Do women make good employers? Anecdotal evidence sought
Discussion
As a result of a discussion I had with someone today I decided to put this to the PH collective.
I have worked for people of the female persuasion several times ove my career, and unfortunately my experiences have been mostly negative. Hopefully this is just bad luck on my part, and it would be good to hear some balancing views.
I should add that women are amongst my most favourite people.
I have worked for people of the female persuasion several times ove my career, and unfortunately my experiences have been mostly negative. Hopefully this is just bad luck on my part, and it would be good to hear some balancing views.
I should add that women are amongst my most favourite people.
Surely it's got to be dependant on the person, not the sex. Only woman boss I have ever had was a nightmare. Very nice, but even though I had been taken on as a professional role with my own remit wanted me to prepare her reports, and could not keep her mouth shut at social occasions with others in the same profession.
Not pretty as I was seeing a secretary from my old office in semi-secret (actually her secretary also as she came from same office), and she proceeded to tell old colleagues all about us. Que "what is this I hear about us from x y x ....) For further useless info we now live together with child..
Just my experience, and completely down to individual I think.
Not pretty as I was seeing a secretary from my old office in semi-secret (actually her secretary also as she came from same office), and she proceeded to tell old colleagues all about us. Que "what is this I hear about us from x y x ....) For further useless info we now live together with child..
Just my experience, and completely down to individual I think.
I've had both male and female bosses.
My line manager is a woman, but on mat leave, so I've not had much contact. Seems a bit dizzy/fluffy but well intentioned. Her boss is also a woman and absolutely fantastic to work for - I couldn't hope for a better employer.
Of the previous female bosses/supervisors, there was one who had terrible mood swings, said one thing then did another, etc., another one who played politics very overtly and clumsily, wore very little and wanted you to be her (loyal) friend before she'd treat you well professionally, another who was very sweet, on the ball, friendly etc, but then would spend any social occasions denigrating staff to her/their superiors behind their backs, she could be extremely personal, and what she did was sometimes very effective at harming her targets' professionally, and another female boss who used to have screaming fits and was so tight over staff equipment, pay etc, that it practically ruined her business (including rationing PPE, and explicitly ordering staff to short clients).
My line manager is a woman, but on mat leave, so I've not had much contact. Seems a bit dizzy/fluffy but well intentioned. Her boss is also a woman and absolutely fantastic to work for - I couldn't hope for a better employer.
Of the previous female bosses/supervisors, there was one who had terrible mood swings, said one thing then did another, etc., another one who played politics very overtly and clumsily, wore very little and wanted you to be her (loyal) friend before she'd treat you well professionally, another who was very sweet, on the ball, friendly etc, but then would spend any social occasions denigrating staff to her/their superiors behind their backs, she could be extremely personal, and what she did was sometimes very effective at harming her targets' professionally, and another female boss who used to have screaming fits and was so tight over staff equipment, pay etc, that it practically ruined her business (including rationing PPE, and explicitly ordering staff to short clients).
I have worked directly for a few in my time, and to be honest the experience left me quite polarised straight into the anti camp. When I was consulting I worked with a mainly female group and if a situation started going rapidly south, the tears would start flowing, there would be closed doors and hugging sessions. And as mentioned not one iota of discretion between the lot of them. And these were allegedly "professionals"
Similar instance with the shirtlifters in higher positions, but they are much much worse in the pointless b
hiness and machinations than women will ever be.
I think moving out of that type of work and into a very male dominated workforce was the best thing I ever did.
Similar instance with the shirtlifters in higher positions, but they are much much worse in the pointless b
hiness and machinations than women will ever be.I think moving out of that type of work and into a very male dominated workforce was the best thing I ever did.
The women I have had as bosses have usually been hard work. It's quite odd as alpha-men tend to behave in a different way. It's more of a case of being the big dog, rather than having to prove it. I'd say quite a few of my lady pyramid climbers have male pattern brains and the same attributes as their male counterparts. They cut it the same. I have had women bosses trying to dominate me more than their male counterparts. It (and I try and say this in the nicest possible way) seems due to some sort of inferiority.
Some of the best bosses have been women, but they are usually older and less neurotic.
My game used to be teaching and in the job, there are a fair few wet, feminine minded men, the few big dogs are rare, on the contrary, there are a lot of assertive women kicking around (someone needs to push the wet men around).
The difference, as I see it is as follows.
Men tend to be more task orientated and are less likely to get distracted by petty personal things, like power struggles.
Most women are the reverse.
In my experience, this doesn't seem to affect performance.
It would be interesting to see how a power woman manages non-power women.
Some of the best bosses have been women, but they are usually older and less neurotic.
My game used to be teaching and in the job, there are a fair few wet, feminine minded men, the few big dogs are rare, on the contrary, there are a lot of assertive women kicking around (someone needs to push the wet men around).
The difference, as I see it is as follows.
Men tend to be more task orientated and are less likely to get distracted by petty personal things, like power struggles.
Most women are the reverse.
In my experience, this doesn't seem to affect performance.
It would be interesting to see how a power woman manages non-power women.
had a right b
h of a boss, lets describe her as an asian who came over from the villages some place on the continent, she got some degree and married some tard, when was working for her, she was undergoing divorce as he wanted a younger model
she was weird already and then totally lost the plot
had another woman for a boss, as a school leaver I should have been trained in the specifics of the job and was stupid for not knowing stuff that had never come across before etc.....single woman, way too ugly to pull and with a personality that matched
h of a boss, lets describe her as an asian who came over from the villages some place on the continent, she got some degree and married some tard, when was working for her, she was undergoing divorce as he wanted a younger modelshe was weird already and then totally lost the plot
had another woman for a boss, as a school leaver I should have been trained in the specifics of the job and was stupid for not knowing stuff that had never come across before etc.....single woman, way too ugly to pull and with a personality that matched
depends on situation of course, in my trade (collision repair) blokes are blokes and prima donna's don't last long before getting a flank Drive aimed at their head. Its quite refreshing to have a massive verbal stoush then laugh about it later over a beer after work. Sure beats listening to some whiny colleague crying over the s
tty choices she constantly makes!
tty choices she constantly makes!Having worked in or around the creative industries for most of my career, I can spot whether a piece of design was created by a man (more lateral thought, more dynamic) or a woman (very good but quite reserved).
In my experience, blokes tend to be fairly straight forward in business whereas women can be exceptionally complex characters in a business scenario. It’s not simply about who’s better, just that we’re different but I have to say I dislike the need to often walk on eggshells when dealing with the ladies.
In my experience, blokes tend to be fairly straight forward in business whereas women can be exceptionally complex characters in a business scenario. It’s not simply about who’s better, just that we’re different but I have to say I dislike the need to often walk on eggshells when dealing with the ladies.
I spent some time working for a woman, it wasn't a good experience but I think that was down the person (and being 3 sheets to the wind most days). Her replacement was a right plonker, even worse than she was so being a crap boss isn't gender specific. Or is it..... I oversee one business with a very high percetage of female staff. The issues they can come up with are mindblowing and absolutely pointless. I have been known to encourage them all to go out the back and talk to each other to sort stuff out, you know the way blokes do!!! My god it's much easier that way...
Gassing Station | Business | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




