Self-employed vs employed
Self-employed vs employed
Author
Discussion

bitwrx

Original Poster:

1,352 posts

235 months

Saturday 3rd October 2009
quotequote all
A company offered a potential employee a three month contract on a salary of £X.

Potential employee returned and said "Yes, X seems doable. Here's a suggestion though: I'm currently self-employed. As it's only 3 months, shall I remain self employed and just bill you every month. It'll make no odds for me and save you the hassle of getting me on the books for what is after all a relatively short time. Obviously I'd want a bit more on the daily rate." (mentions sum, quickly refuted as 'too much').

Meeting concludes with agreement that potential employer will look at the figures and draft a contract.

Contract arrives. Potential contractor is happy with most of the terms, especially the paid holiday pro-rata for the 3 months and paid bank holidays that fall in the time. Understands that as a contractor, he would be ineligible for any pension or bonus which an employee would be entitled to.

On looking at the daily rate, he discovers that the potential employers have taken X and divided it by the 13 weeks that the potential contractor will be employed, arriving at a daily rate of X/(13*5).

So, potential contractor thinks hmmm, how exactly am I better off than if I had accepted the salary of £X as an employee? Apart from offsetting some of my petrol against my income tax liability, I am not. And yet my potential employer has saved the cost of setting up and contributing to a pension, has removed me from any bonus scheme that may be operating, and has saved their Employer's NI contribution (worth nearly 10% of my potential salary according to HMRC).

What has the potential contractor missed? Being fairly young, he is fairly new to all this so is not entirely sure how it all works. Is this usually how it works? Are they hoping his youth corresponds to a certain naivety?

If he hasn't missed anything, how does he broach the subject of asking for a higher rate, and on what should he base the higher rate?

The potential contractor would appreciate the benefit of any similar experiences people on here may have had.

TIA.

Eric Mc

125,975 posts

296 months

Sunday 4th October 2009
quotequote all
Are you saying the self-employed individual is being paid for holiday time?

On what grounds does the self-employed individual think that self-employment status applies to this particular engagement?

bitwrx

Original Poster:

1,352 posts

235 months

Sunday 4th October 2009
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
Are you saying the self-employed individual is being paid for holiday time?
Yes. Odd I agree, but this is the case.

Does this affect the self-employed status of the contractor?

Eric Mc said:
On what grounds does the self-employed individual think that self-employment status applies to this particular engagement?
He will be sending the company to which he is supplying his services a bill at the end of every month. He will be supplying products and services to other companies during the same time period. The contractor will rectify any errors or omissions at his own expense.

I think the last one is what actually clinches it (according to HMRC. Just spent ages looking for the page I swear I saw earlier but can now no longer find.).


Mattt

16,664 posts

249 months

Sunday 4th October 2009
quotequote all
Does the employer understand the full saving - from what I've seen not all HR bods understand the full cost/tax liabilities of an employee.

Or maybe they fully understand, and hope you/your mate doesn't.

bitwrx

Original Poster:

1,352 posts

235 months

Sunday 4th October 2009
quotequote all
Mattt said:
Does the employer understand the full saving - from what I've seen not all HR bods understand the full cost/tax liabilities of an employee.

Or maybe they fully understand, and hope you/your mate doesn't.
I'm nudging toward the latter. But what exactly are the savings to them of employing a contractor over an employee? The contractor in question thinks he's got a fairly good handle on it, but isn't sure if he's missed anything. Any ideas?

Eric Mc

125,975 posts

296 months

Sunday 4th October 2009
quotequote all
bitwrx said:
Eric Mc said:
Are you saying the self-employed individual is being paid for holiday time?
Yes. Odd I agree, but this is the case.

Does this affect the self-employed status of the contractor?

Eric Mc said:
On what grounds does the self-employed individual think that self-employment status applies to this particular engagement?
He will be sending the company to which he is supplying his services a bill at the end of every month. He will be supplying products and services to other companies during the same time period. The contractor will rectify any errors or omissions at his own expense.

I think the last one is what actually clinches it (according to HMRC. Just spent ages looking for the page I swear I saw earlier but can now no longer find.).
Being paid for holidays is something the Revenue would normally take as being a badge of EMOPLOYMENT. Anyone who wants to prove their Self Employment status would normally want to show that they are NOT paid for holidays (or illness as well, for that matter).

Producing a "bill" for the work done is neither here nor there.

Having other bona fide "customers" is very helpful but in itself, may not convince HMRC that his relationship with THIS company is part of his Self Employed activities.

I would seriously look at removing the agreement to pay him on holiday time. It is a bit of a time bomb I would suggest.

bitwrx

Original Poster:

1,352 posts

235 months

Sunday 4th October 2009
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
bitwrx said:
Eric Mc said:
Are you saying the self-employed individual is being paid for holiday time?
Yes. Odd I agree, but this is the case.

Does this affect the self-employed status of the contractor?

Eric Mc said:
On what grounds does the self-employed individual think that self-employment status applies to this particular engagement?
He will be sending the company to which he is supplying his services a bill at the end of every month. He will be supplying products and services to other companies during the same time period. The contractor will rectify any errors or omissions at his own expense.

I think the last one is what actually clinches it (according to HMRC. Just spent ages looking for the page I swear I saw earlier but can now no longer find.).
Being paid for holidays is something the Revenue would normally take as being a badge of EMOPLOYMENT. Anyone who wants to prove their Self Employment status would normally want to show that they are NOT paid for holidays (or illness as well, for that matter).

Producing a "bill" for the work done is neither here nor there.

Having other bona fide "customers" is very helpful but in itself, may not convince HMRC that his relationship with THIS company is part of his Self Employed activities.

I would seriously look at removing the agreement to pay him on holiday time. It is a bit of a time bomb I would suggest.
Ta Eric. My accountant friend is a bit too junior in his career to know all this stuff yet.

jimmyb

12,254 posts

247 months

Sunday 4th October 2009
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
bitwrx said:
Eric Mc said:
Are you saying the self-employed individual is being paid for holiday time?
Yes. Odd I agree, but this is the case.

Does this affect the self-employed status of the contractor?

Eric Mc said:
On what grounds does the self-employed individual think that self-employment status applies to this particular engagement?
He will be sending the company to which he is supplying his services a bill at the end of every month. He will be supplying products and services to other companies during the same time period. The contractor will rectify any errors or omissions at his own expense.

I think the last one is what actually clinches it (according to HMRC. Just spent ages looking for the page I swear I saw earlier but can now no longer find.).
Being paid for holidays is something the Revenue would normally take as being a badge of EMOPLOYMENT. Anyone who wants to prove their Self Employment status would normally want to show that they are NOT paid for holidays (or illness as well, for that matter).

Producing a "bill" for the work done is neither here nor there.

Having other bona fide "customers" is very helpful but in itself, may not convince HMRC that his relationship with THIS company is part of his Self Employed activities.

I would seriously look at removing the agreement to pay him on holiday time. It is a bit of a time bomb I would suggest.
Eric i would think it comes down to how holiday is paid. If invoiced as work time even though tech on holiday to the company then IR will be none the wiser. TBH even if invoiced as holiday they still most likely would take no notice not on a short 3month contract anyway though personally would err on caution and go work/holiday invoice.

Eric Mc

125,975 posts

296 months

Sunday 4th October 2009
quotequote all
You can get away with anything as long as you don't tell the truth. I think they call it "lying"smile

Of course, if HMRC don't notice the fact that the individual is being paid when he is on holidays then the problem may not surface.

I would certainly be reluctant to make any mention of such an arrangement in any contracts being written up for people hired on a Self Employed basis.

Edited by Eric Mc on Sunday 4th October 16:27

jimmyb

12,254 posts

247 months

Sunday 4th October 2009
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
You can get away with anything as long as you don't tell the truth. I think they call it "lying"smile

Of course, if HMRC don't notice the fact that the individual is being paid when he is on holidays then the problem may not surface.

I would certainly be reluctant to make any mention of such an arrangement in any contracts being written up for people hired on a Self Employed basis.

Edited by Eric Mc on Sunday 4th October 16:27
Completely agree that would be somewhat stupid and i expect even Incompetant Retards wouldnt miss it

Edited by jimmyb on Sunday 4th October 18:10

RizzoTheRat

29,169 posts

223 months

Sunday 4th October 2009
quotequote all
I'd steer well clear of that contract. Not only are you going to end up with less money than if full time employed, the holiday and other bits mean you're going to get shafted by IR35. Take a look at the financial profile calculator to get an idea of the difference that makes http://www.contractorcalculator.co.uk/Calculators....

Eric Mc

125,975 posts

296 months

Sunday 4th October 2009
quotequote all
RizzoTheRat said:
I'd steer well clear of that contract. Not only are you going to end up with less money than if full time employed, the holiday and other bits mean you're going to get shafted by IR35. Take a look at the financial profile calculator to get an idea of the difference that makes http://www.contractorcalculator.co.uk/Calculators....
IR35 only applies if the individual is operating through his own limited company or a partnership. It DOES NOT apply to self employed individuals.