'Definitive' stance sought - limited v limiting liability...
'Definitive' stance sought - limited v limiting liability...
Author
Discussion

Arif110

Original Poster:

794 posts

245 months

Friday 31st July 2009
quotequote all
Hi there,

Appealing to the collective erudition here.

Have done a 'search' - nothing to my satisfaction.

Assumptions behind question:

One is selling a physical household product - e.g. stick-on draft excluders for door bottoms.

One's concern is to limit liability in the event of disgruntled customers. I.e. one does not want one's personal assets to be at risk in the event of litigation.

Question:

Given that a business can have detailed Disclaimers and Terms & Conditions (I gather the former expression is the more important to emphasise), what is the advantage, if any, of setting up a Limited Company, disregarding any tax considerations?

I'm suspecting given the assumptions above, that the easiest way to remove fear of losing personal assets is indeed to form a limited company, so that by definition, only that entity can be 'attacked' - with Directors' personal assets safely outside of the equation.

But can not a detailed enough disclaimer achieve the same end, or if not specifically protect assets - remove the risk of liability in all/most imaginable situations?


Your time and attention much appreciated,


Arif

Eric Mc

125,954 posts

296 months

Friday 31st July 2009
quotequote all
Even with a million disclaimers, you could still be exposed. There have been many cases over the years where the existence of a disclaimer has been waived.

johnfm

13,752 posts

281 months

Friday 31st July 2009
quotequote all
Are your draught excluders that dangerous!!

therealpigdog

2,592 posts

228 months

Friday 31st July 2009
quotequote all
You can limit your liability through your terms and conditions, but there are some areas that you cannot totally exclude liability (such as death or personal injury caused by your negligence) or areas of consumer protection. That said, a good set of terms and conditions correctly implemented will protect you against most things.

The advantage of using a limited liability vehicle is that the protection is against the world at large, and not just the people you have contracted with through your terms and conditions. Add banks, employees, suppliers etc. into the mix and depending on the type of business there can be a clear benefit to having the benefit of limited liability status.

Of course you can have the best of both worlds by having limited liability status and making sure your terms and conditions and other contracts are well drafted - but I would say that ... I'm here all week, try the veal.

Arif110

Original Poster:

794 posts

245 months

Thursday 10th September 2009
quotequote all
Er...guiltily late...just replying to say thanks for the replies.

'Draft excluders dangerous?' - well that's actually the nub of the issue. Does one guess at how much could reasonably go wrong, or cover themselves for the scenario that their customer was suffering from rabiz and highly sensitive to breezes - leading to them murdering someone because your draft excluders didn't do their job properly.

E.g. surely the potential liability for brochure-type websites would be far lower in potentia than that of e-commerce websites.


Arif




TurricanII

1,516 posts

229 months

Thursday 10th September 2009
quotequote all
You might be able to get some liability legal insurance to cover your costs if a problem occurs, and it might be cheaper if your product is seemingly harmless.. I guess liability insurance is not, err, limited to limited companies.. Speaking to some insurance companies may prove enlightening

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Friday 11th September 2009
quotequote all
Arif110 said:
Er...guiltily late...just replying to say thanks for the replies.

'Draft excluders dangerous?' - well that's actually the nub of the issue. Does one guess at how much could reasonably go wrong, or cover themselves for the scenario that their customer was suffering from rabiz and highly sensitive to breezes - leading to them murdering someone because your draft excluders didn't do their job properly.

E.g. surely the potential liability for brochure-type websites would be far lower in potentia than that of e-commerce websites.


Arif
This is the thing. It is difficult to write a disclaimer saying:

"Don't expect this draft excluder to exclude draft."

Disclaimer or no disclaimer, that is not the real issue, it is the issue of the overall business.

For example, lets say you are personally liable. You have a great relationship with B&Q, and business is well, they are putting good turnover of your product. So you've had a big amounts made.

You've just got out a loan to get the biggest amount manufactured to date - £20k of your own money and you are waiting for them to arrive. They don't. You get worried and they promise they will be there soon. B&Q ring you saying that they are out of stock - you apologise...

A few weeks pass, and the manufacturer is cagy. B&Q, are getting annoyed at leaving empty space on the shelf. The manufacturer says they are having 'problems'. You've had no income for a couple of months now, and money is running out to pay staff.

You ring the manufacturer telling them your business is going down the pan, and leave a message. You get a loan out to pay staff, and ring the manufacturer who has gone bust...

You have zero stock, no money to pay staff, no money to make any more stock, you've lost your deal with B&Q. You are dead. You've lost £20k of your own money, not been paid for 3 months. Then at the end of the year, you still need to pay your tax bill....


Sometimes through no fault of your own, this can happen. If you have limited liability then you can close, and still have a roof over your head and a career in business afterwards. In the situation above, you would lose everything and possibly be bankrupt so you couldn't even fund a new business.