Estate Agents ...school boy error
Discussion
Had estate agent around Saturday, agreed sole agency terms to the 31st August and a HIP with a deferred payment and I clearly said "this involves no upfront cost yes" and he agreed, unless after 9 months and we have not sold it, which I was content with and signed the sole agency agreement.
Get a call today, your credit card has been refused, I said well it would be I'm over limit till Friday and pay day. Then I said hold on I was clear about this, there was no cost for the hip and the payment details ere to be after 9 months if we haven't sold. Why were you trying to take payment? We were verifying the card Sir. Why? er.....we were verifying the card. Then he tells me it will take 10 days from Friday to get the HIP as well. I say forget it.
He says you have sole agency agreement till end of August, I say yes....but you said you can provide the HIP at no cost and that was not accurate. and you cannot market my property without a HIP as you told me about 20 times.
Am I right in thinking that most sole agency agreements say they can claim commision if I exchange contracts with a buyer within the sole agency agreement yes? My thinking being it would be a minor miracle to get exchange on anything in August. The agent is part of Countrywide Group.
Get a call today, your credit card has been refused, I said well it would be I'm over limit till Friday and pay day. Then I said hold on I was clear about this, there was no cost for the hip and the payment details ere to be after 9 months if we haven't sold. Why were you trying to take payment? We were verifying the card Sir. Why? er.....we were verifying the card. Then he tells me it will take 10 days from Friday to get the HIP as well. I say forget it.
He says you have sole agency agreement till end of August, I say yes....but you said you can provide the HIP at no cost and that was not accurate. and you cannot market my property without a HIP as you told me about 20 times.
Am I right in thinking that most sole agency agreements say they can claim commision if I exchange contracts with a buyer within the sole agency agreement yes? My thinking being it would be a minor miracle to get exchange on anything in August. The agent is part of Countrywide Group.
GreenV8S said:
Mick Jones said:
I clearly said "this involves no upfront cost yes" and he agreed, unless after 9 months and we have not sold it, which I was content with
What he said is irrelevent; what the contract says is the only thing that matters.johnfm said:
GreenV8S said:
Mick Jones said:
I clearly said "this involves no upfront cost yes" and he agreed, unless after 9 months and we have not sold it, which I was content with
What he said is irrelevent; what the contract says is the only thing that matters.They have introduced no-one, prepared no details and told me they could not do so without the HIP in place. The agent has emailed me to say he could not complete the ordering of the HIP, if he cannot do the HIP therefore he cannot market it so therefore no agreement?
Edited by Mick Jones on Monday 27th July 16:00
Mick Jones said:
They have introduced no-one, prepared no details and told me they could not do so without the HIP in place. The agent has emailed me to say he could not complete the ordering of the HIP, if he cannot do the HIP therefore he cannot market it so therefore no agreement?
What does the contract say?Edited by Mick Jones on Monday 27th July 16:00
If it is silent on what happens in the event that a HIP cannot be undertaken, the contract may be void by frustration.
GreenV8S said:
In my limited experience they routinely do contain that clause, but in any case the contract that was signed will determine what the terms were and whether any verbal modifications to the terms are permitted.
You can't make that assumption though - even if as a matter of practicality you are right.Anyway, an entire agreement clause need not necessarily be the end of the matter - there could still be scope for a claim in misrepresentation.
checked agreement HIP has to be in place they cannot provide HIP on the basis that they said they could. Also I thought there was a court case just after christmas where it said Sole Agency rights can be overturned if the agnecy has not created any marketing material or attempted to sell the property?
bad company said:
miniman said:
Mick Jones said:
The agent is part of Countrywide Group.
There's your problem. 
Wouldn't touch them with a barge pole.
The Court of Appeal stated that the notion that estate agents were not allowed to claim commission where they merely introduce eventual purchasers to a property sat well with the principle that commission can only be claimed where there has been a successful transaction. In order to claim commission, an agent must introduce the purchaser to the transaction. The court held that from the facts there was nothing to suggest that the purchaser’s interest in the property was a result of Foxtons’ earlier activities, therefore preventing them from being able to claim commission from the seller
Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



