Blacberry is there a viable alternative?
Blacberry is there a viable alternative?
Author
Discussion

sone

Original Poster:

4,612 posts

269 months

Friday 17th July 2009
quotequote all
Just at the end of the contract term on a couple of our mobile phones and we have had a good few issues with the Blackberry sytem. Problem is if out phones drop out of the email system it can be a right performance getting it back on line.
I've just purchased another phone for one of our lads (on a seperate contract) and to date Orange/Blackberry/Phones for you can't get the push email working after 3 weeks.
A Client of our's has moved over to iphones and says the set-up and maintenance is much easier.
Any suggestions?

Cheers

Steve

Mx_Stu

837 posts

254 months

Friday 17th July 2009
quotequote all
I have a Blackberry (8310) for work and an iphone for personal use.

Whilst I think the iphone's feature are massively better than the Blackberry there is one thing that would make me think twice about having it as a work handset, the battery life.

I don't talk half as much on the iphone than I do on the Blackberry however the iphone has never gone more, I would say, than a day and a half without needing a re-charge whereas the Blackberry can easily go 4 days.

Someone more knowledgeable in this field will no doubt come along soon but I think the main alternatives to the Blackberry come in the form of HTC or Palm range of phones.

AB

20,673 posts

226 months

Friday 17th July 2009
quotequote all
It surprises me that you have had so many issues with Blackberry. In my experience, they have always been the reliable, easy alternative to just about anything else.

I currently use the Curve 8900 and its definitely been one of the best.

In terms of alternatives to BB, there are Palm offerings (although I have only used the Treo Pro which is Windows Mobile based) and certain HTC offerings. I appreciate that the iPhone is in a different class when it comes to full touch screens as it works very well but my advice would be to keep away from anything else such as HTC Touch Diamond/HD etc. Painful.

If BB was definitely out of the equation, take a look at the Nokia E71/51. Exchange server sync, steady software, typical Nokia ease of use and menu structure and a very thin, nice looking handset. It also has decent battery life (still not as good as the BB though).

What you need to consider is that the Blackberry was built for email, with all other features being added around it - which is done very well in the later handsets. All other handsets are built as phones, with email functionality.

Steve, have a chat to Nigel about mobile today.

TheD

3,144 posts

230 months

Friday 17th July 2009
quotequote all
I have a Nokia E71 and there isnt much it cant do.

sone

Original Poster:

4,612 posts

269 months

Friday 17th July 2009
quotequote all
AB said:
It surprises me that you have had so many issues with Blackberry. In my experience, they have always been the reliable, easy alternative to just about anything else.

I currently use the Curve 8900 and its definitely been one of the best.

In terms of alternatives to BB, there are Palm offerings (although I have only used the Treo Pro which is Windows Mobile based) and certain HTC offerings. I appreciate that the iPhone is in a different class when it comes to full touch screens as it works very well but my advice would be to keep away from anything else such as HTC Touch Diamond/HD etc. Painful.

If BB was definitely out of the equation, take a look at the Nokia E71/51. Exchange server sync, steady software, typical Nokia ease of use and menu structure and a very thin, nice looking handset. It also has decent battery life (still not as good as the BB though).

What you need to consider is that the Blackberry was built for email, with all other features being added around it - which is done very well in the later handsets. All other handsets are built as phones, with email functionality.

Steve, have a chat to Nigel about mobile today.
Alex,

will do!. you have to appreciate that I'm a complete technophobe. I have no inclination toward IT be it phones computers or anything to do with them.
I want to switch it on and use it, so ease of use is number one priority. I don't care what it looks like or geeky features because I just don't use them. jester

Cheers

Steve

selwonk

2,143 posts

256 months

Friday 17th July 2009
quotequote all
I have an old Nokia E61 running the GMail application and this browser:

http://www.skyfire.com/

Skyfire is excellent and very fast. It also runs Flash etc. so you are not restricted in what you can do.

bad company

21,920 posts

297 months

Friday 17th July 2009
quotequote all
I changed from BlackBerry to an iphone about 6 months better. It is much better. The only thing I can think of better on the BlackBerry is the camera.

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Friday 17th July 2009
quotequote all
We have Blackberry and iPhone in the company because we develop a mobile version of our application.

Blackberry email worked out of the box. Very good. iPhone - no blimmin' email as of yet. Blackberry web browser useless in comparison to iPhone, though.

Both work as phones. You pays your money you takes your choice but if you want email BB really does the job.

davidjpowell

18,707 posts

215 months

Friday 17th July 2009
quotequote all
HTC windows mobile phones. Set up is dead easy and works with Exchange with no extra software. Check out HTC Pro2.

The Moose

23,709 posts

240 months

Friday 17th July 2009
quotequote all
I would go with an iPhone.

Push e-mail could be an issue as it seems a lot of people running iPhones have issues with them. The way round this is to have the iPhone check for new e-mails regularly which isn't an issue as Data is unlimited! smile

HTH.

Cheers

The Moose

sone

Original Poster:

4,612 posts

269 months

Friday 17th July 2009
quotequote all
What does HTC mean, sorry but I know nothing.

Alex by the way could you give Nigel as shove for me.

Cheers

steve

Lefty Guns

21,608 posts

233 months

Friday 17th July 2009
quotequote all
Another vote for BB here.

The only issue is the standard browser but Opera is good (and free) and Bolt (also free) does the whole Java thing nicely.

No issues with email. Very easy to sue, good keyboard, good screen, good camera, I've got an 8Gb card in mine so storage in no problem either. Superb bit of kit.

HereBeMonsters

14,180 posts

213 months

Friday 17th July 2009
quotequote all
Do you have your own BES, or do you let O2 handle it all for you?

What version of Exchange (presuming you are running MS!) are you on?

Noel

586 posts

284 months

Friday 17th July 2009
quotequote all
HTC is a brand, I have a touch diamond (i think) and would swap for Nokia blackberry copy (the other option our company offer) in a heart beat. Avoid anything touch screen, you have been warned!

NDA

25,836 posts

256 months

Friday 17th July 2009
quotequote all
I recently lost my Blackberry (it's at the bottom of the sea) and am looking for a new gadget that will synch with my Yahoo mail and calender.

The Nokia E71 looks nice, but the new Palm Pre looks very funky indeed.....

plasticpig

12,932 posts

256 months

Friday 17th July 2009
quotequote all
AB said:
It surprises me that you have had so many issues with Blackberry. In my experience, they have always been the reliable, easy alternative to just about anything else.

I currently use the Curve 8900 and its definitely been one of the best.

In terms of alternatives to BB, there are Palm offerings (although I have only used the Treo Pro which is Windows Mobile based) and certain HTC offerings. I appreciate that the iPhone is in a different class when it comes to full touch screens as it works very well but my advice would be to keep away from anything else such as HTC Touch Diamond/HD etc. Painful.

If BB was definitely out of the equation, take a look at the Nokia E71/51. Exchange server sync, steady software, typical Nokia ease of use and menu structure and a very thin, nice looking handset. It also has decent battery life (still not as good as the BB though).

What you need to consider is that the Blackberry was built for email, with all other features being added around it - which is done very well in the later handsets. All other handsets are built as phones, with email functionality.

Steve, have a chat to Nigel about mobile today.
Blackberry Enterprise Server can be a real pain to sort out if it goes wrong. As fo Nokia's Exchange server push email solution it dosent work if you have various flavours of anti virus software on the exchaqnge server. Support is practicaly none existent from Nokia.

My suggestion for anyone who wants push email from an Exchange server is to use a phone running windows mobile.

sone

Original Poster:

4,612 posts

269 months

Friday 17th July 2009
quotequote all
plasticpig said:
AB said:
It surprises me that you have had so many issues with Blackberry. In my experience, they have always been the reliable, easy alternative to just about anything else.

I currently use the Curve 8900 and its definitely been one of the best.

In terms of alternatives to BB, there are Palm offerings (although I have only used the Treo Pro which is Windows Mobile based) and certain HTC offerings. I appreciate that the iPhone is in a different class when it comes to full touch screens as it works very well but my advice would be to keep away from anything else such as HTC Touch Diamond/HD etc. Painful.

If BB was definitely out of the equation, take a look at the Nokia E71/51. Exchange server sync, steady software, typical Nokia ease of use and menu structure and a very thin, nice looking handset. It also has decent battery life (still not as good as the BB though).

What you need to consider is that the Blackberry was built for email, with all other features being added around it - which is done very well in the later handsets. All other handsets are built as phones, with email functionality.

Steve, have a chat to Nigel about mobile today.
Blackberry Enterprise Server can be a real pain to sort out if it goes wrong. As fo Nokia's Exchange server push email solution it dosent work if you have various flavours of anti virus software on the exchaqnge server. Support is practicaly none existent from Nokia.

My suggestion for anyone who wants push email from an Exchange server is to use a phone running windows mobile.
Now that makes sense to me

Tiggsy

10,261 posts

283 months

Friday 17th July 2009
quotequote all
3 iphones in our little place and love them - we use mobile me which means email is push, diary is push....even web favorites and photos, etc can be pushed real time back and forth.


and....its an iphone so is a great "personal" phone as well. Having had EVERY smart phone going in the last 15 years i cant imagine ever not having an iphone now.

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Friday 17th July 2009
quotequote all
HereBeMonsters said:
Do you have your own BES, or do you let O2 handle it all for you?

What version of Exchange (presuming you are running MS!) are you on?
Orange deals with BES for me. I suspect if we ran our own I could do more (like synchronising contacts etc) but I don't give a stuff about that - just syncing emails for me is the killer feature I want.

We run Exchange 2003 in house. I'm the email admin for my sins but it's about one millionth of my role so I want it to be largely self-managing. And with the Orange Blackberry service it is...

HereBeMonsters

14,180 posts

213 months

Friday 17th July 2009
quotequote all
If you ran your own BES, it would be a piece of piss to reconnect failed devices. We do it all the time - 600 or so users, probably get 5-6 a week that need reactivating.
Also running Exchange 2003.
When we upgrade to 2007, apparently we are getting iPhone connectivity as well...