Accounting Software changing to Sage from Quickbooks?
Accounting Software changing to Sage from Quickbooks?
Author
Discussion

smele

Original Poster:

1,284 posts

315 months

Wednesday 16th September 2009
quotequote all
Hi guys,

Just thought I would ask this question, thinking of changing from Quickbooks to Sage for my accounts software. This new business year I am thinking of starting a new copy of quickbooks, as there seems to be lots of erroneous entries in Quickbooks, my fault as I did not know what I was doing. I am thinking of changing to Sage for the following reasons.

1. Most accountants seem to know it better than quickbooks.
2. Office staff that I get in seem to know Sage and not quickbooks.
3. Generally people seem to prefer Sage.

Small business, less then 50 employees, few invoices, nothing really complicated.

Cheers,
smele.

Eric Mc

125,971 posts

296 months

Wednesday 16th September 2009
quotequote all
If you found processing data on Quickbooks difficult, you won't find Sage appreciably easier. Accountants and book-keepers like it because it mimics the "old fashioned" way of entering debits and credits in older manual systems. Lay people may not be so comfortable with its rather archaic aspects.

maser_spyder

6,356 posts

213 months

Wednesday 16th September 2009
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
If you found processing data on Quickbooks difficult, you won't find Sage appreciably easier. Accountants and book-keepers like it because it mimics the "old fashioned" way of entering debits and credits in older manual systems. Lay people may not be so comfortable with its rather archaic aspects.
I'll second that.

Archaic is hardly the word for both of them, they're both hopeless without training or experience (or both), and have generally the same setup.

From a laymans point of view, I found sage more cumbersome than QB, but that's not to say QB was good, just not quite so bad as sage....

There really is a gap in the market for a DECENT accounting package, that works with modern business practice rather than an antiquated double entry type ledger that the most popular systems use.

At the moment, I'm using MYOB, but that's being phased out at the moment, so not sure where we'll go next. It certainly won't be QB or sage though, unless they have a radical re-think.

We're multi-currency, multi million t/o, but relatively simple as far as book keeping goes.

If your accounting is 'really' easy, try kashflow.co.uk (ignore the naff name), it's very easy to use, and a completely different approach to sage/QB.

orbit123

305 posts

223 months

Thursday 17th September 2009
quotequote all
We're having a good look at http://www.msofficeaccounting.co.uk/ Anyone tried it?
Currently use Sage but really hate it.

Eric Mc

125,971 posts

296 months

Thursday 17th September 2009
quotequote all
Double entry book-keeping is at the core of ALL accounting systems and a good working knowledge of the principles of Debits and Credits will be of use no matter who supplies the software.

maser_spyder

6,356 posts

213 months

Thursday 17th September 2009
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
Double entry book-keeping is at the core of ALL accounting systems and a good working knowledge of the principles of Debits and Credits will be of use no matter who supplies the software.
Absolutely agree, BUT.... When software is easy to use for the layman who simply wants to register a paid invoice in or out, i.e. simple book keeping with debits and credits, sage and QB very quickly fall down.

I've had some training with it (although I'm far from expert, I know my credit from debits, and can work with journals etc. no issue), but if you're new to either package, they really are terribly designed systems.

Look at the iPhone, a very technical bit of kit, that's also very simple to use. There's no reason an accounts package should be any different. If only somebody could tell sage and QB this!

PetrolTed

34,468 posts

334 months

Thursday 17th September 2009
quotequote all
Someone pointed me at this the other day.

If it really can deliver on its promises then it will really move things on. Hosted apps are really where it's going to be in future. Ultimately that will facilitate much better data exchange between companies, easier payment etc. etc.

http://www.thisispearl.com/

Eric Mc

125,971 posts

296 months

Thursday 17th September 2009
quotequote all
maser_spyder said:
Eric Mc said:
Double entry book-keeping is at the core of ALL accounting systems and a good working knowledge of the principles of Debits and Credits will be of use no matter who supplies the software.
Absolutely agree, BUT.... When software is easy to use for the layman who simply wants to register a paid invoice in or out, i.e. simple book keeping with debits and credits, sage and QB very quickly fall down.

I've had some training with it (although I'm far from expert, I know my credit from debits, and can work with journals etc. no issue), but if you're new to either package, they really are terribly designed systems.

Look at the iPhone, a very technical bit of kit, that's also very simple to use. There's no reason an accounts package should be any different. If only somebody could tell sage and QB this!
I have never come across any package that didn't - at some point or other - force the user to have some knowledge of debits and credits. It is such a fundamental aspect of all accounts preparation that, no matter how well the programmers try to disguise the fact that underneath, the computer is handling all the entries in a double entry manner, at some point the operator will come face to face with a problem of a double entry nature.

The trick is to design the program in such a way that these double entry confrontations are kept to a minimum.