Wages vs Winnings
Author
Discussion

Stevenj214

Original Poster:

4,941 posts

259 months

Friday 18th September 2009
quotequote all
Say my company gained all the necessary gambling licenses etc. Could I place a £1 bet every month at odds of my monthly salary to 1 on a surefire thing to receive my 'salary' tax free?

Eric Mc

125,972 posts

296 months

Friday 18th September 2009
quotequote all
No.

Next question.

Edited by Eric Mc on Friday 18th September 17:21

Stevenj214

Original Poster:

4,941 posts

259 months

Friday 18th September 2009
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
No.

Next question.
Why not?

Chris_w666

22,655 posts

230 months

Friday 18th September 2009
quotequote all
I would bet you another pound that HMRC would have something to say about you always winning. I also think that the gambling licence people would say no too.

Like the idea though, if you make it work can I have a job at 10000/1 per week please?

Eric Mc

125,972 posts

296 months

Friday 18th September 2009
quotequote all
Stevenj214 said:
Eric Mc said:
No.

Next question.
Why not?
Define gambling for me.

V8mate

45,899 posts

220 months

Friday 18th September 2009
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
Stevenj214 said:
Eric Mc said:
No.

Next question.
Why not?
Define gambling for me.
You must be the only Irishman who doesn't know hehe

Eric Mc

125,972 posts

296 months

Friday 18th September 2009
quotequote all
Just because I ask the question doesn't mean I don't know the answer. I'm not sure the OP understands the notion of "gambling" though.

Stevenj214

Original Poster:

4,941 posts

259 months

Friday 18th September 2009
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
Just because I ask the question doesn't mean I don't know the answer. I'm not sure the OP understands the notion of "gambling" though.
Correct, I have no idea of what "gambling" is defined as in law. To be honest, the question would probably have been better off in The Lounge given it's light hearted intendedness, but I pre-empted the mods and placed it here as it's a "business" question.

dcw@pr

3,516 posts

274 months

Friday 18th September 2009
quotequote all
OK, so how about this.

Have a monthly prize draw for your salary, which includes a question so that there is "an element of skill". You don't publicise it very well, so you are the only entrant.

Tax free?

wink

Eric Mc

125,972 posts

296 months

Friday 18th September 2009
quotequote all
Gambling involves random chance. If there was any hint that the transaction did not contain this chance element, then there is no way that iy would be construed as bona fide gambling.
There is no way any tax officer would accept such an arrangement.

Stevenj214

Original Poster:

4,941 posts

259 months

Friday 18th September 2009
quotequote all
Ok, another scenario. Are gambling profits tax free for companies? Are companies allowed to gamble? Could they take a profit of x on which tax is due, gamble in such a way that the loss is less than the tax due(i.e split the profit between all possible results) and not have to pay...

Stevenj214

Original Poster:

4,941 posts

259 months

Friday 18th September 2009
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
Gambling involves random chance. If there was any hint that the transaction did not contain this chance element, then there is no way that iy would be construed as bona fide gambling.
What if there were 2 outcomes - wages or wages plus £1. The monthly "gamble" could then consist of 2 separate bets to cover all possibilities.

dcw@pr

3,516 posts

274 months

Friday 18th September 2009
quotequote all
Stevenj214 said:
Eric Mc said:
Gambling involves random chance. If there was any hint that the transaction did not contain this chance element, then there is no way that iy would be construed as bona fide gambling.
What if there were 2 outcomes - wages or wages plus £1. The monthly "gamble" could then consist of 2 separate bets to cover all possibilities.
I'm not sure that paying a pound, then either receiving (for example) £3000 or £3001 would count as gambling in anyone's books...

Edited by dcw@pr on Friday 18th September 19:17

dcw@pr

3,516 posts

274 months

Friday 18th September 2009
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
Gambling involves random chance. If there was any hint that the transaction did not contain this chance element, then there is no way that iy would be construed as bona fide gambling.
There is no way any tax officer would accept such an arrangement.
Take my idea for the draw, but have it with 2 employees entered, and do it twice. You could therefore win either nothing, £salary or 2x£salary. If someone wins 2x, they gift half of it to the other employee

I don't see what problem HMRC could have with that?

Eric Mc

125,972 posts

296 months

Friday 18th September 2009
quotequote all
dcw@pr said:
Eric Mc said:
Gambling involves random chance. If there was any hint that the transaction did not contain this chance element, then there is no way that iy would be construed as bona fide gambling.
There is no way any tax officer would accept such an arrangement.
Take my idea for the draw, but have it with 2 employees entered, and do it twice. You could therefore win either nothing, £salary or 2x£salary. If someone wins 2x, they gift half of it to the other employee

I don't see what problem HMRC could have with that?
I can see plenty.

dcw@pr

3,516 posts

274 months

Saturday 19th September 2009
quotequote all
but my idea is a random prize draw, like a raffle but with two entrants. I don't think you get taxed on raffle tickets do you?

dcw@pr

3,516 posts

274 months

Saturday 19th September 2009
quotequote all
swerni said:
but to gain entrance in the draw they're working for you.
says who? can be anyone can enter - but then if no one else knows about it...

TooLateForAName

4,935 posts

215 months

Saturday 19th September 2009
quotequote all
That nag doesn't look too well to me. wink

Four Cofffee

11,838 posts

266 months

Sunday 20th September 2009
quotequote all
I did wonder myself how winnings can be tax free when they are in effect unearned income. Given that HMRC tax the arse off everything else I am surprised they haven't had a go at this.

Could it be that , like in horse racing, you pay the tax on the stake which makes winnings tax free? Then I wonder how TV quiz shows get on. A friend my mine recently took a very nice five figure sum away from a TV game show, all tax free.

ShadownINja

80,189 posts

313 months

Sunday 20th September 2009
quotequote all
I think it's to do with losers being able to claim losses against income...

ETA: that said, why they're being so fair is odd. They could easily just change the rules to pay for Brown's gambling debts.

Edited by ShadownINja on Sunday 20th September 11:44