Is £12,000 a bit excessive as a website quote?
Is £12,000 a bit excessive as a website quote?
Author
Discussion

E36Rob

753 posts

221 months

Friday 2nd October 2009
quotequote all
Yes, i would say that price is way OTT.

Does the quote include anything else, such as maintenance fee's for a year or include hosting etc?

There is many many companies out there that would bite your arm off if you was to even pay 1/2 that fee!

I myself am not a fan of flash websites in any form, i would look more down the route of a normal coded website with flash components if thats what you need. It will be much easier for you to manage should you need to make changes if the designer is not available.

Also i believe that Google will find it hard to index your website properly if its totally flash built, which could loose potential business from the Internet.

klimakool

592 posts

206 months

Friday 2nd October 2009
quotequote all
too much, too much too much

i'm getting mine done just now, buying all the names, data, internet space, pictures, info the lot all being designed by a friend of mine and coming in at way under £1000 and my site isnt exactly too basic

Fittster

20,120 posts

244 months

Friday 2nd October 2009
quotequote all
Is the idea to get multiple quotes to see what the general market thinks the price should be?

Dupont666

22,987 posts

223 months

Friday 2nd October 2009
quotequote all
Before we all jump to conclusions and you refuse the work for your website to this cowgirl style website builder that gives us normal code monkeys a bad name....

Can you please ask for a complete breakdown and estimated leadtime off this legit (her friends) company, then we can all have a laugh at what she thinks is a resonable price and leadtimes.

Maybe ask if there was a finders fee included in your quote?

TimCrighton

996 posts

247 months

Friday 2nd October 2009
quotequote all
I know a marketing assistant looking for a job!

Seriously, if she's that incompetant she wouldn't be working for me anymore. I'd be offended she'd think I was that stupid.

Slurms

1,254 posts

235 months

Friday 2nd October 2009
quotequote all
I think your "marketing assistant" is taking the P*ss

£12k for a basic website is crazy.

£1.2k maybe..

V8mate

45,899 posts

220 months

Friday 2nd October 2009
quotequote all
The problem is, that there's a gulf between students who are happy to do this kind of stuff for some beer/holiday money (but don't bother calling them back to fix anything becasue they'll be touring India/away at Uni etc) and commercial outfits who offer some kind of warranty and continuation of service.

Creating a website can range from easy to complex, but ensuring that you are fully briefed by the client can take ages! Additionally, who will be responsible for providing all the copy for the pages, how many iterations does the price include, will the services of a graphic designer be required for some elements etc etc. Time is money and time is not only spent on the first build.

You have to ask yourself, however, what do you want your website to do for your company? Will it be an income generator in its own right? Will it be persuasive in bringing in new customers?

Twelve grand is nothing in today's commercial service market. If you get a good product with good support and an obviously commited contractor, I'd say it's well worth the money.

nsmith

34 posts

208 months

Friday 2nd October 2009
quotequote all
Seems a tad ridiculous to me! We don't work on fully flash websites (bad for seo etc) but for something that style with a built in cms we'd be quoting around £1k tops, and then probably around £50 - £100/m to design and send newsletters (based on how many subscribers you have). So for a year you'd be looking around the £2k mark! I've worked in big companies where we've got quotes back for all singing all dancing ecommerce websites that were only in the range of £7 - 8k with some of the more reputable companies.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Friday 2nd October 2009
quotequote all
IL_JDM said:
,... as the company she has contacted turns out to be a friend of hers... ]
There's the key my friend.

It is for precisely this reason that most companies have rules about staff making deals with friends outside the company, even if you are just putting something through the till of a shop.

She may have told them "It's in the bag, quote what you like..."

By all means she could have got a couple or three quotes from companies from the same specification sheet, and *then* told you that she has a friend in the industry and would it be alright to see if they can offer a better deal...

nsmith

34 posts

208 months

Friday 2nd October 2009
quotequote all
IL_JDM said:
Dupont666 said:
Before we all jump to conclusions and you refuse the work for your website to this cowgirl style website builder that gives us normal code monkeys a bad name....

Can you please ask for a complete breakdown and estimated leadtime off this legit (her friends) company, then we can all have a laugh at what she thinks is a resonable price and leadtimes.

Maybe ask if there was a finders fee included in your quote?
Website design, time, images etc £10k
Flash Animation £2k
HTML newsletter £1k

I don't want to really divulge too much into detail, but that's the overall summary (even though I would have thought the first 2 would come under 1).

I used to make websites myself, purely as a hobby, probably cost me a couple of weekends in man-hours and hosting was around £10 a month, plus £20 a year for domains.

I would have though a business hosting solution would cost around £50 a month (we probably get maximum 1,000 hits a day), newsletter once every month, 20 email accounts, already own domain names and would need to be able to manage this through the back end.

Though I'm capable of this, I imagine the boss will want one of these 'control panel styles' where he (or even an untrained monkey) could log in and update the 'projects' or 'news' section.
£10k for design?! Who the hell are they paying to do that!

Hosting wise for 1k hits a day you could safely manage to pay about £15/20 a month for hosting!

Website management wise, it might sound common but wordpress or textpattern are very powerful tools that websites can sit on top of and like you said any monkey can update them.

Slate99

2,270 posts

216 months

Friday 2nd October 2009
quotequote all
You must be joking - I've just finised a site which included Design, some animation, Content management system, Blogs, Forum, Podcasts, Videos, Newsletters. for £1400.

JustinP1

13,364 posts

261 months

Friday 2nd October 2009
quotequote all
IL_JDM said:
Dupont666 said:
Before we all jump to conclusions and you refuse the work for your website to this cowgirl style website builder that gives us normal code monkeys a bad name....

Can you please ask for a complete breakdown and estimated leadtime off this legit (her friends) company, then we can all have a laugh at what she thinks is a resonable price and leadtimes.

Maybe ask if there was a finders fee included in your quote?
Website design, time, emails, domains, hosting, images etc £10k
Flash Animation & website management via control panel £2k
HTML newsletter management £1k

I don't want to really divulge too much into detail, but that's the overall summary (even though I would have thought the first 2 would come under 1).

I used to make websites myself, purely as a hobby, probably cost me a couple of weekends in man-hours and hosting was around £10 a month, plus £20 a year for domains.

I would have though a business hosting solution would cost around £50 a month (we probably get maximum 1,000 hits a day), newsletter once every month, 20 email accounts, already own domain names and would need to be able to manage this through the back end.

Though I'm capable of this, I imagine the boss will want one of these 'control panel styles' where he (or even an untrained monkey) could log in and update the 'projects' or 'news' section.

Edited by IL_JDM on Friday 2nd October 09:57
For £2500 a US company built two flash sites for us.

One has a 15 second completely bespoke cartoon animation as flash and a fully flash animated site.

jamieboy

5,932 posts

260 months

Friday 2nd October 2009
quotequote all
nsmith said:
£10k for design?! Who the hell are they paying to do that!
That's pretty much what it comes down to.

From what you've described there are no real technical challenges, so it all comes down to design. Good design costs money, it's up to you to decide from their portfolio whether they're 10 times better than a student who'd do it for £1k, or twice as good as some other company who might do it for £5k.

Slate99

2,270 posts

216 months

Friday 2nd October 2009
quotequote all
jamieboy said:
nsmith said:
£10k for design?! Who the hell are they paying to do that!
That's pretty much what it comes down to.

From what you've described there are no real technical challenges, so it all comes down to design. Good design costs money, it's up to you to decide from their portfolio whether they're 10 times better than a student who'd do it for £1k, or twice as good as some other company who might do it for £5k.
Design costs money but paying that much is ridiculous - I know excellent graphic designers who charge 1.2k for a fully designed website. I am not talking students either. Well respected and good designers.

nsmith

34 posts

208 months

Friday 2nd October 2009
quotequote all
jamieboy said:
nsmith said:
£10k for design?! Who the hell are they paying to do that!
That's pretty much what it comes down to.

From what you've described there are no real technical challenges, so it all comes down to design. Good design costs money, it's up to you to decide from their portfolio whether they're 10 times better than a student who'd do it for £1k, or twice as good as some other company who might do it for £5k.
Heh, I've worked with designers charging over the £10k mark for designs but not for something described as "basic and minimalist" even some of the more talented designers wouldn't be charging near £10k for a few pages. When you consider that really the site is going to be one page with different content, it's not like it's going to be a completely custom design for each page!

Slurms

1,254 posts

235 months

Friday 2nd October 2009
quotequote all
IL_JDM said:
Dupont666 said:
Before we all jump to conclusions and you refuse the work for your website to this cowgirl style website builder that gives us normal code monkeys a bad name....

Can you please ask for a complete breakdown and estimated leadtime off this legit (her friends) company, then we can all have a laugh at what she thinks is a resonable price and leadtimes.

Maybe ask if there was a finders fee included in your quote?
Website design, time, emails, domains, hosting, images etc £10k
Flash Animation & website management via control panel £2k
HTML newsletter management £1k

I don't want to really divulge too much into detail, but that's the overall summary (even though I would have thought the first 2 would come under 1).

I used to make websites myself, purely as a hobby, probably cost me a couple of weekends in man-hours and hosting was around £10 a month, plus £20 a year for domains.

I would have though a business hosting solution would cost around £50 a month (we probably get maximum 1,000 hits a day), newsletter once every month, 20 email accounts, already own domain names and would need to be able to manage this through the back end.

Though I'm capable of this, I imagine the boss will want one of these 'control panel styles' where he (or even an untrained monkey) could log in and update the 'projects' or 'news' section.

Edited by IL_JDM on Friday 2nd October 09:57
It just doesn't add up for the size of site your talking about and as others have said - avoid flash, it's old technology and doesn't work with the search engines.

What your looking for isn't rocket science and even if you go with a company that offers an extensive support package I still think there are substantial savings to be made.

bonsai

2,015 posts

211 months

Friday 2nd October 2009
quotequote all
Since this includes hosting as well, remember to factor that in. If your site gets 30,000 hits a month then you will need a fairly decent hosting setup, and they don't come particularly cheap.

jamieboy

5,932 posts

260 months

Friday 2nd October 2009
quotequote all
IL_JDM said:
The logic is simple but admittedly the graphics/designs are pretty mindblowing.

Still, not £12,000 worth.
How does their design compare to the other companies she's contacted, and what are the other companies charging?

She has got more than one quote, not just the one from her mate's company, hasn't she?

Slate99

2,270 posts

216 months

Friday 2nd October 2009
quotequote all
IL_JDM said:
bonsai said:
Since this includes hosting as well, remember to factor that in. If your site gets 30,000 hits a month then you will need a fairly decent hosting setup, and they don't come particularly cheap.
1,000 currently.
you pay £1000 a month on hosting yikes I would say you could get that down to £400-£500 with a similar spec server.

Slate99

2,270 posts

216 months

Friday 2nd October 2009
quotequote all
IL_JDM said:
HAHA, no, 1,000 hits a month,
Pheew! I think 12k for a site that gets 1,000 hits a month - is completly unrealistic and uneconomical.