that 30- 60 minute slot will be limited in value, most likely inconclusive. But it should give you an indication of whether or not it is worth putting some money in to this.
That way if it appears you have a case, something can be put to the company suggesting a problem. Experience tells me in the main either no response is received, or something with no detail and a straightforward rebuttal would return. Why? As having advised clients on the receiving end of such matters, you never want to show your full hand from the off- you just don’t need to, and nor are you obliged at this stage. Heels will be dragged, calls will not be quickly returned.
After all what’s next for a claimant or attacker? In this case perhaps sending your prior art to the USPTO (given this is pre-grant by the sound of it), which they may or may not accept, which they may or may not either offer you the chance to challenge the patent directly (it’s called revocation, interference is unlikely to be relevant, it exists between either an existing application and (your own) new application- which does not sound feasible given the dates you may have disclosed information, you get a 12 month window to publicly use your invention before filing an application in the US, not 8 years). They can challenge the patent of their own initiative, but may put it down to you. And if it’s invalidated, the company theoretically loses (see below), but you may not be able to gain. If there is no patent, just publicly available information- including of course the patent application as filed, anyone can play.
As a broad indication cost-wise you’re looking at upwards of £1M in general terms for a UK revocation action for a single UK patent if it goes to court and you have Attorneys, Solicitors and Barristers involved. Add a fluctuating exchange rate and a knowledgeable firm defending, you could double or triple that- especially if you lose and have to cover the defendant’s costs. Patents can be partially revoked- limiting the impact of your earlier work, or (limited) changes can be made to patents to keep them alive, rendering your previous work irrelevant. Once a patent is granted presumptions are usually in favour of a patentee. As such there is never such a thing as a 50:50 case in patent law, in the US this even firmer than in the UK/ Europe. Moreover even if a patent is revoked, the patentee can appeal. More time, more cost, more uncertainty.
Add to that the international dimension and risks it brings- many, many cases fall here because of simple admin errors, or procedural deficiencies. Given the reliance on two companies working together you magnify that risk.
Separately the patent may be useful, but may not be the definitive reason for the company’s market position, they may simply have used it as a “first mover” advantage, so they may not be bothered about defending it. You just don’t know. It may cost you significantly to find out. They may have used the patent as a basis for other works they do, you would be amazed at how few patents are used- but there is no requirement to do so, the right you get is a negative one, to stop other people using the claims that you have described. Unlike other IP, there is no obligation to use a patent, all you have to do post grant is keep up the renewal fees, and you have protection. Others cannot use without your say so. Unless of course (noting again this is civil law) others do use it, and a patent owner cannot afford to defend it. I have in fact got a bag of grit as my footrest right now, which claims on it to be a “patented formula”. The patent as filed lists a specific range of grit sizes for use in a particular method, this grit falls outside that range. I’m trying to revoke two European and one UK patent based on this technology, the grit is an irritant [sic] as it forms no part of any argument I can make against the patents… Trading standards may wish to consider misleading statements, but commercial matters cut no ice with the IPO or EPO. But it goes to show, the patents are used for marketing, not necessarily for actual use. They don’t have to be.
On the basis of experience I am pretty confident that you could risk spending a non-trivial sum of money to accurately determine your position, at which point you may not want to take things further. Many, many cases result in a company (sometimes even both sides) being bankrupted as a result of determination over common sense. That having been said you indicate you have deep pockets, and if you have a good case, you may find the patentee does offer settlement (either lump sum or royalty), to avoid the potential pain…
Either way, I wish you good luck. It’ll be interesting if you can keep your progress updated here.
Edited for being a muppet, sorry!
Edited by DonkeyKong on Monday 6th July 16:29
Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


