Search engine optimisation
Search engine optimisation
Author
Discussion

rah1888

Original Poster:

1,589 posts

218 months

Tuesday 28th July 2009
quotequote all
Has anyone got any experience of companies that provide this service?

We have a small estate agents company and have just had someone in pitching. They promise to get our website higher up the Google search results page.

Bit of a new area for me, would welcome hearing thoughts from others.

cs02rm0

13,966 posts

222 months

Tuesday 28th July 2009
quotequote all
I wouldn't bother spending a penny on it personally. So long as you've got a well-written website that's, largely, all there is to it unless you can get high ranking sites to link to you. Google rankings are somewhat of a dark art and the people best placed to manipulate the rankings don't pitch to estate agents. If Google think your site is trying to manipulate its ranking they'll also send it to the bottom of the pile. Best avoided.

IMO.

rah1888

Original Poster:

1,589 posts

218 months

Tuesday 28th July 2009
quotequote all
Thats pretty much what i have been thinking, thanks for your comments!

DonnyMac

3,634 posts

234 months

Tuesday 28th July 2009
quotequote all
With respect to cs02rm0, I don’t agree.

Being in the top ten / five / three of SERPs will have a major positive effect on your business, you must measure whether that effect has a positive ROI against the SEO company’s charges.

A top 5 UK SEO firm will charge between £6-10k per annum – I’ve done months of research on this and will happily pass on the top three UK companies.

PM me the website URL and the most important keyword string – ‘selling a house in Essex’ etc and I’ll let you know within minutes how well the site is optimised for it.

SEO is one of the most effective and low cost methods of generating a high volume of highly targeted and motivated prospects, but takes effort and time.

(I do offer SEO services, however I'd guess we'd be too expensive so the recommendations I’ll give will be independent)

GTIR

24,741 posts

297 months

Tuesday 28th July 2009
quotequote all
It depends if you want a website to generate work through search engines or just a place for your existing/
future clients to visit once they know your name (googling your name will usually bring up your website anyways)

I get endless calls regarding seo companies, all of them saying they are "number 1" and will get you on the first page of google, which is tripe as it depends on what keywords they are talking about. Also if your website is crap, as in badly formatted, it's pointless spending money trying to optimise it.

Go for a small scale Adwords and map with google for relevant keywords; "estate agents" is to generic and will cost you wasted money but "estate agents west London" is better. I get good results with this and am number 1 of page 1 in google for certain keywords, this is with a self built website and approx £60pm adwords. smile

just a mention to the last poster, if you are too expensive for the op why are you offering him the top five seo's! Are you not in the top 5? Maybe your too expensive. wink

spend your money on a well optimised, well built website and google adwords.

playerone

872 posts

241 months

Tuesday 28th July 2009
quotequote all
Can recommend www.vervesearch.com

Nice people and no nonsense advice.


evo4a

737 posts

212 months

Tuesday 28th July 2009
quotequote all
My old website was not optimised and as a result it generated very little business.
My new one is and wow I have more business than I can handle and now cherry pick jobs, SEO is a must if you want to generate sales through a website.

DonnyMac

3,634 posts

234 months

Tuesday 28th July 2009
quotequote all
GTIR said:
just a mention to the last poster, if you are too expensive for the op why are you offering him the top five seo's! Are you not in the top 5? Maybe your too expensive. wink
laugh - we resell the joint number 2 UK/USA SEO firm to our exsisting client base as a value add, so add some margin for an honest days account management work, I wouldn't want to add margin to a PHer on purely a resale deal so would just give the facts on the top five and let them decide (or not) and contact direct.

No point in adding to the bill for no good reason and passing it off as a favour. I'm all heart today biggrin

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 29th July 2009
quotequote all
evo4a said:
My old website was not optimised and as a result it generated very little business.
My new one is and wow I have more business than I can handle and now cherry pick jobs, SEO is a must if you want to generate sales through a website.
You can't make broad comments like that, if the site has content and relevant keywords then it will rank highly in google. Both our sites rank number 1 for search terms we want. It's not rocket science.


stuart-b

3,651 posts

257 months

Wednesday 29th July 2009
quotequote all
Exactly... SEO is a "black magic" which to be honest, is a term made up by website designers after their business model fell flat on its face when everyone offered "£500 websites" and nobody made any money.

If the content is written correctly, the URL/meta/keyword density is correct, you have a few incoming links from relevant sources, you don't need SEO.

IMHO you're better off spending 10k a year on a complete marketing mix (offline + online advertising) than just spending it on SEO.

Google can change their algorithms at any time and wipe you off the face of the earth, over the last few years this has happened numerous times (plenty of pages on Google PageRank, Google Sandboxing). You only have to have an SEO company "spam" a few keywords too many, or link your page on a linkfarm, and you're sandboxed.

If your business relies on Google entirely for its leads and sales, prepare for doom.

It should be treated as a bonus to get anything from Google.

The only thing you can count on from Google is paid advertising getting you on page 1 (yes, you have to pay for it!) But then any changes in the google search engine algorithms won't cause you massive problems.

For example, search for "printer leasing" in google. We're #3 in the world out of 2,750,000 pages. (UK + USA). No SEO, just a properly built website (which I might had, has hardly any content about printer leasing still...).

Search "plasma leasing" #1 in Google.
"desktop pc leasing" #1 in Google.
"server leasing" #1 in Google.

You're also better off building "micro-sites" which are dedicated to the phrase you're after. For example "computer support worthing", there is a website called computer-support-worthing.co.uk

All those keywords are found by Google, they are #1 in the rankings. Their website has some valid content. The website though is shocking and it's just a link generator to take you through to another website... but this is the power of building a website properly.

You're better off spending £5k on a professional copywriter than £5k having your existing website "tarted up", because that copy can also be used offline, for promotions, leaflets, and so on.

All IMHO of course.

Edited by stuart-b on Wednesday 29th July 09:20

jon-

16,534 posts

247 months

Wednesday 29th July 2009
quotequote all
stuart-b said:
You're better off spending £5k on a professional copywriter
Depending on the sector this could be the be the best advice you ever follow!

jas xjr

11,309 posts

270 months

Wednesday 29th July 2009
quotequote all
also have a search on ph. a chap posted some worthwhile information some time ago on some tips for optimising your own site. will have a look when a have a few minutes

Graham

16,381 posts

315 months

Wednesday 29th July 2009
quotequote all
seo, 90% is just smoke and mirrors and a good way of relieving you of cash... build a relavent website with the right content and your most of the way...

The guys at google are much more intelligent than the seo guys, and they figure out all of the scams in the end..

Andrew[MG]

3,360 posts

229 months

Wednesday 29th July 2009
quotequote all
stuart-b said:
Exactly... SEO is a "black magic" which to be honest, is a term made up by website designers after their business model fell flat on its face when everyone offered "£500 websites" and nobody made any money.

If the content is written correctly, the URL/meta/keyword density is correct, you have a few incoming links from relevant sources, you don't need SEO.

IMHO you're better off spending 10k a year on a complete marketing mix (offline + online advertising) than just spending it on SEO.

Google can change their algorithms at any time and wipe you off the face of the earth, over the last few years this has happened numerous times (plenty of pages on Google PageRank, Google Sandboxing). You only have to have an SEO company "spam" a few keywords too many, or link your page on a linkfarm, and you're sandboxed.

If your business relies on Google entirely for its leads and sales, prepare for doom.

It should be treated as a bonus to get anything from Google.

The only thing you can count on from Google is paid advertising getting you on page 1 (yes, you have to pay for it!) But then any changes in the google search engine algorithms won't cause you massive problems.

For example, search for "printer leasing" in google. We're #3 in the world out of 2,750,000 pages. (UK + USA). No SEO, just a properly built website (which I might had, has hardly any content about printer leasing still...).

Search "plasma leasing" #1 in Google.
"desktop pc leasing" #1 in Google.
"server leasing" #1 in Google.

You're also better off building "micro-sites" which are dedicated to the phrase you're after. For example "computer support worthing", there is a website called computer-support-worthing.co.uk

All those keywords are found by Google, they are #1 in the rankings. Their website has some valid content. The website though is shocking and it's just a link generator to take you through to another website... but this is the power of building a website properly.

You're better off spending £5k on a professional copywriter than £5k having your existing website "tarted up", because that copy can also be used offline, for promotions, leaflets, and so on.

All IMHO of course.

Edited by stuart-b on Wednesday 29th July 09:20
"printer leasing" only had 590 searches on Google last month according to Google's keyword tool. Try getting to number 1 on Google for big terms like "jeans" or "ipod" and see how you get on with your technique.

Why tell people that they don't need SEO when you don't know very much about the industry and how well it has worked for other people?

If you have a massive hotel in Brighton, but are competing with 50 other hotels to be no.1 in Google, some good copy and tagging won't be enough to do it.

stuart-b

3,651 posts

257 months

Wednesday 29th July 2009
quotequote all
Andrew[MG said:
"printer leasing" only had 590 searches on Google last month according to Google's keyword tool. Try getting to number 1 on Google for big terms like "jeans" or "ipod" and see how you get on with your technique.

Why tell people that they don't need SEO when you don't know very much about the industry and how well it has worked for other people?

If you have a massive hotel in Brighton, but are competing with 50 other hotels to be no.1 in Google, some good copy and tagging won't be enough to do it.
Here comes the SEO brigade rolleyes

What I was trying to explain, is that you can't say, here is my website, here is £500 per month, make me #1 for "jeans" and then I'll earn £100,000 per month.

If everyone is using the same "tricks" then you're back to square one again.

This is my point.

Sure, optimisation of a website helps, but people think it is the be all and end all - when it is just one part of the mix.

Hotels also sign up and get referred from major hotel affiliate websites who pay for Google PPC, which a quick search, shows most of them. Lastminute.com, Booking.com, Laterooms, and so on. These people do not rely on SEO.

It also isn't about the most targeting keyword phrases with the most search phrases either.

You are better off targeting less used phrases which have a higher conversation rate.

Your example of "jeans", means you will no doubt see less conversation rate than "buy levis jeans" as a search phrase.

Trying to get "jeans" as #1 in Google is unrealistic, you are competiting against major players, with huge websites and thousands of back links.

The likelyhood of getting #1 for "ipod" is also fairly remote, as it's an Apple product.

If you target more "smaller" keyword phrases that are more specific, you can get just as much if not more response than always trying to target the most popular searches...

There are too many people competing for the #1 spot, and lots of SEO companies promising them #1, just how many people can get on the first page for such popular search terms Andrew? Oh, that will be 10, plus a few mapping links and PPC.

rah1888

Original Poster:

1,589 posts

218 months

Wednesday 29th July 2009
quotequote all
Thanks guys for all the replys - PH really is the answer to everything!!

Am off to do some reading and chat with my 2 colleagues, which will almost certainly result in a couple of questions as none of us are that IT literate, so will defintely be back to pick your brains!

Thanks again thumbup

Dick Dastardly

8,326 posts

294 months

Wednesday 29th July 2009
quotequote all
Stuart-b, I think you are confusing SEO with something else (black-hat SEO, perhaps?).

stuart-b said:
If the content is written correctly, the URL/meta/keyword density is correct, you have a few incoming links from relevant sources, you don't need SEO.
That is SEO. Creating web pages with keywords in mind, so that you are including them in the URL, in the title, in the meta data and then in the body copy, as well as seeking links for site respected for theose keywords, means you are optimising the page for those keywords. The very basics of normal SEO, and have been for years.

stuart-b said:
For example, search for "printer leasing" in google. We're #3 in the world out of 2,750,000 pages. (UK + USA). No SEO, just a properly built website (which I might had, has hardly any content about printer leasing still...).
This is happeneing because you guys have done a good job of optimising your site, not because you have avoided SEO.

stuart-b

3,651 posts

257 months

Thursday 30th July 2009
quotequote all
Dick Dastardly said:
Stuart-b, I think you are confusing SEO with something else (black-hat SEO, perhaps?).

stuart-b said:
If the content is written correctly, the URL/meta/keyword density is correct, you have a few incoming links from relevant sources, you don't need SEO.
That is SEO. Creating web pages with keywords in mind, so that you are including them in the URL, in the title, in the meta data and then in the body copy, as well as seeking links for site respected for theose keywords, means you are optimising the page for those keywords. The very basics of normal SEO, and have been for years.

stuart-b said:
For example, search for "printer leasing" in google. We're #3 in the world out of 2,750,000 pages. (UK + USA). No SEO, just a properly built website (which I might had, has hardly any content about printer leasing still...).
This is happeneing because you guys have done a good job of optimising your site, not because you have avoided SEO.
Dick, agreed, I understand SEO. But I don't agree with monthly subscriptions (perhaps I pointed this out badly). Once you've done "SEO", you don't need to keep paying £160-£500 per month. Sure, you can write some more content, but you're better off giving this to a professional copywriter, not for someone to do a few more back links or score a few more keywords.

DonnyMac

3,634 posts

234 months

Thursday 30th July 2009
quotequote all
stuart-b said:
Dick Dastardly said:
This is happeneing because you guys have done a good job of optimising your site, not because you have avoided SEO.
Dick, agreed, I understand SEO. But I don't agree with monthly subscriptions (perhaps I pointed this out badly). Once you've done "SEO", you don't need to keep paying £160-£500 per month. Sure, you can write some more content, but you're better off giving this to a professional copywriter, not for someone to do a few more back links or score a few more keywords.
It's obvious you have a good understanding of SEO in a'nuts & bolts' kind of way, but you yourself said the algorithms change without warning, with a good SEO firm, copywriting and article generation & submission is included within the above cost, some things are important, and more than one aspect of business requires huge amounts of management time, so £500+ for someone to competently manage one of your most important sales channels is chicken feed (sorry to steal the line Boris).
Ensuring your international online presence is at the top of the agenda for circa £6-10k is money very well spent IMHO.



Dick Dastardly

8,326 posts

294 months

Thursday 30th July 2009
quotequote all
I suppose it all depends on competition level. Some of the services you mention (link building, content generation, etc.) are things we offer and we often do charge a monthly fee. A lot of companies targetting niche or local keywords don't need it, and after a re-write of their homepage and a day spent securing a handful of decent links they are up on page one and usually stay there. I have other clients in some really competitive areas (personal injury, software, mortgages, insurance, etc) where without using a specialist team like ourselves they stand no chance of ranking, even for second tier keywords, despite a perfectly optimised site.