Does this Country need Health & Safety Legislation?
Does this Country need Health & Safety Legislation?
Author
Discussion

cardigankid

Original Poster:

8,880 posts

243 months

Thursday 17th September 2009
quotequote all
We can't be rude on Pistonheads these days and that seems to include questioning the value of Government led bureaucracy on a topic on that precise subject. Maybe that would be politically incorrect.

No-one would question the need to prevent children working up chimneys, and workers handling molten metal with their bare hands or being given asbestos in the sandwiches in the staff canteen. However, most of the legislation on these topics is so much shutting the stable door after the horse has bolted. Having now run short of major industrial threats to legislate against we are now down to advising people not to stand too close to dock edges. You can go nowhere these days without some gonk coming up and suggesting where it is safe to stand or walk.

Should we not run railings round the entire coastline? What about kerbs? Should we have railings there? And then again, what about the heavy metal objects travelling along the roads controlled by people. Maybe we need reinforced concrete barriers, not railings. If we are going to remove every risk that anyone can think of the sky is the limit for this 'industry'

Can I be so ignorant, obtuse and unacceptable as to suggest that every activity people engage in from the moment they get up in the morning involves risk and people in most cases need only to keep their eyes open and not do anything stupid. Furthermore, if they come unstuck, particularly doing something which common sense ought to tell you is risky, they have noone to blame but themselves. There is no legislation on earth present past and future which is going to remove this fundamental requirement.

I suggest to you good people that a great deal of the health and safety practice which is growing up around us is little more than telling people how to tie their own shoelaces. You may say, why not, it may be ludicrous, but what harm does it do?

Quite a lot. Firstly people are given to believe that if anything bad happens to them they can always claim from someone. Second people come to think that common sense is not a facility they require to exercise. Third the time and bureaucracy associated with the 'systems' is such that real hazards come and go and are not dealt with. Fourth, there is a cost to all this, which is picked up by the taxpayer and more importantly by everyone who buys British goods or services. The cost of Health & Safety, Quality, Environmental and other assorted professionals who comprise the burgeoning 'inspection industry' is a direct oncost which makes us uncompetitive in comparison with other suppliers, and that is something we cannot afford in today's global market place.

Super Slo Mo

5,374 posts

229 months

Thursday 17th September 2009
quotequote all
I must admit I do agree to a large extent. The whole H&S explosion over the last few years has served only to erode individual responsibility, and instead pave the way for the whole blame culture that's growing up around us.

It seems you can't have an accident nowadays that's your own stupid fault (and I've had more than my fair share, believe me), no, it's the fault of someone else, a corporation, the government, and the 'No Win, No Fee' lawyers are cleaning up.

The industry seems to be driven by what might happen, not what actually has happened, and while we don't want to see the return of worker exploitation of the past, there needs to be some balance, some sense.

I'll leave you with two extremes of the same situation that I've encountered fairly recently:

1: The roof at the Old Trafford Football Stadium, to access this area you need to be wearing safety boots, a hard hat, and a high vis vest. However, all walkways on the roof are 'safe working platforms' so you can't fall off the roof, unless you climb over the rails (and your hard hat ain't gonna help then!).

2: The other extreme, the Inonu Stadium, Turkey. The roof is at least as high as the one at Old Trafford, but there are NO rails, and no 'safety' equipment is required either. However, because you can just walk straight off the roof into thin air, believe me, you take much more care over your footing, where you're standing, what you're doing, than you do at the UK equivalents.

Which is better? Well, it's nice to work in an environment where you can't injure yourself, but then, are you more likely to take greater risks, or not take care at all, because the obvious dangers have been taken care of?

Lil Miss Shy

21 posts

207 months

Thursday 17th September 2009
quotequote all
Do we need legislation?

2007/2008 statistics state
2.1 million people were suffering from an illness they believed was caused or made worse by their current or past work.
229 workers were killed at work, a rate of 0.8 per 100 000 workers.
136 771 other injuries to employees were reported under RIDDOR, a rate of 517.9 per 100 000 employees.
299 000 reportable injuries occurred, according to the Labour Force Survey, a rate of 1000 per 100 000 workers.
34 million days were lost overall (1.4 days per worker), 28 million due to work-related ill health and 6 million due to workplace injury.

Individuals can be held to blame if the have acted negligently...

Besides why unnecessarily injure yourself at work (if work have not met requirements to provide safe work) there's plently of ways to do this at home... smile

Although some places blame helath and safety when in fact they are scared of being sued if something goes wrong...

bga

8,134 posts

282 months

Thursday 17th September 2009
quotequote all
Super Slo Mo said:
I must admit I do agree to a large extent. The whole H&S explosion over the last few years has served only to erode individual responsibility, and instead pave the way for the whole blame culture that's growing up around us.
I look at it in a slightly different way. It is the rise in blame (or rather claim) that means these procedures are put in place.

It also manifests itself in the service industry removing individual initiative and replacing it with "computer says no/yes". This means they can employ cheaper staff as they do not have to be so smart or highly trained. It also facilitates automation of tasks.

Four Cofffee

11,838 posts

266 months

Friday 18th September 2009
quotequote all
I heard the CEO of the HSE speak and she was pointing out that much H&FS stuff is driven by lawyers, not the HSE. Thus all the stupid stuff about cancelling community bonfires and fetes, no conkers at school etc is just the insurance companies and the organisers reacting to the possible threat of litigation. The legislation says one thing, the lawyers, HR managers and insurers over interpet.

cardigankid

Original Poster:

8,880 posts

243 months

Friday 18th September 2009
quotequote all
The blame/claim culture and H&S mania to my mind are two sides of the same phenomenon, ond none of it is sustainable. One example - an acquaintance is in a specialist NHS hospital following an injury. They would benefit from being allowed out to exercise. The staff are afraid that if they are allowed outside and hurt themselves they will be blamed. So they don't let anyone exercise outside. So the patients mobility and general state of health deteriorate.

If you have got two products and one is more expensive than the other it doesn't matter whether one is produced in a factory which meets all the latest EC and national requirements, and abounds in H&S and Quality Systems. You are going to buy the cheaper item. People do not want to pay for all this paraphernalia.

We have got away with it for years, and New Labour and the Tories before them have reduced unemployment by increasing the numbers employed in needless and inefficient bureaucracy, because they believed that the wealth the country needed would be generated by the City. And despite the credit crunch, they still do, both Labour and Tories. That is why I also consider that we are a long way from being out of this mess, because there is still a belief that banks and other financial institutions can generate wealth on a national scale by some kind of unexplained jiggery pokery, and the bottom line is that they are essentially a support service not a wealth generator, and they can't. And furthermore, to bail these financial operators out of the massive gambles they took, and try to get the whole fraudulent merry go round going again, the Government has spent our money, and proposes to get it back by raising taxes making it yet more difficult for genuinely wealth creating businesses to grow.

The real way out of this mess is less government not more, and to reduce our overheads radically by getting rid, among other things, of all this tosh.





Edited by cardigankid on Friday 18th September 09:13

Digga

48,649 posts

314 months

Friday 18th September 2009
quotequote all
It's a moot point.

Post credit crunch the economic world is a rapidly changing place where the West overall, much less the UK, holds a diminishing share of the 'pot'. Advantage is being gained by emerging economies with far looser legislative burdens - less red tape and H & S - for their businesses and we will eventually come to realise we are faced with a choise between the nanny state and all it entails, along with poverty, or reform and be slightly more proseperous.

I've always suspected that, considering the amount of time spent at work rather than at home and the fact that at home most people spend a good proportion of time either outright alseep or at least relaxing, the figures for death and injury at work are perhaps unfairly represented.

The Black Flash

13,735 posts

229 months

Friday 18th September 2009
quotequote all
Four Cofffee said:
I heard the CEO of the HSE speak and she was pointing out that much H&FS stuff is driven by lawyers, not the HSE. Thus all the stupid stuff about cancelling community bonfires and fetes, no conkers at school etc is just the insurance companies and the organisers reacting to the possible threat of litigation. The legislation says one thing, the lawyers, HR managers and insurers over interpet.
'Tis true AIUI. Most of the really stupid things I've looked into are driven by insurance agencies, worried about "potential liability". Kants.

cardigankid

Original Poster:

8,880 posts

243 months

Friday 18th September 2009
quotequote all
The constitution of the UK is of course a tailor made lawyer's playground, (particularly with the EU and the Treaty on Human Rights, which I believe that we should secede from.) It requires to be reduced to a much simpler code by someone who do not have the interests of lawyers at heart. I think the present situation will lead us into abject, not minor poverty.

jameshaworth

42 posts

227 months

Friday 18th September 2009
quotequote all
Yeah we need much more Health and Safety legislation - people are still far too responsible for their own safety.

Any injury, regardless of fault or stupidity should surely result in compensation! wink

Legmaster

1,277 posts

238 months

Saturday 19th September 2009
quotequote all
Four Cofffee said:
I heard the CEO of the HSE speak and she was pointing out that much H&FS stuff is driven by lawyers, not the HSE.
yes

Four Cofffee said:
Thus all the stupid stuff about cancelling community bonfires
http://www.hse.gov.uk/myth/oct08.htm

Four Cofffee said:
and fetes,
http://www.hse.gov.uk/myth/jul09.htm

Four Cofffee said:
no conkers at school
http://www.hse.gov.uk/myth/september.htm

Four Cofffee said:
is just the insurance companies and the organisers reacting to the possible threat of litigation. The legislation says one thing, the lawyers, HR managers and insurers over interpet.
yes
Nail:Head