Theft / Fraud from my business - Any help
Theft / Fraud from my business - Any help
Author
Discussion

SagMan

Original Poster:

686 posts

251 months

Monday 13th July 2009
quotequote all
Currently a bit fuming, to say the least, but would welcome any advise comments on my situation.

I run a family business in Yorkshire and recently (3 months ago) parted company with our IT manager through voluntary redundancy. A few weeks ago we started to source alternative quotes for hardware (drives, terminals, printers, disks, printers etc) and consumables and became shocked at the savings to be had. We did allow our IT manager full authority to purchase these items! We then saw a quote, Jan 09, for a laser printer plus an Ipod touch. The subsequent invoice for the delivered printer matched the quote (including Ipod price) but did not list the Ipod. The cost of the Ipod was placed in the printer cost!!

We then suspected this "type" of fraudalent activity was massively prevalent, and as it turned out, it was! The orders suspected were provided by the Sales Director of our hardware supplier. We asked the director and her MD to meet with us and explained our concerns and our desire to take it legal and maybe inform the police. There were extremley "relaxed" about the situation and said as far as they were concerned all transactions had been approved by our companies Directors! I asked them to confirm all items, including serial numbers, that were delivered but not stated on the invoice. They have confirmed this list today at it amounts to over £4500 of hardware involving laptops. Ipod's camera's etc etc!!! I have none of these hardware items and hardly possible for any of my Directors could be involved.

Does anyone have any ideas on how I progress this issue, I am p*ssed off and have certainty that our supplier was fully aware of fraud. I am in discussion with my solicitors but appreciate any comments / advice.
I will name supplier, if requested by PM as they are a thiefing sh*thouse and we are probably not the only one who have been affected!. Sorry but business is diffcult enough wilthout this going on.
Many thanks in advance for all suggestions.
Sagman

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

286 months

Monday 13th July 2009
quotequote all
Police...

Why pay a lawyer..?

groomi

9,331 posts

274 months

Monday 13th July 2009
quotequote all
What was your ordering process? Did an order only require the IT managers signature, or did it have to directors signatures too?

Either way you may struggle to prove the supplier knew of any fraud. The IT manager on the other hand should be easy to prove.

I don't know whether the police would get involved, but if they do then you can provide all the serial numbers and they could search his house. Unless he's sold everything on already...

11SJC

643 posts

275 months

Monday 13th July 2009
quotequote all
happens all the time we make sure all post and deliveries are opened by a director

have come across loads check the contract with the it manager ours state that any gifts belong to the company its mainly the suppliers that offer free stuff to get you to order but it normally is on the order as a FOC item

on another note we would be happy to quote for equipment and consumables

11SJC

643 posts

275 months

Monday 13th July 2009
quotequote all
happens all the time we make sure all post and deliveries are opened by a director

have come across loads check the contract with the it manager ours state that any gifts belong to the company its mainly the suppliers that offer free stuff to get you to order but it normally is on the order as a FOC item

on another note we would be happy to quote for equipment and consumables

Mr POD

5,153 posts

223 months

Monday 13th July 2009
quotequote all
mybrainhurts said:
Police...

Why pay a lawyer..?
The police to press for prosecution of a criminal nature, and the lawyer to sue the offending persons for the civil debt.

SagMan

Original Poster:

686 posts

251 months

Monday 13th July 2009
quotequote all
Thanks for replies.
Director does not sign order (manager had authorisation upto £3k) but I see list of orders every day with item and value. Personally I wouldn't know competitive cost of laser printer or drive recorder!. Why employ expensive manager if I'm going to do the role, why - well might save on theft!!.

11SJC - PM me with company details you can tender for future products.
I'm not blinkered re company theft issues but when it happens at managerial level it p*sses me off major time!




Mr POD

5,153 posts

223 months

Monday 13th July 2009
quotequote all
On a related point, I noticed whilst looking for hotels in Chicago that some of the major chains have 2 prices, one of which includes x1000 free points, such that the person who is booking a more expensive option, is getting free accomodation at a later date.

This is either a tax fiddle, such that a small business man ends up with a lower profit, but 'free' accomodation, or some multinational is paying more than they should so that their junior executives can get a free holiday.

Equipment supply companies like FLUKE, have offers, so that the maintenance supervisor ordering a £1500 thermal imaging camera, gets a palm top thrown in.

To me it's all fraud in different costumes

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Monday 13th July 2009
quotequote all
Whether the other company was complicit is not the issue - it could never be proven, and you would get nothing back.

You would be better off keeping them sweet in order to build a case against the thief as they may have to be a witness.

My tact would be to get a definitive list and ask him to come to the office for a chat about something different, secretly record the conversation and hit him with it.

I would give him 7 days to come up with the cash in full or you will take civil and criminal action.


joewilliams

2,004 posts

232 months

Monday 13th July 2009
quotequote all
Are you more concerned about the money or the morals?

If it's the morals, let the police deal with it.

If it's the money, put the frighteners on him till he coughs up. Lawyers, small claims court, whatever you can muster.

SagMan

Original Poster:

686 posts

251 months

Monday 13th July 2009
quotequote all
Hi Joe,
Both to be honest. My business is built on integrity and I gave him all the flexibility he needed (he had relationship issues so he told me!) and I paid him well.
I will speak to local constabulary tomorrow and work out that route. Getting any money/kit back would be welcomed but probably just trying to relieve emotion!

flyingjase

3,095 posts

262 months

Tuesday 14th July 2009
quotequote all
The police will not be very interested. I was recently taken for £10k due to a forged signature and reported it. 12 months of me nagging them every week, they have eventualy said that there is not enough evidence for a court case despite me having the document with the forged signature. Read that as can't be arsed because they have more long hanging fruit.

I managed to get £6k of the person in question by engaging a top city lawyer and threatening a civil case.

In your shoes I would take a 3 pronged approach:-

1.Call the Old Bill and see what interest they have. Make it really simple for them and have all the evidence copied - you really have to spoon feed them at this level. In my case I got a PC who wasn't eactly bright and should have been put out to pasture years ago. Although £4.5k may seem a lot, in the eyes of the Old Bill it's not worth getting anyone with a brain involved in.

2.Talk to the ex-IT Manager and let him know he's rumbled and that you are taking it further in a civil and criminal case unless he stumps up the £4.5k and you certainly will not be giving him a reference for any future jobs. If you know where he is working now you could use that at leverage by inferring than you will tell his new employer about his ill gotten gains.

3.If the supplier is interested in ever delaing with your company again and maintaining their reputation in the market place then encourage them to make a contribution towards the loss as well. With my supply side hat on, I would rather maintain my reputation and lose a few grand.

Good luck - more than anything it's the breach of trust that really hurts

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 14th July 2009
quotequote all
I've done a couple of fraud audits, (for big groups) that has disclosed this sort of thing, the advice form Police is forget it, and lawyer fees can be huge, think about biting the bullit on the cost, and declering it to the tax man as untaxed income. had a case like it ( but in Norway) and the tax man took the guy to the cleaners, very satisfying result.

Eric Mc

125,936 posts

296 months

Tuesday 14th July 2009
quotequote all
I don't think the tax man will be that interested .

However, you may have a legal obligation to report this under the Proceeds of Crime Act. I would get legal advice on this topic. If you don't report it, YOU could end up being prosecuted.

Ironically, notifying the police does not constitute reporting under the Proceeds of Crime Act. You might need to notify the Serious and Orgnaised Crime Agency (SOCA). Also, your accountant is also required to report separately such matters too - as well as you.
HE can also be prosecuted too for failure to notify.

Soir

2,277 posts

270 months

Tuesday 14th July 2009
quotequote all
sounds to me the IT director has committed fraud here not the supplier as your IT Director (representing your company and placing/signing for orders) has clearly asked them to amend the invoice - they are only doing (although not above board) what your company (dir) has asked them to do.

I'd go after the IT Director

bad company

21,920 posts

297 months

Tuesday 14th July 2009
quotequote all
As the items were 'sold' to your firm why not contact your ex employee and ask for them to be returned. You can even itemise them now with the info received from the suppliers.


SagMan

Original Poster:

686 posts

251 months

Tuesday 14th July 2009
quotequote all
Great suggestions guys. Colleague of mine says foget it and move on but I will follow some of your leads and find out where it goes for sake of an hour or two of my time.
Thanks again.

JJCW

2,449 posts

217 months

Tuesday 14th July 2009
quotequote all
SagMan said:
Great suggestions guys. Colleague of mine says foget it and move on but I will follow some of your leads and find out where it goes for sake of an hour or two of my time.
Thanks again.
A couple of hours is worth investing jut for the principle of the thing - can imagine you don't want to let the bugger make off with your stuff!!!

Mojooo

13,291 posts

211 months

Tuesday 14th July 2009
quotequote all
at the very least send him a threating letter

joewilliams

2,004 posts

232 months

Tuesday 14th July 2009
quotequote all
flyingjase said:
The police will not be very interested. I was recently taken for £10k due to a forged signature and reported it. 12 months of me nagging them every week, they have eventualy said that there is not enough evidence for a court case despite me having the document with the forged signature. Read that as can't be arsed because they have more long hanging fruit.

I managed to get £6k of the person in question by engaging a top city lawyer and threatening a civil case.

In your shoes I would take a 3 pronged approach:-

1.Call the Old Bill and see what interest they have. Make it really simple for them and have all the evidence copied - you really have to spoon feed them at this level. In my case I got a PC who wasn't eactly bright and should have been put out to pasture years ago. Although £4.5k may seem a lot, in the eyes of the Old Bill it's not worth getting anyone with a brain involved in.

2.Talk to the ex-IT Manager and let him know he's rumbled and that you are taking it further in a civil and criminal case unless he stumps up the £4.5k and you certainly will not be giving him a reference for any future jobs. If you know where he is working now you could use that at leverage by inferring than you will tell his new employer about his ill gotten gains.

3.If the supplier is interested in ever delaing with your company again and maintaining their reputation in the market place then encourage them to make a contribution towards the loss as well. With my supply side hat on, I would rather maintain my reputation and lose a few grand.

Good luck - more than anything it's the breach of trust that really hurts
Agreed. We lost, from various companies serviced by the same accountant, getting on to £140k from forged signatures on cheques. We spoke to the police, and eventually got somebody who took it seriously. The police were brilliant, collected the evidence and got forensics involved.

The CPS, however, were complete bobbins. They eventually got him to plead guilty to a third of the charges, which got him sent to prison for a few months. However, they managed to lose the Confiscation and Compensation hearing by failing to properly adjourn the hearing. Three and a half years on from the discovery, our lawyers are still trying to recover the money.

While the thought of him enjoying his birthday in prison was rather nice (and celebrated with a good few cold bottles), given the choice again I'd go straight for the cash.