Reclaiming bank charges ?
Reclaiming bank charges ?
Author
Discussion

RobPhoboS

Original Poster:

3,454 posts

257 months

Tuesday 29th September 2009
quotequote all
I'm not sure if this is the right forum but seems close enough.
I've had charges from Natwest at various points over the last few years, and I'm wondering what the situation is on bank charges and reclaiming from this currently?
Obviously I've looked at : http://www.moneysavingexpert.com/reclaim/bank-char...
But not sure how up-to-date that is.

RRH

619 posts

278 months

Tuesday 29th September 2009
quotequote all
Whilst proceedings are stayed at this point in time, you still need to get your claim in. If you were to win in court you'd be entitled to 8% interest too- this is running whilst the stay is in place- so, in theory, the money they owe you is earning 8% interest!

Also have a look here http://www.consumeractiongroup.co.uk/forum/natwest...

Hope this helps!

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 29th September 2009
quotequote all
Mr Tourette?

B Oeuf

39,731 posts

315 months

Tuesday 29th September 2009
quotequote all
Judges to decide in October

siscar

6,887 posts

248 months

Tuesday 29th September 2009
quotequote all
Am I alone in thinking this is wrong? You enter into an agreement, that agreement includes charges in certain circumstances, those circumstances occur and you get charged. I really don't see the problem.

OnTheOverrun

3,965 posts

208 months

Tuesday 29th September 2009
quotequote all
siscar said:
Am I alone in thinking this is wrong? You enter into an agreement, that agreement includes charges in certain circumstances, those circumstances occur and you get charged. I really don't see the problem.
You are correct only if those charges or penalties are legal under English law. If they are not legal or are mis-sold, you may not be liable for them.

B Oeuf

39,731 posts

315 months

Tuesday 29th September 2009
quotequote all
siscar said:
Am I alone in thinking this is wrong? You enter into an agreement, that agreement includes charges in certain circumstances, those circumstances occur and you get charged. I really don't see the problem.
Banks are dropping their charges already in preperation of the anticipated verdict that they are, indeed, overcharging. The fact that all banks charge roughly the same amount makes it kind of difficult to avoid as well.

Engineer1

10,486 posts

240 months

Tuesday 29th September 2009
quotequote all
The bit that made the charges look unfair is that lets say you have £50 in your account and 3 bills come out, all on the same day the values are £50.01 £10 and £5, now by my reconing that comes to £15.01 overdrawn and one charge, some banks took the highest first meaning that you got charged for 3 overdrawn transactions.

RobPhoboS

Original Poster:

3,454 posts

257 months

Wednesday 30th September 2009
quotequote all
Appreciate the advice and practical input.

son of a vette

405 posts

246 months

Wednesday 30th September 2009
quotequote all
swerni said:
B Oeuf said:
siscar said:
Am I alone in thinking this is wrong? You enter into an agreement, that agreement includes charges in certain circumstances, those circumstances occur and you get charged. I really don't see the problem.
Banks are dropping their charges already in preperation of the anticipated verdict that they are, indeed, overcharging. The fact that all banks charge roughly the same amount makes it kind of difficult to avoid as well.
And in return we will see the end of free banking.

So the end result is we all end up paying for those who are incapable of balancing their account.

Sorry if this comes across as a bit harsh, but why should I pay for someone else's mistakes.
Because banking has never been "Free" it all has costs, and at the moment the banks are covering their costs by charging people these fees.

By saying you signed up to these terms, therefor you should lie down and accept these charges, what other option do you have, you need a bank account to live, all bank accounts apply these penalty charges on people, no other industry has the power to charge you when they like, however much they like.

B Oeuf

39,731 posts

315 months

Wednesday 30th September 2009
quotequote all
swerni said:
son of a vette said:
swerni said:
B Oeuf said:
siscar said:
Am I alone in thinking this is wrong? You enter into an agreement, that agreement includes charges in certain circumstances, those circumstances occur and you get charged. I really don't see the problem.
Banks are dropping their charges already in preperation of the anticipated verdict that they are, indeed, overcharging. The fact that all banks charge roughly the same amount makes it kind of difficult to avoid as well.
And in return we will see the end of free banking.

So the end result is we all end up paying for those who are incapable of balancing their account.

Sorry if this comes across as a bit harsh, but why should I pay for someone else's mistakes.
Because banking has never been "Free" it all has costs, and at the moment the banks are covering their costs by charging people these fees.

By saying you signed up to these terms, therefor you should lie down and accept these charges, what other option do you have, you need a bank account to live, all bank accounts apply these penalty charges on people, no other industry has the power to charge you when they like, however much they like.
If you abide by the terms of the contract you sign with the bank then banking is free.
swerni, you've seen two sides of a valid argument, some cannot avoid going over the limit slightly, especially those in financial difficulty, to charge them is fair but to charge them dis[proportionately isn't. It's just like riding a bike in a convoy, you have to ride at the slowest riders pace, or the speed limit to limit damage to those who can't drive as well as others.
There's plenty of justifiable reasons to argue against these things but you can't argue against human nature, especially greed. wink

The banks have been taking the piss

Edited by B Oeuf on Wednesday 30th September 11:31

Kermit power

29,622 posts

244 months

Wednesday 30th September 2009
quotequote all
swerni said:
son of a vette said:
swerni said:
B Oeuf said:
siscar said:
Am I alone in thinking this is wrong? You enter into an agreement, that agreement includes charges in certain circumstances, those circumstances occur and you get charged. I really don't see the problem.
Banks are dropping their charges already in preperation of the anticipated verdict that they are, indeed, overcharging. The fact that all banks charge roughly the same amount makes it kind of difficult to avoid as well.
And in return we will see the end of free banking.

So the end result is we all end up paying for those who are incapable of balancing their account.

Sorry if this comes across as a bit harsh, but why should I pay for someone else's mistakes.
Because banking has never been "Free" it all has costs, and at the moment the banks are covering their costs by charging people these fees.

By saying you signed up to these terms, therefor you should lie down and accept these charges, what other option do you have, you need a bank account to live, all bank accounts apply these penalty charges on people, no other industry has the power to charge you when they like, however much they like.
If you abide by the terms of the contract you sign with the bank then banking is free.
That's possibly so, but with most contracts, the other party doesn't get so much freedom to interpret the terms as they see fit.

I used to take the exact same view you do. I used to have a go at Mrs Kermit before we were married for allowing herself to get into the position of being charged these fees from time to time.

Then I had a look at her statements. The scenarios which absolutely changed my view looked something like the following:

1. Having a payment for £22 returned because it would've taken her £5 over her overdraft.
2. Being charged £30 for the returned payment.
3. Being charged a further £30 for exceeding her overdraft by £13, as a result of the original charge of £30 for the returned payment.

As a result of them playing it this way, she ended up £43 over her overdraft limit and paying £60 in charges. I would've accepted them either returning the payment and charging her once, or honouring the payment and charging her once, but to charge her, and then charge her again because they've charged her can't possibly be fair?

Having seen that, I got her to send off for every single bank statement from the previous 6 years, and went through every single page of them. I found 5 scenarios like the above where she had been charged a penalty, then charged another penalty as a result of the first penalty being applied.

I wrote to the bank outlining these 5 examples, stating that they were unfair and asking them to refund the excess fees - £150 in total. The bank point blank refused. They wouldn't even make a gesture of goodwill by offering a token percentage.

So I took the case to the Banking Ombudsman, at which point the bank promptly made an offer to refund every single charge they'd made in the previous 6 years plus interest, just to avoid the case going to court.

They could've accepted that they'd been unreasonable with £150 of charges, and that would've been an end of it. Instead, they ended up refunding well over £3,000, and even I thought that my wife's financial irresponsibility had justified 95% of that! hehe

Ask yourself this. If the bank didn't know with absolute certainty that they were in the wrong, why would they have paid out thousands of pounds to prevent me taking them to court? You might argue it's to save them legal costs in the long run, but that doesn't hold up to scrutiny, as it would only require them to set precedent, and it would become much easier for them in the future. They just expected the precedent to be set against them, so they relied on the vast majority of people not taking them to court, and paid off those who started proceedings to do so.

son of a vette

405 posts

246 months

Wednesday 30th September 2009
quotequote all
swerni said:
son of a vette said:
swerni said:
B Oeuf said:
siscar said:
Am I alone in thinking this is wrong? You enter into an agreement, that agreement includes charges in certain circumstances, those circumstances occur and you get charged. I really don't see the problem.
Banks are dropping their charges already in preperation of the anticipated verdict that they are, indeed, overcharging. The fact that all banks charge roughly the same amount makes it kind of difficult to avoid as well.
And in return we will see the end of free banking.

So the end result is we all end up paying for those who are incapable of balancing their account.

Sorry if this comes across as a bit harsh, but why should I pay for someone else's mistakes.
Because banking has never been "Free" it all has costs, and at the moment the banks are covering their costs by charging people these fees.

By saying you signed up to these terms, therefor you should lie down and accept these charges, what other option do you have, you need a bank account to live, all bank accounts apply these penalty charges on people, no other industry has the power to charge you when they like, however much they like.
If you abide by the terms of the contract you sign with the bank then banking is free.
The actual act of banking is not "free", managing the account, paying the tellers, processing payments for the various card companies, processing direct debits all have costs attached to them.

The reason you think it is free is currently the banks don't pass on these charges to the end user, they use different methods to get their costs back, one of which is charging people these O/d fees etc. If these fees are deemed illegal, then the banks will have to follow a traditional service industry structure, charge people for that service.

It's a bit like assuming the mobile phone you got for "free" on an 18 month contract is free, it's not, the company selling you this will get their cut some way or another. After all they aren't a non profit charity

sleep envy

62,260 posts

280 months

Wednesday 30th September 2009
quotequote all
son of a vette said:
swerni said:
B Oeuf said:
siscar said:
Am I alone in thinking this is wrong? You enter into an agreement, that agreement includes charges in certain circumstances, those circumstances occur and you get charged. I really don't see the problem.
Banks are dropping their charges already in preperation of the anticipated verdict that they are, indeed, overcharging. The fact that all banks charge roughly the same amount makes it kind of difficult to avoid as well.
And in return we will see the end of free banking.

So the end result is we all end up paying for those who are incapable of balancing their account.

Sorry if this comes across as a bit harsh, but why should I pay for someone else's mistakes.
Because banking has never been "Free" it all has costs, and at the moment the banks are covering their costs by charging people these fees.

By saying you signed up to these terms, therefor you should lie down and accept these charges, what other option do you have, you need a bank account to live, all bank accounts apply these penalty charges on people, no other industry has the power to charge you when they like, however much they like.
balance your account and don't spend what you don't have = no charges

it's not difficult

B Oeuf

39,731 posts

315 months

Wednesday 30th September 2009
quotequote all
sleep envy said:
son of a vette said:
swerni said:
B Oeuf said:
siscar said:
Am I alone in thinking this is wrong? You enter into an agreement, that agreement includes charges in certain circumstances, those circumstances occur and you get charged. I really don't see the problem.
Banks are dropping their charges already in preperation of the anticipated verdict that they are, indeed, overcharging. The fact that all banks charge roughly the same amount makes it kind of difficult to avoid as well.
And in return we will see the end of free banking.

So the end result is we all end up paying for those who are incapable of balancing their account.

Sorry if this comes across as a bit harsh, but why should I pay for someone else's mistakes.
Because banking has never been "Free" it all has costs, and at the moment the banks are covering their costs by charging people these fees.

By saying you signed up to these terms, therefor you should lie down and accept these charges, what other option do you have, you need a bank account to live, all bank accounts apply these penalty charges on people, no other industry has the power to charge you when they like, however much they like.
balance your account and don't spend what you don't have = no charges

it's not difficult
Clearly it is, or we wouldn't be having this debate, neither would both the High Court and the Court of Appeal rule that bank charges are subject to fairness rules and the Office of Fair Trading has decided that, provisionally, it agrees.

sleep envy

62,260 posts

280 months

Wednesday 30th September 2009
quotequote all
B Oeuf said:
Clearly it is, or we wouldn't be having this debate
one wonders how people clothe and feed themselves if that is such a troublesome task to manage

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Wednesday 30th September 2009
quotequote all
swerni said:
son of a vette said:
swerni said:
son of a vette said:
swerni said:
B Oeuf said:
siscar said:
Am I alone in thinking this is wrong? You enter into an agreement, that agreement includes charges in certain circumstances, those circumstances occur and you get charged. I really don't see the problem.
Banks are dropping their charges already in preperation of the anticipated verdict that they are, indeed, overcharging. The fact that all banks charge roughly the same amount makes it kind of difficult to avoid as well.
And in return we will see the end of free banking.

So the end result is we all end up paying for those who are incapable of balancing their account.

Sorry if this comes across as a bit harsh, but why should I pay for someone else's mistakes.
Because banking has never been "Free" it all has costs, and at the moment the banks are covering their costs by charging people these fees.

By saying you signed up to these terms, therefor you should lie down and accept these charges, what other option do you have, you need a bank account to live, all bank accounts apply these penalty charges on people, no other industry has the power to charge you when they like, however much they like.
If you abide by the terms of the contract you sign with the bank then banking is free.
The actual act of banking is not "free", managing the account, paying the tellers, processing payments for the various card companies, processing direct debits all have costs attached to them.

The reason you think it is free is currently the banks don't pass on these charges to the end user, they use different methods to get their costs back, one of which is charging people these O/d fees etc. If these fees are deemed illegal, then the banks will have to follow a traditional service industry structure, charge people for that service.

It's a bit like assuming the mobile phone you got for "free" on an 18 month contract is free, it's not, the company selling you this will get their cut some way or another. After all they aren't a non profit charity
Right now as a consumer,for me, banking is free. ie I pay nothing for it.
That will change due to peoples inability to manage their accounts.

What you are talking about are the cost associated with delivering a service.

If your going to be pedantic at least do it properly wink
+1

How on earth did banks survive before they decided to add £30 charges to people eh?

They did it the good old fashioned way of charging people interest to borrow money and investing the monies saved with them and their own assets to get a return.

They still do that now!

Charges amount to a tiny fraction of a bank's income - even a fraction of the profit they make, charges make no relevance to staffing at all.

Kermit power

29,622 posts

244 months

Wednesday 30th September 2009
quotequote all
JustinP1 said:
swerni said:
son of a vette said:
swerni said:
son of a vette said:
swerni said:
B Oeuf said:
siscar said:
Am I alone in thinking this is wrong? You enter into an agreement, that agreement includes charges in certain circumstances, those circumstances occur and you get charged. I really don't see the problem.
Banks are dropping their charges already in preperation of the anticipated verdict that they are, indeed, overcharging. The fact that all banks charge roughly the same amount makes it kind of difficult to avoid as well.
And in return we will see the end of free banking.

So the end result is we all end up paying for those who are incapable of balancing their account.

Sorry if this comes across as a bit harsh, but why should I pay for someone else's mistakes.
Because banking has never been "Free" it all has costs, and at the moment the banks are covering their costs by charging people these fees.

By saying you signed up to these terms, therefor you should lie down and accept these charges, what other option do you have, you need a bank account to live, all bank accounts apply these penalty charges on people, no other industry has the power to charge you when they like, however much they like.
If you abide by the terms of the contract you sign with the bank then banking is free.
The actual act of banking is not "free", managing the account, paying the tellers, processing payments for the various card companies, processing direct debits all have costs attached to them.

The reason you think it is free is currently the banks don't pass on these charges to the end user, they use different methods to get their costs back, one of which is charging people these O/d fees etc. If these fees are deemed illegal, then the banks will have to follow a traditional service industry structure, charge people for that service.

It's a bit like assuming the mobile phone you got for "free" on an 18 month contract is free, it's not, the company selling you this will get their cut some way or another. After all they aren't a non profit charity
Right now as a consumer,for me, banking is free. ie I pay nothing for it.
That will change due to peoples inability to manage their accounts.

What you are talking about are the cost associated with delivering a service.

If your going to be pedantic at least do it properly wink
+1

How on earth did banks survive before they decided to add £30 charges to people eh?

They did it the good old fashioned way of charging people interest to borrow money and investing the monies saved with them and their own assets to get a return.

They still do that now!

Charges amount to a tiny fraction of a bank's income - even a fraction of the profit they make, charges make no relevance to staffing at all.
You may have added a +1, but you're actually disagreeing with Swerni! hehe

hsv123

233 posts

214 months

Wednesday 30th September 2009
quotequote all
what a lot of peeople forget is the banks are a business. they charge you for there services. now if you go over you limit and use there "money" how can you complain about it after wards? i feel most people think that having a bank account is something that is given to you at birth. like its your right to have one. well it isnt!!! if you want a bank account you have to stick to the t/c no point complaing afterwards!

son of a vette

405 posts

246 months

Wednesday 30th September 2009
quotequote all
Actually 25 years ago everyone paid a fee for their account, it was only the Anglia bank that initially offered a fee free banking service, whilst introducing charging for errors.

The banks do make the majority of their money from traditional banking, lend at a higher rate than you pay for the money. Banks are estimated to make £1.5Bn from charging each year, a huge figure.

Before I end up in a constant cyclical debate, I think people should manage their accounts correctly, but then if everyone did that, the £1.5Bn would dry up and the banks would come looking for this money elsewhere (probably fee's for accounts).
I'd much rather see an up-front fee for your banking and pay a fair price for the service you receive


Edited by son of a vette on Wednesday 30th September 13:54