Growth Securities Ownership Plan
Growth Securities Ownership Plan
Author
Discussion

x5x3

Original Poster:

2,437 posts

284 months

Monday 6th July 2009
quotequote all
apparently (according to the Times) this is a scheme being touted by Grant Thornton for turning 40%/50% income tax liable income into 18% CGT income - anyone know anything about it?

Mx_Stu

837 posts

254 months

Monday 6th July 2009
quotequote all
Yep - Growth shares have been around for a fair while but only since the introduction of the 18% CGT rate more listed companies (and companies who would otherwise find it hard to create a new class of share) have started to use jointly owned shares.

In a nutshell (and by no means comprehensive advice on the subject)

Growth shares - Valuation of the company is undertaken now. A new class of shares is created to share in future income (i.e. dividends and/or capital on a sale) only if the whole company value grows above todays value plus X%. The X% is the key bit as you need to be able to justify to HMRC* that anything above the whole company value plus X% is going to be difficult to achieve and as such the shares have minimal value now (typically par value). As the shares have minimal value the individual can usually buy them for minimal outlay then as the company increases in value he can sell them and the whole gain will be at 18% (plus the benefit of the annual allowance)

Jointly Owned shares - Similar concept but a trust and an individual jointly own the share (albeit the individual only pays a tiny amount to acquire his share). The agreements are then usually structured so that the trust only wants the first X% from any future gain leaving the rest of the gain to accure to the individual, once again taxable as a capital gain.

I used to work advising and implementing employee shares schemes but am now more concerned with valuations (specifically tax valuations) so might be a touch rusty on some of the new tweaks that have no doubt been incorporated.

  • HMRC are smart on growth shares so the valuation element can be tricky and the X% can be different for every company, there is no set formula.
Edited by Mx_Stu on Monday 6th July 15:10

x5x3

Original Poster:

2,437 posts

284 months

Monday 6th July 2009
quotequote all
thanks for that - so not entirely new then, wonder what twist Grant Thornton have put on it then?

Mx_Stu

837 posts

254 months

Monday 6th July 2009
quotequote all
I've just been speaking to an ex colleague about this. Whilst the above are schemes that have been around a whil and have gone unchallenged it appears that gt has come up with something entirely different (but named it similar)

Apparently the gt plan works by allowing an individual to swap a bonus for a contract for a bonus. As this is an asset they then claim cgt treatment on the gain. The general concensus is that it simply won't work and hmrc will close it down asap. That being said it probably will run until the pre budget and then legislation will be put in place.

Stu

ps apologies if the above doesn't make sense or contains spelling mistakes, im typing on my phone.

x5x3

Original Poster:

2,437 posts

284 months

Monday 6th July 2009
quotequote all
thanks - makes sense to me - my interest comes from the fact that I will be back running my own company soon and am fed up with paying so much tax, I want to make sure all my hard work is rewarded by 18% CGT and not upper rate tax bands this time - that is assuming we are still allowed to "plan" our tax affairs :-)

Mx_Stu

837 posts

254 months

Monday 6th July 2009
quotequote all
The sooner you start giving the consideration to planning the better. I personally dont think the CGT rate can remain as low as it currently is for much longer, especially with the current state of the public finances.

x5x3

Original Poster:

2,437 posts

284 months

Monday 6th July 2009
quotequote all
I know what you mean - the Government just never seem to think ahead and issue policies and laws with no thought as to how people will react - or even how it will drive their behaviour.

There again, unless they raise it from 18% to 40% then I cannot see it raising enough money to get them out of debt, they are in so deep, but there again if they did raise it then it would just change people's behaviour once again.

flyingjase

3,095 posts

262 months

Monday 6th July 2009
quotequote all
I'm meeting GT next week to discuss exactly this

Having worked with GT for the last 5 years I have found them very conservative when it comes to tax planning, so I'd be very surprised if they haven't thought this through in a lot of detail.

There are loads of schemes on the market but this seems to have the right balance of saving tax to not taking the complete piss

Regarding the above thread (swapping bonus for a contract for a bonus), remember for this to work you must take on risk, so it's possible that you would never qualify for the GSOP bonus.

x5x3

Original Poster:

2,437 posts

284 months

Monday 6th July 2009
quotequote all
would be interested to hear what you find out - appreciate you may be under NDA

Mx_Stu

837 posts

254 months

Tuesday 7th July 2009
quotequote all
flyingjase said:
Having worked with GT for the last 5 years I have found them very conservative when it comes to tax planning, so I'd be very surprised if they haven't thought this through in a lot of detail.
I don't doubt they would have thought it through, however I dont think the government (and HMRC who are under massive pressure to increase yields) will play fair on it:

"We are well aware of this aggressive avoidance scheme and we're looking at it closely," said the permanent secretary for tax, Dave Hartnett.

"If it works technically, then we will go to ministers to ask that the law is amended so that everyone pays their fair share of tax".

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/8136458.stm



x5x3

Original Poster:

2,437 posts

284 months

Tuesday 7th July 2009
quotequote all
to be honest about all this - I will probably split the share ownership between myself and wife (she will have a real and active but not key involvement), take a reasonable income (i.e. under 40% threshold), avoid dividends (avoid IR35/S660 interest from HMRC), if need more cash then take out a mortgage, then sell shares after 2-3 years and get 18% tax.

Clearly this is the behaviour the Government is keen to encourage so who am I to say otherwise.

flyingjase

3,095 posts

262 months

Tuesday 7th July 2009
quotequote all
x5x3 said:
to be honest about all this - I will probably split the share ownership between myself and wife (she will have a real and active but not key involvement), take a reasonable income (i.e. under 40% threshold), avoid dividends (avoid IR35/S660 interest from HMRC), if need more cash then take out a mortgage, then sell shares after 2-3 years and get 18% tax.

Clearly this is the behaviour the Government is keen to encourage so who am I to say otherwise.
Nothing wrong with taking Dividends if you wife geniunely has a role in the business, if not then that is income shifting which has just been through the courts, court of appeal and the House of Lords! HMRC lost in the Lords, so still ok for now!

IR35 is a whole different can of worms which seems to be fading fast.

Mx_Stu said:
flyingjase said:
Having worked with GT for the last 5 years I have found them very conservative when it comes to tax planning, so I'd be very surprised if they haven't thought this through in a lot of detail.
I don't doubt they would have thought it through, however I dont think the government (and HMRC who are under massive pressure to increase yields) will play fair on it:

"We are well aware of this aggressive avoidance scheme and we're looking at it closely," said the permanent secretary for tax, Dave Hartnett.

"If it works technically, then we will go to ministers to ask that the law is amended so that everyone pays their fair share of tax".

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/8136458.stm
Agree completely - HMRC will do whatever they can to stop any kind of tax reduction. They however have limited resources and have to prioritise which schemes they go after first.

The lend and forget schemes, which have become increasingly common and mainstream are easier targets. Also the standard of some of the companies offering these schemes leads me to believe that the paper trail would not stand up to a closer inspection by HMRC.

No doubt GSOP will also have a limited shelf life, however it stands up to current legislation, therefore whilst it's legal and above board why not do it?

Obviously if you are happy paying 50% tax, then nobody is stopping you do that either!!