Holding an Irish passport (one for Eric?)
Holding an Irish passport (one for Eric?)
Author
Discussion

Kinky

Original Poster:

39,946 posts

300 months

Wednesday 9th September 2009
quotequote all
A comment that has me puzzled ....

On the N,P and E forum there is a dicussion about T.Bliar avoiding tax, by only being in the UK less than 90 days a year. And a link to the source of the subject here: http://order-order.com/2009/09/09/has-tony-gone-no...

However, what puzzles me is this comment at the end of the article:

Guido Fawkes said:
Didn’t Cherie mention that the kids all have Irish passports?
Is there a benefit of any sort by having an Irish passport over an english one? Or is it just an irrelevant comment confused

K

seaninog

513 posts

220 months

Wednesday 9th September 2009
quotequote all
I'm an Irish citizen but I've been resident in the UK for almost 14 years.

Up until Apr 2008 there was an advantage as I was classed as a non-domiciled tax resident. This wasn't peculiar to being Irish rather this was for all foreign passport holders who chose to make a country other than the UK their domicile (actually, you can't easily "choose" your domicile, you take that of your Father I believe. My father was Irish, obviously).

The advantage was that I didn't have to declare income I made outside the UK unless I brought that income onshore. All my bank accounts were in the Isle of Man, any investment I did was in an offshore tax wrapper and any income I earned outside of the UK stayed there and garnered no tax.

Our good friend Mr Brown changed the rules though and now if I wish to retain this system I have to pay £30,000 a year as a flat fee and I lose all my tax allowances. Unless you're mega wealthy it no longer pays (typical New Labour move: protect the super-rich and make the middle classes pay!).

So to answer your question to the best of my knowledge, No, there is no longer any advantage to being an Irish passport holder.

I don't know why Cherie said her kids have Irish passports. I don't even know how they'd get one - did she or Blair have an Irish grandparent? If this is the case I can only suspect it was the Football Association of Ireland that encouraged the move in case they grow up to be a bit handy ... wink

Kinky

Original Poster:

39,946 posts

300 months

Wednesday 9th September 2009
quotequote all
Feck ... I've got an Irish passport. What have I been missing out on frown

Eric Mc

125,970 posts

296 months

Wednesday 9th September 2009
quotequote all
Holding an Irish passport is seen by some as a good security measure compared to holding a UK one. The New York Times journalist who was rescued today was English but it appears he was travelling on an Irish passport - fat lot of good it did him.

I don't think Muslim extremists are impressed by waving an Irish passport at them.

seaninog

513 posts

220 months

Thursday 10th September 2009
quotequote all
Kinky said:
Feck ... I've got an Irish passport. What have I been missing out on frown
It's not just about having an Irish passport, the schemes were for those with their tax domicile outside the UK (eg in Ireland). What domicile did your Father have? If he was born and grew up in Ireland before emigrating to the UK then it's possible he has an Irish domicile in which case so can you. If you have to trace your Irish roots back to your grandfather and your father was born in the UK then it's unlikely you can claim to be domiciled in Ireland. How one selects one's "tax domicile" is actually a more complex issue than this simplistic explanation but I think that's the guts of it

In any case, it's only relevant if you have overseas income that you have already declared and have some facility to redo your tax returns for years up to 07/08 e.g. if you were under investigation. In this circumstance you could likely claim a refund. Otherwise it's a moot point because the laws have changed already.

Edited by seaninog on Thursday 10th September 10:57

JuniorD

9,013 posts

254 months

Thursday 10th September 2009
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
Holding an Irish passport is seen by some as a good security measure compared to holding a UK one. The New York Times journalist who was rescued today was English but it appears he was travelling on an Irish passport - fat lot of good it did him.
IIRC Oliver North and his cohorts closely involved in the Iran-Contra affair travelled on dodgy Irish passports.

Eric Mc said:
I don't think Muslim extremists are impressed by waving an Irish passport at them.
Absolutely - they don't seem to to take time to check passports. Wasn't the lady who was excetued in Iraq, the one who was married to an Iraqi and had dedicated her life to helping the people there, Irish? Also, an Irish passport didn't stop the capture of Brian Keenan although at best it may in conjunction with the efforts of the Irish government have helped sped his release.

Now that Ireland is complicit in all the skulduggery surrounding extraordinary rendition I can't see how it would be persuasive to a modern day extremist.


Stitch

933 posts

248 months

Thursday 10th September 2009
quotequote all
All valid - but if you held two or more passports are were in a "hot spot" you could hand one over and still leave the country if you wanted to.

Also, US has a more benevolent relationship with Eire than the UK, therefore might be a benefit of traveling on an RoI passport to the US.

How times have changed, my mother is Irish and she and her brothers travelled on RoI passports until once in the early 70s one of my uncle's had a bad experience traveling back into the UK (along the lines of being pulled to one side at passport control and detained for some time as a potential terrorist).

Perhaps pakistani etc passport holders suffer the same humiliation now.

BigBen

12,161 posts

261 months

Friday 11th September 2009
quotequote all
Is it easier to emmigrate to the USA on an Irish PP ? I ask this as I seem to meet a lot of Irish folk working over their and not necessarily in highly skilled jobs.

I have the same surname as a famous Irish poet so am sure I could prove some link if this were the case.

Ben

Eric Mc

125,970 posts

296 months

Friday 11th September 2009
quotequote all
BigBen said:
Is it easier to emmigrate to the USA on an Irish PP ? I ask this as I seem to meet a lot of Irish folk working over their and not necessarily in highly skilled jobs.

I have the same surname as a famous Irish poet so am sure I could prove some link if this were the case.

Ben
Officially, I wouldn't think so. It could even be a hindrance.

Eric Mc

125,970 posts

296 months

Friday 11th September 2009
quotequote all
As this is in the "business" forum, it should be pointed out that holding any particular passport has no real bearing on one's tax position.
Passports do not indicate tax residency status nor do they indicate country of domicile (as defined under English Law).

auditt

715 posts

215 months

Friday 11th September 2009
quotequote all
seaninog said:
I'm an Irish citizen but I've been resident in the UK for almost 14 years.

Up until Apr 2008 there was an advantage as I was classed as a non-domiciled tax resident. This wasn't peculiar to being Irish rather this was for all foreign passport holders who chose to make a country other than the UK their domicile (actually, you can't easily "choose" your domicile, you take that of your Father I believe. My father was Irish, obviously).

The advantage was that I didn't have to declare income I made outside the UK unless I brought that income onshore. All my bank accounts were in the Isle of Man, any investment I did was in an offshore tax wrapper and any income I earned outside of the UK stayed there and garnered no tax.

Our good friend Mr Brown changed the rules though and now if I wish to retain this system I have to pay £30,000 a year as a flat fee and I lose all my tax allowances. Unless you're mega wealthy it no longer pays (typical New Labour move: protect the super-rich and make the middle classes pay!).

So to answer your question to the best of my knowledge, No, there is no longer any advantage to being an Irish passport holder.

I don't know why Cherie said her kids have Irish passports. I don't even know how they'd get one - did she or Blair have an Irish grandparent? If this is the case I can only suspect it was the Football Association of Ireland that encouraged the move in case they grow up to be a bit handy ... wink
one of there grandparents are irish, but what i cant believe is, tony blaire ran this so called great country but he has another countys passport for his kids..what does that tell you?

Eric Mc

125,970 posts

296 months

Friday 11th September 2009
quotequote all
His kids are probably eligible for both.

TotalControl

8,307 posts

229 months

Sunday 13th September 2009
quotequote all
Stitch said:
Perhaps pakistani etc passport holders suffer the same humiliation now.
yes Makes you wish you never went in the first place.

However, being born in the UK, I don't really use my pakistani passport much. Still, I guess it's ok to have. Can't see any real benefits though.

JuniorD

9,013 posts

254 months

Sunday 13th September 2009
quotequote all
BigBen said:
Is it easier to emmigrate to the USA on an Irish PP ? I ask this as I seem to meet a lot of Irish folk working over their and not necessarily in highly skilled jobs.

I have the same surname as a famous Irish poet so am sure I could prove some link if this were the case.

Ben
Maybe in the Green Card lottery; IIRC Irish nationality made you eligible for it whereas British did not, or maybe it was that there were a certain number of places available in the lottery for Irish people. It may well have changed now though.

cardigankid

8,880 posts

243 months

Monday 14th September 2009
quotequote all
The bottom line is, I think, where is the best place to go if you wish to minimise your tax bill, and how do you change your domicile.

Is it sufficient to fly to Geneva, for example, stop paying UK tax and simply refuse to come back?

If you want to remain reasonably close to Europe, where is the best choice?

Monaco doesn't appeal at all - what's the difference between paying a fortune in tax and paying a fortune in rent for a property which in the normal course of events you wouldn't want to live in anyway?