08 passat vs 08 mondeo?
Author
Discussion

labrit

Original Poster:

321 posts

214 months

Thursday 9th July 2009
quotequote all
Which one has had better reviews?

Which one is more reliable?

Looking for some input as i am about to buy one this week.

Thanks!

AKA8

1,849 posts

258 months

Thursday 9th July 2009
quotequote all
I've only driven rental Mondeos with 140 bhp diesel in titanium spec and the body control was appalling. Feels slightly more plush somehow though

mattman73

16 posts

213 months

Thursday 9th July 2009
quotequote all
depends what sort of thing you are after, but IMO the passat everytime.
Not only does it look a lot better, its does have a slightly better image and will retain its value a lot better than the mondingo when you've finished with it. Build quality is superb as is the rear leg room.
I'm a little bit biased having just purchased an 06 passat sport tdi, but having already completed over 700 miles in a week I'm more than impressed - just watch out for tyre noise at 40mph if it has continental tyres fitted.

Only thing to consider is if you need a hatch back or not - you don't state in the question - as that could be a bit of a problem on the passat unless you get an estate!


missing the VR6

2,540 posts

220 months

Thursday 9th July 2009
quotequote all
To be honest I'm a die hard Dub fan but as far as reviews go the Mondeo absolutely walks the floor with the Passat, if memory serves it came 3rd in European car of the year and every mag I can think of place's it top rep mobile type car. With regards residuals any rep mobile, like Vectra, Laguna, Passat and Mondeo residuals will be awful, don't believe the VW residual hype on Passats. All those cars are mass produced for the fleet sector and as a consequence they're discounted heavily to fleet buyers and that kills residuals. The only car's in that sector without going prestige which do ok on residuals are the Accord and Mazda6.
I'm sure the Passat is a lovely car, and I'd probably buy one over a Mondeo, but having driven a few Mondeo's I'd find it hard to believe the Passat is the better car.

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Thursday 9th July 2009
quotequote all
The mondeo drives better and is bigger inside, the passat is built to a higher standard and imo has better engines. Both are good cars, not a lot between them.


whitefto

37 posts

231 months

Friday 10th July 2009
quotequote all
vw everytime owned a mondeo tdci hatchback handled like a boat and has very expensive issues such as clutch,injectors fail,rear bushes made out of playdo just cheaply made.saying that tho older bro has a st tdci looks the part with the fancy recaro interior but is still a poo ford

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Friday 10th July 2009
quotequote all
whitefto said:
vw everytime owned a mondeo tdci hatchback handled like a boat and has very expensive issues such as clutch,injectors fail,rear bushes made out of playdo just cheaply made.saying that tho older bro has a st tdci looks the part with the fancy recaro interior but is still a poo ford
yeah that was probably an old shape mondeo, which shares 0 parts with the new model

whitefto

37 posts

231 months

Friday 10th July 2009
quotequote all
still poo because its a ford cheap rubbish

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Friday 10th July 2009
quotequote all
whitefto said:
still poo because its a ford cheap rubbish
rofl

Come on, you can't be serious with that comment. As much as I am a a loyal VW fan, I can still see the latest Mondeo is a good car.

whitefto

37 posts

231 months

Friday 10th July 2009
quotequote all
good if your a rep and want to be a sheep everyone has them there boring and will prob rust just like the older version least a vw is built too a high standard which ford can never achieve and will never achieve

stewies_minion

1,167 posts

218 months

Friday 10th July 2009
quotequote all
I've driven a few of that age Mondeos. The diesel manual.

I own an older Passat and consider myself a true VW fan.

I have driven a few of this shape Passat. A vile 1.9 manual and a pleasant 2.0 DSG.

To drive the Mondeo is better all the way. I dare say the Ford auto is rubbish though so if it's an auto I'd go VW every time.
If it wasn't my own money I'd almost certainly pick the Ford. If it was my own money if would still be the VW.

ClintonB

5,079 posts

244 months

Friday 10th July 2009
quotequote all
whitefto said:
still poo because its a ford cheap rubbish
Such eloquent language to match an opinion of stunning intellectual clarity.rolleyes


Neither the Mondeo or Passat are ever going to get the juices flowing but both are thoroughly decent family barges with their good & bad points.

I'm no Fordista but I've had one (not a Mondeo) for a couple of years and it's been fine & reliable in 50k of hard driven miles. One non-mechanical fault (apart from those I've inflicted, which would have happened with any car/marque) in that time is hardly in line with cheap rubbish, now is it?

whitefto

37 posts

231 months

Saturday 11th July 2009
quotequote all
Ha Ha Ha never realised you had too have a english degree to right your opinion about something,all iam saying is that fords no matter what make or model are never gonna be in the same league as vw and it shows you pay for vw quality thats what you get and im not just talking about passats.

Fort Jefferson

8,237 posts

253 months

Saturday 11th July 2009
quotequote all
whitefto said:
still poo because its a ford cheap rubbish
And Henry Ford was a Hitler supporting Nazi.

Alfa_75_Steve

7,489 posts

231 months

Saturday 11th July 2009
quotequote all
Having driven both. And run a Passat for 100k miles....

Passat every time. Unless you need a hatch.

The Mondeo *may* have a very slight edge on how it drives, but the Passat 'feels' like an 'executive' car, rather than something mass-produced.

The 2.0 16v PD diesel can be a bit vocal at times, but it's strong, and reliable. I'm not a fan of the PSA sourced TDCI lumps when installed in Fords.

Don't know why, but Passats in SE trim and above look classy, but even top spec. Mondeos look cheap.

missing the VR6

2,540 posts

220 months

Sunday 12th July 2009
quotequote all
whitefto said:
Ha Ha Ha never realised you had too have a english degree to right your opinion about something,all iam saying is that fords no matter what make or model are never gonna be in the same league as vw and it shows you pay for vw quality thats what you get and im not just talking about passats.
As I stated earlier I am an avid VW fan, but having driven a Focus and a MK5 Golf back to back I can say in all honesty that the Focus felt better screwed together, don't be blindly led into thinking VW make really well made cars as if the MK5 was as good as it's meant to be then surely they wouldn't have bought the MK6 out heralding it as a better built car? The MK6 is basicly VW admitting the MK5 wasn't good enough in terms of build quality.

whitefto

37 posts

231 months

Monday 13th July 2009
quotequote all
As i have said earlier its just my opinion my partner owns a mk5 tdi and is a great car and in my opinon better than a ford focus which i have also drove so each to there own i guess!!

AKA8

1,849 posts

258 months

Monday 13th July 2009
quotequote all
Not sure if the Mondeo Titanium has any additional kit that would help it handle, but it was very unstable under hard braking at high speeds and felt more 'barge' like than the Passat. I drive these cars whenever I'm in Italy and find the Passat handles much better at speed. The seats in the Passat are also much better.

AKA8

1,849 posts

258 months

Monday 13th July 2009
quotequote all
Not sure if the Mondeo Titanium has any additional kit that would help it handle, but it was very unstable under hard braking at high speeds and felt more 'barge' like than the Passat. I drive these cars whenever I'm in Italy and find the Passat handles much better at speed. The seats in the Passat are also much better.

GreatGranny

9,519 posts

257 months

Tuesday 14th July 2009
quotequote all
Whitefto - I've owned both VWs and Fords, the Fords on the whole drive better than the VWs but interiors are better quality in the VWs. I don't think there is much in the reliability stakes, both the diesel engines are proven but the Ford engine is a little quieter,especially compared to the 1.9TDi. I drove a new Mondy Estate a few weeks ago and was very impressed. Gutsy engine, good grip and covered the miles with ease. Interior still not up to the quality feel of the Passat IMO. I had a Ghia I think so was well equipped with climate, voice control (waste of time), bigger wheels, electric seats and cruise but no leather which I think is not standard even on the most expensive models.
I can't see how the Passat can be any better considering its an older design.