VAT investigations
Author
Discussion

pugwash4x4

Original Poster:

7,684 posts

252 months

Tuesday 14th July 2009
quotequote all
Need some help with a rather convaluted and potentially very serious problem.

Sold some shops for a very high lease about 2 years ago. They were performing at the very limit of their potential. The new owner has seen his turnover drop to 25% of when i sold them to him! He has now approached us saying that I mis represented the businesses to him and has evidence to prove. This is untrue.

The problem is that one of the things he is threatening (in a very roundabout and indirect way) to do is go to HMCE with "proof" that we lied about turnover. Now i don't beleive for a minute that his proof is real, but it may trigger an VAT investigation even if the proof is bks.

The period in question covers 2002 - 2007. We have had a variety of investigations over the years (the businesses were fast food cash based and attracted alot of HMCE interest- there was little to find- over a 3 yera period we owed them £1100 on a turnover of over £.5 million/yr for each business) and all have been closed.

Can HMCE re-investigave even though we don't own the trading business anymore, are they likely to do so from a tip off, considering that they have already investigated?

There are various routes to defend ourselves against our contentious lessee, but i need information first!

Lessee wants us to sell shops at below leease value so he can sublet them- basically he now isn't doing the turnover that he could be and thus the businesses are unprofitable.

don't want to give lawyers loads and loads of money to defend slander/libel cases!

there is more to the case, but the bare bones, and hopefully enough information is here.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Tuesday 14th July 2009
quotequote all
Just say no.

Why would he want to buy a shop which he knows is underperforming!?

If he is going to lease it on, then of course all he would do is surely have a lessor who is unprofitable and goes bust. That makes no sense.


If you have figures that you quoted to him that are backed up with figures also quoted to HMRC then I would show some to him to prove you are in the right, and that should put an end to the matter.

pugwash4x4

Original Poster:

7,684 posts

252 months

Tuesday 14th July 2009
quotequote all
he already owns the lease- bought it 2 years ago. its underperforming because of his lack of ability.

he wants to make as much trouble as possible, knowing that at the moment i have no way of handling it (there are a lot of reasons why i would struggle to cope with a full on VAT investigation at the moment- both personal and business). He knows this and is trying to take advantage.

smartie

2,630 posts

304 months

Tuesday 14th July 2009
quotequote all
So he's going to tell HMRC that you overstated your turnover meaning they would owe you money!?

Although they might have a bit of a look, hopefully they will see it as the sour grapes it is?

fastfreddy

8,577 posts

268 months

Tuesday 14th July 2009
quotequote all
He's not selling freshly baked pasties by any chance? getmecoat

The Count

3,417 posts

294 months

Tuesday 14th July 2009
quotequote all
As someone who has just been VAT investigated, i wouldn’t batter an eye at them turning up again. The officer was superb and we got along famously.

So if someone was to threaten me with this, i certainly wouldn’t give a hoot.

As long as you have nothing to hide, or haven’t done anything intentionally wrong...you have nothing to fear. smile

Ali_D

1,115 posts

315 months

Tuesday 14th July 2009
quotequote all
HMRC will be worried about you under paying VAT - if you have over declared sales then you'll have over paid VAT. They will not be in a hurry to investigate that very much. If it appears that the level of sales you had could only have been created by money laundering then you may have some problems, however if you can compare it to another fast food outlet (maccy d's?) and not be miles above that level then I would again think this is unlikely. Even if this does get to an investigation they'll not throw too many resources at it as they only really concentrate on the larger VAT payers now.

Brave it out - he's just looking for excuses for his own incompetance.