Do you judge suppliers by the car they drive?
Do you judge suppliers by the car they drive?
Author
Discussion

jamiebae

Original Poster:

6,245 posts

242 months

Thursday 16th July 2009
quotequote all
Mods, please don't move this to GG, it intended to stay here!

I always thought it wouldn't make a difference to me, but today I found myself thinking otherwise...

I had the MD of a company in who supply us with a few items because the quality of the last batch was unacceptable, we have had issues with them previously but this is the first time I had met him. Anyway, he agreed the products I had were unacceptable and agreed to take them back to be re-worked so I offered to help take them down to his car.

In the car park I found a tatty 2003 Focus in doom blue with scrapes on both bumpers and a smashed rear light. Now this guy is the MD of a company which our group spends over £500k a year with so it's not a small firm, yet he drives around it a car which is, to all intents and purposes, a shed, and it left me thinking that we shouldn't be doing business with a company where the MD can't even justify spending £200 a month to lease a new Octavia Estate so goes to business meetings in a tatty car which was de-fleeted by someone else 3 years ago.

Am I just being a snob or do other people think this way too?

Truckosaurus

13,311 posts

315 months

Thursday 16th July 2009
quotequote all
Perhaps he's spent the 500-Large on a supercar but thought it wise to turn up for the bking in The Wife's car.

The Nur

9,168 posts

216 months

Thursday 16th July 2009
quotequote all
how do you know that was his car?

Sam_68

9,939 posts

276 months

Thursday 16th July 2009
quotequote all
jamiebae said:
Am I just being a snob or do other people think this way too?
Yes, but it cuts both ways, too - I have ditched Architects and Consulting Engineers who have turned up to talk business driving Ferraris and Bentleys; if they are making that much cash, then either their fees are too high or they are cutting corners on quality of service to maximise their profit (or they are just so careless about the impression they give that I still don't want them working for me).

And I always try to choose a company car myself that isn't too obvious; my opposite numbers tend to be running Mercs, BMW's, Audis or Lexus', these days, but I tend to prefer something less 'middle management' so that (hopefully) less senior colleagues/poorer consultants don't feel that I'm rubbing their noses in it, and others on my level and above get to understand that I don't need rely on my car to define my status and authority.

jamiebae

Original Poster:

6,245 posts

242 months

Thursday 16th July 2009
quotequote all
I know it was his car.

I guess it was the car, in conjunction with the rest of the image he seemed to project that made me think that the fact that everyone in my team thinks he's a useless git is probably justified, and the car just underlined that.

KevF

1,996 posts

229 months

Thursday 16th July 2009
quotequote all
jamiebae said:
Mods, please don't move this to GG, it intended to stay here!

Am I just being a snob or do other people think this way too?
Yes you are.....how do you know he didnt have a Merc C63 AMG but had it in for a service so borrowed his wife/sons car in the meantime.
Or, as you have posted his previous supplies have been inferior, his business could be going down the pan so he sold his year old RS6 to pay off the overdraft/bills/baliffs/workforce/management buyout.

jamiebae

Original Poster:

6,245 posts

242 months

Thursday 16th July 2009
quotequote all
KevF said:
jamiebae said:
Mods, please don't move this to GG, it intended to stay here!

Am I just being a snob or do other people think this way too?
Yes you are.....how do you know he didnt have a Merc C63 AMG but had it in for a service so borrowed his wife/sons car in the meantime.
Or, as you have posted his previous supplies have been inferior, his business could be going down the pan so he sold his year old RS6 to pay off the overdraft/bills/baliffs/workforce/management buyout.
Without wishing to go into too much detail, I know it's his car and I know he has owned it since it was de-fleeted at 3 or 4 years old.

I don't think the car itself was the main problem, until recently I was driving an 02 plate Mondeo, but it was immaculate bar slightly corroded wheels and always clean(ish). His car was filthy and had several scars from impacts with road furniture. Put it another way there's no way it would pass 90% of companies requirements for cars to be used on business.

R6dug

344 posts

222 months

Thursday 16th July 2009
quotequote all
But he must be doing something right if you are spending 500K with him.It should be the product and not the car!!

Simon

jamiebae

Original Poster:

6,245 posts

242 months

Thursday 16th July 2009
quotequote all
I'm not, the division I work in (and am responsible for overseeing most of the spend with him in) spends very little, and we're reducing that where possible, it's other divisions outside my control spending the money there.

The reason I posted this is that I was surprised at my own reaction and wondered if anyone else had felt the same.

rich1231

17,340 posts

291 months

Thursday 16th July 2009
quotequote all
Small minded and point less to worry about what another person drives. Not everyone has the same priority.

john_p

7,073 posts

281 months

Thursday 16th July 2009
quotequote all
rich1231 said:
Small minded and point less to worry about what another person drives. Not everyone has the same priority.
Exactly, he could have driven home to a £5m mansion in Surrey while another guy turns up in a new R8 but goes home to his rented flat. Horses for courses.

dafydd2008

454 posts

215 months

Thursday 16th July 2009
quotequote all
Sam_68 said:
jamiebae said:
Am I just being a snob or do other people think this way too?
Yes, but it cuts both ways, too - I have ditched Architects and Consulting Engineers who have turned up to talk business driving Ferraris and Bentleys; if they are making that much cash, then either their fees are too high or they are cutting corners on quality of service to maximise their profit (or they are just so careless about the impression they give that I still don't want them working for me).

And I always try to choose a company car myself that isn't too obvious; my opposite numbers tend to be running Mercs, BMW's, Audis or Lexus', these days, but I tend to prefer something less 'middle management' so that (hopefully) less senior colleagues/poorer consultants don't feel that I'm rubbing their noses in it, and others on my level and above get to understand that I don't need rely on my car to define my status and authority.
Sam i disagree with you.
I am in the building indusry in London and work all hours god sends.
I am at the office at 6 oclock and still at the office now and will be for a further 30mins or so.
I am in my mid twentys, however drive a Aston as i work for my money.
Leaving the office at night and jump in it and know i work for it so i smile away.
You can not judge people on what they drive, for this exact reason.
Some people walk into it, however some work for it and the later part is me!

Sam_68

9,939 posts

276 months

Thursday 16th July 2009
quotequote all
dafydd2008 said:
Sam i disagree with you.
I am in the building indusry in London and work all hours god sends.
I am at the office at 6 oclock and still at the office now and will be for a further 30mins or so.
I am in my mid twentys, however drive a Aston as i work for my money.
I don't doubt you've earned it through graft, and good luck to you - but consultancy is a little different; you can't generate big profits from a small Architects or Engineering Consultant's practice without either inflated fees, corner-cutting, or employing second-rate (hence cheap) staff. And I wouldn't want a consultant who worked his bks off 16 hours a day consistently, because the sorts of fatigue levels those hours induce in anyone mean they're prone to making mistakes or failing to spot something obvious, and in my game that can prove very, very costly.

But regardless of the justification, I'm sorry, but I'll happily admit that first impressions count; car, as well as clothes, personal hygiene, timekeeping and general attitude all count for a lot, and someone who's too 'flash' will do themselves just as much of a disservice as someone who's slapdash and scruffy.

Edited by Sam_68 on Thursday 16th July 21:11

leeb

1,074 posts

274 months

Thursday 16th July 2009
quotequote all
i have gone from peugeot 406 estate, to audi a4, honda accord tourer, to a merc c220 sport.

the only people the new car impresses is people who like the look of it. Clients see it, and think that they are somehow being ripped off. Truth is i got a result, and it costs the same as a high spec mondeo on business contract hire.

so judging by cars is always a bad thing. sometimes i drive an old p reg landrover for work, does that mean i change when i swap over through the day?

jimmyb

12,254 posts

247 months

Thursday 16th July 2009
quotequote all
Sam I would actually kinda agree with your assesment. The car he drives is to a degree a representation of the success and values of his business.

Now im not saying that if he makes millions he should turn up in a bugatti however in most fields the service supplier should at least turn up in a decently looked after car even if its a 20 yr old ford escort. So long as it's in good cond it would show that he takes pride in his possesions and that would be a reflection of how he runs his business. It's much the same as a persons appearance.

If someone turns up smelling and or dressed in rags i am certainly going to have grave reservations about doing any business with them.


pcowen

401 posts

297 months

Thursday 16th July 2009
quotequote all
I try not to judge by the car clients or suppliers drive. I did once and I was wrong. We had a new client turn up in a DB7 Vanquish about 5 years ago, so the car was worth quite a bit. We thought he was good for the credit, without checking him out. Turned out he was a professional con artist. He was married with 5 kids, had his house repossessed, already owed thousands to other car dealers and businesses. He conned his way into renting a £1800 a month house for 1 year, and his business was supposed to be buying and selling expensive cars. He owed thousands to Octane, Motorsport and Classic Car magazines of unpaid bills and was been watch by undercover police.

So never judge a client or supplier by their car, you can be so wrong. We did get some of our money back, most of it was just lost time.

jimmyb

12,254 posts

247 months

Thursday 16th July 2009
quotequote all
Clearly you dont judge by car alone but i think it should factor into the equation beyond doubt. Its also very true that someone turning up in an aston is not necessarily a good supplier which is why i pointed out its about presentation. It doesnt really matter what car its the state of the car that matters i would say. Obviously if its quite a nice car you could read a little into their companies succes but i certainly wouldnt use it to make or break a contract.

taffyracer

2,093 posts

274 months

Thursday 16th July 2009
quotequote all
well, i agree wiht the 1st impression part, being overtly flashy and showy is vulgar at best, but I work very closely with architects, designers and many other trades, I don't have any problem with any of them that I employ having nice cars, its a sign of success to some extent and I want successful people on my projects, those that are successful usually bring others that they work with success

Mx_Stu

837 posts

254 months

Friday 17th July 2009
quotequote all
jamiebae said:


In the car park I found a tatty 2003 Focus in doom blue with scrapes on both bumpers and a smashed rear light.
It wouldn't bother me if he turned up in a Ford Focus as I am well aware that some people just aren't 'into' cars like PH'ers are, however I would be concerned at the state of it. Surely whatever you drive you would want it to be clean and tidy and a reflection of your person.

On the wider discussion here, if a supplier turned up in a supercar then I don't think it would concern me. If everyone at the company he was from drove round in them it would be a different matter, but you dont know what sacrifices this person has made to drive, presumably, his dream car.

360 boyy

89 posts

210 months

Friday 17th July 2009
quotequote all
When i go to meetings to do business i usually take the Ferrari or my M3. Some people's faces when they see me in the ferrari just drop (55k motor) but anyway i drive these cars becouse im succesfull at what i do and really coudnt care less what people thought of me being flashy or whatever. However we are currently opening a new unit and we are getting quotes of shop fitters and one chap (recommened by franchise) came in a new LP560 which was suprising as rest of them had vans. The chap with the LP560 portfolio of work is so much better and the quote he gave us was reasonable.