How discounts are detrimental to business - opinions pls
Discussion
Dear All,
I'm helping one of friends with his IT related business.
Basically they carry out networking/ home visits /laptop upgrades.
Compared to the other local companies, he and all his staff work really hard and go the extra mile.
I just can't believe the discounts he is giving !
He is of the mind that you should not lose a customer.
I've said to him its better to lose a few customers than reduce your price but he disagrees. £10 - £20 here and there add up so i need your help to convince him. He is an engineer by profession.
It would be great if you could post some opinions below with your background /business experience if you don't mind.
I'm trying to convince him and I need your help !
I'm helping one of friends with his IT related business.
Basically they carry out networking/ home visits /laptop upgrades.
Compared to the other local companies, he and all his staff work really hard and go the extra mile.
I just can't believe the discounts he is giving !
He is of the mind that you should not lose a customer.
I've said to him its better to lose a few customers than reduce your price but he disagrees. £10 - £20 here and there add up so i need your help to convince him. He is an engineer by profession.
It would be great if you could post some opinions below with your background /business experience if you don't mind.
I'm trying to convince him and I need your help !
If you are running a business with a long term view, you will do your utmost to keep customers. Even if this means running at a loss for a certain period of time. It's called investing in the long term.
When I started my own IT company many years ago, we never made a penny profit in the first 5 years. We didn't expect to make any money duringthis time because our plan was to build up a market share in our area of specialisation. That was 15 years ago. We now have long term clients and make reasonable margins but our business is solid. Many of my colleauges thought we were mad not planning to make money within the first few weeks/months and couldn't see the point of working when not making any money. It's a typical short term view that's endemic in the UK.
When I started my own IT company many years ago, we never made a penny profit in the first 5 years. We didn't expect to make any money duringthis time because our plan was to build up a market share in our area of specialisation. That was 15 years ago. We now have long term clients and make reasonable margins but our business is solid. Many of my colleauges thought we were mad not planning to make money within the first few weeks/months and couldn't see the point of working when not making any money. It's a typical short term view that's endemic in the UK.
Silver993tt said:
If you are running a business with a long term view, you will do your utmost to keep customers. Even if this means running at a loss for a certain period of time. It's called investing in the long term.
When I started my own IT company many years ago, we never made a penny profit in the first 5 years. We didn't expect to make any money duringthis time because our plan was to build up a market share in our area of specialisation. That was 15 years ago. We now have long term clients and make reasonable margins but our business is solid. Many of my colleauges thought we were mad not planning to make money within the first few weeks/months and couldn't see the point of working when not making any money. It's a typical short term view that's endemic in the UK.
When I started my own IT company many years ago, we never made a penny profit in the first 5 years. We didn't expect to make any money duringthis time because our plan was to build up a market share in our area of specialisation. That was 15 years ago. We now have long term clients and make reasonable margins but our business is solid. Many of my colleauges thought we were mad not planning to make money within the first few weeks/months and couldn't see the point of working when not making any money. It's a typical short term view that's endemic in the UK.

Bullett said:
Depends if you want to keep the customer or not.
If they are a good customer, pay on time lots of repeat business, sure discount away.
If they are a pain in the arse then don't (unless they are very profitable).
I think that as long as both parties are clear as to why discount is being given that is fine. If I discount a bit of training, research or postage I make it clear in the invoice that it is a one off and the reason (even if that is a 'loyalty discount' and they get it every time) to protect future prices.If they are a good customer, pay on time lots of repeat business, sure discount away.
If they are a pain in the arse then don't (unless they are very profitable).
I prefer to offer a fee day amongst paid days and show that, so that they don't think the day rate is now lower and expect that rate for an odd day and I sometimes trade off discount by making it clear what I am getting for the discount (e.g. retaining copyright, or work as part of a larger piece of work). That way if they back out of the rest of the deal I have the right (if not the guts!) to invoice the discount to get it back.
I have resisted discount, for example a client who wanted me to discount because she was buying 4 days of my time at her offices, and pointed out that I would discount consequtive days but not when I am travelling 200 miles each time simply because I know she talks to others in the business who would expect the same for an odd day.
His business has been running for ten years.
The thing with the IT industry is changes are rapid. In my opinion it's o.k. to give a discount occasionally. However, you cannot count on anything these days running for a very long time.
I'm in my 30's and I was only one of handful of people in school with a home computer (Vic 20 !).
Look at the younger generation now, everyone (almost) is tech savy and most people know of one 'expert' who can help them with IT issues.
But, discounts are dangerous. My friend's business is flooded with calls/messages asking for him
(because his staff are not authorised to give more than a 5% discount.)
People even call and when his staff say he's not available they hang up !( how rude.)
I mean you don't call Virgin and expect to talk to Richard B! This also means he has deal with a lot of msgs and calls which should have been handled by his staff. which increases his work load.
Almost everyone knows it takes time to build your business and it's fine not to make a reasonable(or any!) profit for a year or two (or three!).
If we can talk about one thing that's endemic to the U.K.(IMHO) is poor customer service + after sales support. Our US cousins know a thing or two about customer service. I've bought books /parts /camera bits and they always call (internationally ! ) or at least email after a few days and weeks and ask if they can be of help. I walk into many shops (because I like to support independent businesses) and many times the staff do not even bother to engage with me and say at least a hello.
Most of my friends with local retail businesses offer their customers tea/coffee/biscuits and hello as well !
I do completely agree that its better to retain a god customer. I like offers which reward you if you recommend a friend. But discounting leads to haggling where the customer wants to pay the lowest price and you want to keep your margin.
I'll tell you a story about what happened in SW london many years ago.
Once upon a time there was a pound shop. A year later another one opened up across the road.
Now the owner of the first shop got worried, so he decided to make a loss on kitchen towels and sell them for below cost price (loss leader). Now the second shop seeing this, decided to lower the cost of coffee and toilet tissues. A third shop opened and the owner decided to included some below cost products as well. What did the customers do ? They bought kitchen rolls from one shop, toilet rolls and coffee from the second and other products from the third.
All three shops closed down after awhile.
Perhaps discounts are offered for multiple purchases and to reward loyalty.
But to just discount for the sake of it is dangerous (IMHO).
A company exists to make a profit. If I only service my bike and computer once a year I'm happy to pay a bit extra for added value and a job well done.
The thing with the IT industry is changes are rapid. In my opinion it's o.k. to give a discount occasionally. However, you cannot count on anything these days running for a very long time.
I'm in my 30's and I was only one of handful of people in school with a home computer (Vic 20 !).
Look at the younger generation now, everyone (almost) is tech savy and most people know of one 'expert' who can help them with IT issues.
Silver993tt said:
... Many of my colleagues thought we were mad not planning to make money within the first few weeks/months and couldn't see the point of working when not making any money. It's a typical short term view that's endemic in the UK.
You cannot expect to make a profit in the first few weeks /months of the majority of businesses.But, discounts are dangerous. My friend's business is flooded with calls/messages asking for him
(because his staff are not authorised to give more than a 5% discount.)
People even call and when his staff say he's not available they hang up !( how rude.)
I mean you don't call Virgin and expect to talk to Richard B! This also means he has deal with a lot of msgs and calls which should have been handled by his staff. which increases his work load.
Almost everyone knows it takes time to build your business and it's fine not to make a reasonable(or any!) profit for a year or two (or three!).
If we can talk about one thing that's endemic to the U.K.(IMHO) is poor customer service + after sales support. Our US cousins know a thing or two about customer service. I've bought books /parts /camera bits and they always call (internationally ! ) or at least email after a few days and weeks and ask if they can be of help. I walk into many shops (because I like to support independent businesses) and many times the staff do not even bother to engage with me and say at least a hello.
Most of my friends with local retail businesses offer their customers tea/coffee/biscuits and hello as well !
I do completely agree that its better to retain a god customer. I like offers which reward you if you recommend a friend. But discounting leads to haggling where the customer wants to pay the lowest price and you want to keep your margin.
I'll tell you a story about what happened in SW london many years ago.
Once upon a time there was a pound shop. A year later another one opened up across the road.
Now the owner of the first shop got worried, so he decided to make a loss on kitchen towels and sell them for below cost price (loss leader). Now the second shop seeing this, decided to lower the cost of coffee and toilet tissues. A third shop opened and the owner decided to included some below cost products as well. What did the customers do ? They bought kitchen rolls from one shop, toilet rolls and coffee from the second and other products from the third.
All three shops closed down after awhile.
Perhaps discounts are offered for multiple purchases and to reward loyalty.
But to just discount for the sake of it is dangerous (IMHO).
A company exists to make a profit. If I only service my bike and computer once a year I'm happy to pay a bit extra for added value and a job well done.
Edited by RameshUK on Friday 14th August 20:31
Edited by RameshUK on Friday 14th August 20:33
Edited by RameshUK on Friday 14th August 20:35
Silver993tt said:
If you are running a business with a long term view, you will do your utmost to keep customers. Even if this means running at a loss for a certain period of time. It's called investing in the long term.
When I started my own IT company many years ago, we never made a penny profit in the first 5 years. We didn't expect to make any money duringthis time because our plan was to build up a market share in our area of specialisation. That was 15 years ago. We now have long term clients and make reasonable margins but our business is solid. Many of my colleauges thought we were mad not planning to make money within the first few weeks/months and couldn't see the point of working when not making any money. It's a typical short term view that's endemic in the UK.
When I started my own IT company many years ago, we never made a penny profit in the first 5 years. We didn't expect to make any money duringthis time because our plan was to build up a market share in our area of specialisation. That was 15 years ago. We now have long term clients and make reasonable margins but our business is solid. Many of my colleauges thought we were mad not planning to make money within the first few weeks/months and couldn't see the point of working when not making any money. It's a typical short term view that's endemic in the UK.
Our new Barn Conversions for sale website is offering a 100% discount for the time being, ie its free. This is designed to establish ourselves as the market leaders (bit more to it than just the discount but not relevant to this thread).As far as my other companies are concerned we always offer a discount when we can esp to PH members, its a very important marketing tool IMHO
Hate to say it, but it's his business, if he finds that this way is successful then good for him. Waitrose does a "refund and replacement" service for items, which means they lose some money on that particular sale. But the customer is going to remember it and come back, and they'll spend more money next time which will easily make up for it (I know, big company not the same as a small IT one, but all big companies started off as small ones trying to grab customers and clients).
What if you persuade him that this is wrong and as a result he stops offering discounts, but then his clientele plummets, you're not exactly going to be any kind of friend to him afterwards. It's his company, not yours, so if he's making a profit and he's happy with how things are going then step back and let him do it his way.
What if you persuade him that this is wrong and as a result he stops offering discounts, but then his clientele plummets, you're not exactly going to be any kind of friend to him afterwards. It's his company, not yours, so if he's making a profit and he's happy with how things are going then step back and let him do it his way.
If he is making and keeping customers, and making some money, then he can't be going too far wrong. As my learned colleague asked earlier, never mind the discount, how much money is he making?
One good thing about discounts is that the only time you have to give them is when you make a sale. If his customers are accustomed to demanding, and getting, discounts then the answer, if he's not making enough money, is to increase the prices and keep the discounts going. I take it that what he is selling isn't easy for the customer to price (not liked sliced bread in other words)?
One good thing about discounts is that the only time you have to give them is when you make a sale. If his customers are accustomed to demanding, and getting, discounts then the answer, if he's not making enough money, is to increase the prices and keep the discounts going. I take it that what he is selling isn't easy for the customer to price (not liked sliced bread in other words)?
Discount is often built in. We sell kit at 30-40% off list (we buy at nearer 50% off list). We are happy to sell kit at cost if we need to get the deal.
The PS days to deploy are where we make money, we hardly every discount these.
I have had a problem recently with a salesman, to get a deal we discounted PS to half (we still make money) it was for a lab demo system in order to sell future kit so I supported it. However, I made it clear that it was a discount rate, the job still takes 100 days so when the customer calls and says this is taking longer than expected (ie more than 50 days) I was not happy.
So a discount is a useful tool, but you must control costs and set expectations.
The PS days to deploy are where we make money, we hardly every discount these.
I have had a problem recently with a salesman, to get a deal we discounted PS to half (we still make money) it was for a lab demo system in order to sell future kit so I supported it. However, I made it clear that it was a discount rate, the job still takes 100 days so when the customer calls and says this is taking longer than expected (ie more than 50 days) I was not happy.
So a discount is a useful tool, but you must control costs and set expectations.
RameshUK said:
I'll tell you a story about what happened in SW london many years ago.
Once upon a time there was a pound shop. A year later another one opened up across the road.
Now the owner of the first shop got worried, so he decided to make a loss on kitchen towels and sell them for below cost price (loss leader). Now the second shop seeing this, decided to lower the cost of coffee and toilet tissues. A third shop opened and the owner decided to included some below cost products as well. What did the customers do ? They bought kitchen rolls from one shop, toilet rolls and coffee from the second and other products from the third.
All three shops closed down after awhile.
Wasn't New Malden was it? Shops seem to pop up there in multiples. Like Korean Internet cafes. How can they all compete?Once upon a time there was a pound shop. A year later another one opened up across the road.
Now the owner of the first shop got worried, so he decided to make a loss on kitchen towels and sell them for below cost price (loss leader). Now the second shop seeing this, decided to lower the cost of coffee and toilet tissues. A third shop opened and the owner decided to included some below cost products as well. What did the customers do ? They bought kitchen rolls from one shop, toilet rolls and coffee from the second and other products from the third.
All three shops closed down after awhile.
One principle I always teach is that people don't want discounts- they want more for their money.
"I want to buy your product / service, but want a discount"...
"I'd love to give you a different price, but then I'd have to give you a different product / service"... which isn't what they want.
If you feel you have to give a discount, try giving them something free rather than actually discounting. Such an item would be of higher perceived value to them than it actually costs you... We've recently done it for an engineering supplies client with workboots that would retail at circa £50. In actual fact they only cost my client about £11, but its worked really well with the customers.
Try it.. it works
HTH.
Simon
"I want to buy your product / service, but want a discount"...
"I'd love to give you a different price, but then I'd have to give you a different product / service"... which isn't what they want.
If you feel you have to give a discount, try giving them something free rather than actually discounting. Such an item would be of higher perceived value to them than it actually costs you... We've recently done it for an engineering supplies client with workboots that would retail at circa £50. In actual fact they only cost my client about £11, but its worked really well with the customers.
Try it.. it works

HTH.
Simon
Rameshuk. I could equally tell you a story about a company that could actually tell its customers to use their competition and the customers would refuse to do so. Discounts are allowed to a degree but in fairness the most important factor in any business is customer service. If your customer knows they are def going to get the best hassle free service from you even if you are marginally more expensive than others they will always use you.
Companies in the uk know nothing about customer service. I've even had a situation where whilst on a site talking to a customer another member of staff from my company senior to me talked over my customer to me causing the customer to go quiet. I informed my so called colleague that i was talking to the customer and would chat to him in a minute and was informed that i would talk to him now. I promptly apologised to the customer and spoke to my colleague but was very brief and short.
Hilariously when i lef site i got a call from the company md who threatened to fire me for being rude to my "senior" colleague even though i explained why and how he had behaved.
SAdly though its what universities teach these days short term high profit over longevity. Customer service does not come into it.
Companies in the uk know nothing about customer service. I've even had a situation where whilst on a site talking to a customer another member of staff from my company senior to me talked over my customer to me causing the customer to go quiet. I informed my so called colleague that i was talking to the customer and would chat to him in a minute and was informed that i would talk to him now. I promptly apologised to the customer and spoke to my colleague but was very brief and short.
Hilariously when i lef site i got a call from the company md who threatened to fire me for being rude to my "senior" colleague even though i explained why and how he had behaved.
SAdly though its what universities teach these days short term high profit over longevity. Customer service does not come into it.
Slightly off topic, but when phoning up a Porsche dealership, I was informed that they were offering 10% discounts on servicing etc. etc.
So I booked the car in, and after collecting the car and parking overnight in the street outside my home, in the morning the same company have placed a flyer on my car offering 15% discounts on servicing etc. etc.
So I booked the car in, and after collecting the car and parking overnight in the street outside my home, in the morning the same company have placed a flyer on my car offering 15% discounts on servicing etc. etc.
Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


