Revenue backdate and IR35
Revenue backdate and IR35
Author
Discussion

thegreengoblet

Original Poster:

1,040 posts

247 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
I've had my last 4 1/2 years worth of Contracts reviewed and they've come back as being outside the IR35 legislation. Great. I've been offered a Tax Loss insurance against said Contracts just in case the Revenue disagree with the private review and it goes to court and I lose. I'm now wondering whether or not to get my previous batch of Contracts reviewed and protected. How far could the Revenue go back? I know you need to keep paperwork for 6 years, so is it 6 years? Or could they go back to 2000 when the legislation came into force?

LivingTheDream

1,769 posts

210 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
The revenue can investigate contracts from the last 6 years.

IIRC though there are certain circumstances when they can go back further but can only apply IR35 as far back as 2000.


Eric Mc

125,944 posts

296 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
They can go back indefinitely regarding suspected fraud cases.

They also can go back quite a way on NI investigations - over 60 years if necessary.

thegreengoblet

Original Poster:

1,040 posts

247 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies.

Not fraud. Just want to know how far back they could apply IR35 legislation should you be found to be caught inside the rules even though you legitimately felt you were outside. How far would they go back to apply the rules and calculate tax (and interest) you now owe?

On the safe side you'd cover yourself from 2000. However if I only had to cover 6 years, then I could save myslef 3 years of tax loss insurance premiums.

thegreengoblet

Original Poster:

1,040 posts

247 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
Just found the answer should anyone else be interested.

It is 7 years, made up of the current year and 6 preceeding closed years. If you cease trading, there is a 2 year enquiry window.

Eric Mc

125,944 posts

296 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
IR35 only came into being in 1998, so that's as far as they could possibly go regarding an IR35 based enquiry.

bigandclever

14,423 posts

269 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
Can I just clarify something? What kind of insurance is it: is it a payout to cover the costs of an investigation; or is it cover that, if found that you were actually caught by IR35, then the insurance will pay out whatever the 'fine' is?

thegreengoblet

Original Poster:

1,040 posts

247 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
bigandclever said:
Can I just clarify something? What kind of insurance is it: is it a payout to cover the costs of an investigation; or is it cover that, if found that you were actually caught by IR35, then the insurance will pay out whatever the 'fine' is?
Yes, pays out the tax and fines owing. Mind you, you must have the investigation insurance as well, and your contract (and working practices) must be reviewed and passed before they will offer the insurance. A (relatively) small price to pay for total security against IR35.

bigandclever

14,423 posts

269 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
thegreengoblet said:
bigandclever said:
Can I just clarify something? What kind of insurance is it: is it a payout to cover the costs of an investigation; or is it cover that, if found that you were actually caught by IR35, then the insurance will pay out whatever the 'fine' is?
Yes, pays out the tax and fines owing. Mind you, you must have the investigation insurance as well, and your contract (and working practices) must be reviewed and passed before they will offer the insurance. A (relatively) small price to pay for total security against IR35.
I'm surprised. It's fair enough that the contract(s) can be reviewed, and deemed safe, and so if you were investigated then your costs would be covered (after all, you're not caught so the only payout required would be for legal/accountancy work). But I do find it hard to believe that an insurer will cover you for work done years ago effectively on your say-so, unless they get in touch with the client(s), that the working practices were suitable for HMRC, particularly in light of the Dragonfly case.

How much are we talking for cover? My exposure to IR35 is, let's say, significant for the last few years.

thegreengoblet

Original Poster:

1,040 posts

247 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
bigandclever said:
thegreengoblet said:
bigandclever said:
Can I just clarify something? What kind of insurance is it: is it a payout to cover the costs of an investigation; or is it cover that, if found that you were actually caught by IR35, then the insurance will pay out whatever the 'fine' is?
Yes, pays out the tax and fines owing. Mind you, you must have the investigation insurance as well, and your contract (and working practices) must be reviewed and passed before they will offer the insurance. A (relatively) small price to pay for total security against IR35.
I'm surprised. It's fair enough that the contract(s) can be reviewed, and deemed safe, and so if you were investigated then your costs would be covered (after all, you're not caught so the only payout required would be for legal/accountancy work). But I do find it hard to believe that an insurer will cover you for work done years ago effectively on your say-so, unless they get in touch with the client(s), that the working practices were suitable for HMRC, particularly in light of the Dragonfly case.

How much are we talking for cover? My exposure to IR35 is, let's say, significant for the last few years.
I see what you are saying, but the Contract still forms the major basis of the case as this is the only legal document describing the working relationship. Other factors (work practices, how you run your company, and the nature of your work) simply help to convey you, your business, and how the Contract (and all it's clauses) are applicable. Basically a secondary check to ensure that you don't have Clauses in the Contract that are not applicable and are only there to guard against IR35. Just like any insurance, if you lie about something and they find out, then they won't pay out. I'm sure this is no different. For someone like me, where the legislation puts me into a grey area, it's nice to have the reassurance backing up my belief that I'm in business, to be in business.

Cover cost depends on Contract value. If you're a member of the PCG, then you can get further discounts. For modest annual contract values say up to £300k, then you'll be paying a few hundred pounds, no more than £500. If you think about it, the insurance isn't really covering huge amounts, as any tax (or fines) owed using the deemed payment would be offset against what you've already paid in Corporation Tax, PAYE, Salary's, etc.

bigandclever

14,423 posts

269 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
I guess where I'm coming from is, post-Dragonfly, it's clear that HMRC will look at every aspect of an engagement. The paper contract you have, and the working practices you undertake, still isn't necessarily enough to convince HMRC with regards to IR35 - so getting someone to insure you against a decision that doesn't go your way seems unlikely to me. We know, for instance, that most IR35 cases don't go to court because the contractor rolls over and pays. I would assume the insurance doesn't cover this. So the implication is that it goes to court, HMRC says "yes, but we're dealing with mirrored contracts" which might not have all the IR35 protection in place, won't have been reviewed by whoever, and as such you are not insured.

Although I am plonking my typical arrangement of my co -> [known contract] -> agent -> [invisible contract] -> client, which of course may be different to yours.

And I am being paranoid smile

thegreengoblet

Original Poster:

1,040 posts

247 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
bigandclever said:
I guess where I'm coming from is, post-Dragonfly, it's clear that HMRC will look at every aspect of an engagement. The paper contract you have, and the working practices you undertake, still isn't necessarily enough to convince HMRC with regards to IR35 - so getting someone to insure you against a decision that doesn't go your way seems unlikely to me. We know, for instance, that most IR35 cases don't go to court because the contractor rolls over and pays. I would assume the insurance doesn't cover this. So the implication is that it goes to court, HMRC says "yes, but we're dealing with mirrored contracts" which might not have all the IR35 protection in place, won't have been reviewed by whoever, and as such you are not insured.

Although I am plonking my typical arrangement of my co -> [known contract] -> agent -> [invisible contract] -> client, which of course may be different to yours.

And I am being paranoid smile
There are 3 main criteria surrounding self employment: Control, Substitution, and mutuality. Only one of these needs to be proven beyond doubt in your favour to remain "self employed". It seems evident to me that in the Dragonfly case was won on Control. Substitution was weak and there was no mention of mutuality. It seems that the Contractor was given a set of tasks each week. Required to attend and work 40 hours a week, with a special overtime rate when required. Seems pretty straight forward to me! The contract must have been very loose.

My arrangements are similar to yours. But, my situation is different from the Dragonfly case in many ways. My contracts are Consultancy Agreements between my company, and the Client, with the Agency as an intermediary. The substitution clauses are water tight, as are the mutuality obligations. The control aspect is pretty water tight as well although this is further bolstered by the very nature of the work - basically intellectual based where a "design task" can take anywhere from 1 to 12 months. There is no control other than progress reports. I can work where, and when I want, and for however many hours I deem necessary in order to deliver the task within a reasonable agreed time frame (contract length). I can draft in more help, or sub-contract the work out if necessary.

You are right to be paranoid though. I think most of us are. However I believe it's all about tick boxes and getting as many of them ticked in your favour as possible. For a lot of us, we simply got dragged into the grey area of IR35. You simply need to help yourself as much as possible and I believe the Revenue will leave you alone. And if they don't, be prepared to go all the way. Some of my recommendations... Get your contracts reviewed, join the PCG, have a sound Accountant, get all insurances (public, employers, professional indemnity, tax investigation, tax loss, office contents), operate professionally (business premises (or dedicated area at home), email, broadband, website, stationary, advertise for work), have a business plan, pay yourself a decent PAYE salary, have an equipment and training budget, and don't screw for everything you can possibly think of. I've had both a PAYE audit (post IR35 legislation introduction) and a VAT audit. No problems with either. The Revenue only go after weak individuals with poor practices and paperwork. Don't lose sleep, get the boxes ticked!