Constrructive dismissal
Constrructive dismissal
Author
Discussion

Four Cofffee

Original Poster:

11,838 posts

266 months

Wednesday 19th August 2009
quotequote all
Quickie....

Does the law on ET's require you to be employed for a certain amount of time before making constructive dismissal claims? Talking to a guy today who sounds like he was bullied out of his job. I seem to recall that only the sex/race discrimination stuff applied before any probationary period /2 years were up????

JamieBeeston

9,294 posts

296 months

Wednesday 19th August 2009
quotequote all
First link in google said:
constructive dismissal

What is it?

In simple terms when an employer acts in a way that permits an employee to resign without notice and the employee has more than 1 years service he/she can make a claim of Constructive dismissal as if he/she has been unfairly dismissed.

M-J-B

15,406 posts

281 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
Constructive dismissal can be claimed at any time from day one of employment according to Mentor (employment lawyers) given the right circumstances.

Four Cofffee

Original Poster:

11,838 posts

266 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
Looks like it is 12 months unless:

Exceptions to the 1 year continuous employment are where the dismissal is for one of the following reasons:
1. Trade Union activities, carried out at an appropriate time. This is usually out of work hours or during work with the employer's permission. (This does not include strikes or working to rule, which are breaches of your contract).

2. Belonging to a trade union.

3. Refusing to join a trade union.

4. Where selection for redundancy was connected with a trade union issue.

5. Where dismissal is linked with pregnancy and maternity rights.

6. Shop or betting industry workers who object to working on Sundays.

7. Where an employee is dismissed due to Sex, Race, Age or Disability discrimination. An employee should bring a claim for discrimination, not Unfair Dismissal. If successful they are likely to receive more compensation.

8. Dismissal relating to an employee asserting their rights under employment laws.

9. Dismissal of an employee observing health & safety rules.

10. Where an employee is dismissed for acting as an employee representative or person was a candidate to become an employee representative.

11. Dismissal relating to an employee asserting their rights under the Employment Relations Act 1999, section 10, the right to be accompanied to a disciplinary or grievance hearing.

12. Dismissal related to an employee acting as a pension scheme trustee.

13. Dismissal relating to the Working Time Regulations.

14. Dismissal relating to an employee asserting their rights under the National Minimum Wage Act 1998.

15. Dismissal relating to an employee participating in protected industrial action.

16. Dismissal relating to an employee asserting their rights under the Tax Credits Act 1999.

17. Dismissal relating to an employee asserting their rights under the Part Time Workers (Prevention of Less Favourable Treatment) Regulations 2000.

18. The selection of an employee for redundancy based upon a reason which would have been automatically unfair if the same reason was used to dismiss the worker.





















M-J-B

15,406 posts

281 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
Those seem to be the circumstances wink

ruddermode

105 posts

269 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
Four Cofffee said:
This does not include strikes or working to rule, which are breaches of your contract
How can working to rule be a breach of contract? I thought it was obeying the rules to the letter, and so in theory is doing exactly what the contract requires...?

Stitch

933 posts

248 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
In summary - 12 month employment required to bring an ET claim.

Unless claim relates to one of the isms (sexism, racism etc) when it can be brought at any time. Workers on fixed term contracts also have the right to go to ET without the 12 month qualifying period under the Unfair Treatment of Fixed Term Workers Regs.

Has the employee been through a formal grievance procedure? Would normally be required to do so before raising an ET claim. The recommended procedure for handling grievances will be on the ACAS website.

Four Cofffee

Original Poster:

11,838 posts

266 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
Stitch said:
In summary - 12 month employment required to bring an ET claim.

Unless claim relates to one of the isms (sexism, racism etc) when it can be brought at any time. Workers on fixed term contracts also have the right to go to ET without the 12 month qualifying period under the Unfair Treatment of Fixed Term Workers Regs.

Has the employee been through a formal grievance procedure? Would normally be required to do so before raising an ET claim. The recommended procedure for handling grievances will be on the ACAS website.
Complicated, but the guy was made redundant after his employer folded. He had been subjected to bullying at the old employer. I think grievance was started there but the company went bust before it was resolved.

He got a new job at a new company the bully then got a new job at the next desk and took up the bullying where he left off. The bullying was mainly undermining and criticising his work in front of others and the boss, highlighting any mistakes to others (inside and outside work) and he thinks that as a result his work was then seen as an under performance. It is clear the other guy was telling the boss to lok at particular pieces of work and about incidents when he couldn't answer queries etc. He had beguun to keep a log. The new employer indicated they were not happy with his performance but accepted that they hadn't provided the right support and training. It came to a head yesterday when they said he could resign or they would sack him within his 6 months probation. He resigned and they have offered a reference which sounds bizarre!

Jasper Gilder

2,166 posts

304 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
Because of the circumstances of his leaving he has legally been sacked - but as he has only six month service he can't make an appeal to employment tribunal - much of the earlier stuff in this thread is well meaning but not fully accurate.

Unless he has been bullied for a reason which is automatically unfair, which it seems he hasn't - he doesn't have a right to claim

Making no mistakes would have given the bully no ammunition.......

Four Cofffee

Original Poster:

11,838 posts

266 months

Friday 21st August 2009
quotequote all
Jasper Gilder said:
Because of the circumstances of his leaving he has legally been sacked - but as he has only six month service he can't make an appeal to employment tribunal - much of the earlier stuff in this thread is well meaning but not fully accurate.

Unless he has been bullied for a reason which is automatically unfair, which it seems he hasn't - he doesn't have a right to claim

Making no mistakes would have given the bully no ammunition.......
I think he is realising he should have said something to the new management but the new guy quickly got his feet under the table and slid the knife in. He did defend some of his mistakes (which included his inability to answer internal enquiries promptly enough because all the files were in a pile pending the arrival of a new filing system) but he does admit he didn't do himself justice becuas e half the tiomwe was spent worrying abiout what the other guy was doing and saying behind his back.

dudleybloke

20,553 posts

217 months

Friday 21st August 2009
quotequote all
its this sort of crap that makes me glad im not an office worker.