How far back can you re-claim income tax?
How far back can you re-claim income tax?
Author
Discussion

timskipper

Original Poster:

1,306 posts

297 months

Monday 12th October 2009
quotequote all
So my ex-accountants (you'll see why they're ex shortly) just sent me a breakdown of my director's loan account for the 2008/2009 year so they can finish off the year-end accounts and finally end their interest in running my affairs.

It didn't look right, so I did my own calcs and found they'd overstated my drawings by £1,700. Ok so this confirms I did the right thing in sacking them and they'll correct the error, but this got my mind whirring.

So I pulled my accounts for 2001/2002 (the first year they did for me) and re-did the same calcs. It looks to me like they've overstated that years drawings by £15,000.

Umm, that's a very broken calculator!

So question for the resident experts; if indeed this is the case, and the accounts for that year recorded a dividend far in excess of what was required, then this would have had a knock on effect on every year thereafter, as dividends were raised to clear down a director's loan account based on, it seems, wildly inaccurate figures.

It seems quite likely doesn't it that I've paid income tax on those divis, which could have been avoided?

So how far back can you re-submit tax returns to sort this out? Anyone know?

I ended up getting 4 grand back a couple of years ago as they'd cocked up the allocation of dividends between me and another shareholder. :rollseyes:


Eric Mc

125,978 posts

296 months

Monday 12th October 2009
quotequote all
Simple answer is six years.

What leads you to believe that they have overstated your "drawings"?

What leads you to believe that they have overstated your Dividends?

Have they allocated payments made by your company to you in error when they should have been treated as business costs? If so, they could also have overstated the company's business profits - so the company could have paid exccess Corporation Tax.

Were you a higher rate taxpayer in any of the years in dispute?





Edited by Eric Mc on Monday 12th October 11:42

timskipper

Original Poster:

1,306 posts

297 months

Monday 12th October 2009
quotequote all
Hi Eric

Well I've got detailed records of every personal withdrawal I've made from this company. So for the given year I've added those up for each month and subtracted my net PAYE salary and agreed expenses for that month. What's left is what I beleive should be entered into the Director's Loan account as debits.

Then at the end of the tax year a dividend should have been made to cover these non-PAYE non-Expenses amounts, thus reducing the director's loan account to zero by way of a credit equaling the dividend.

In the sample year, the accounts show a dividend was paid and that the director's loan account had an outstanding overdrawn balance of £13,700.

In reality, adding the dividend amount to the actual loan account balance leaves a outstanding balance of approx £1,300 in credit. So that years dividend was £1,300 more than it needed to have been.

...so then the following year was started with a £13,700 overdrawn balance and the next lot of dividends would have been allocated to clear this and any other drawings for that year, and so on.

Am I making sense?

edited to add, yes in the sample year I was a higher rate tax payer, the following year I think I was just under the threshold.

Edited by timskipper on Monday 12th October 11:54

Eric Mc

125,978 posts

296 months

Monday 12th October 2009
quotequote all
And were you a higher rate taxpayer in any of those years?

timskipper

Original Poster:

1,306 posts

297 months

Monday 12th October 2009
quotequote all
you beat my edit... yes in the sample year I was a higher rate tax payer, the following year I think I was just under the threshold.

Eric Mc

125,978 posts

296 months

Monday 12th October 2009
quotequote all
From a personal tax point of view, you do not pay any tax on dividends unless you were in the Higher Rate brackets in the relevant year. So, in any year where you were NOT a higher rate tax payer, you will not have paid any tax on the dividends allocated to you so submitting an amended Self Assessment return will achieve nothing - apart from maybe drawing HMRC's attention to your affairs - or the affairs of the company.

There might be more mileage to be gained from re-examining the accounts to see if the company's business expenditure was understated in any given year.

timskipper

Original Poster:

1,306 posts

297 months

Monday 12th October 2009
quotequote all
Thanks Eric.

Whilst I have nothing to fear from having HMRC take another look I'd sooner not wake the beast unless absolutely necessary!

I'm thinking the simplest solution might be to re-visit the director's loan account from the beginning and see what the real balance is at 05/04/2009, then revisit any declared dividends for that year, which they've still to finalise, and the current year if necessary to ensure I end up with a proper zero balance on 04/04/2010.

But it still irks me that in some years I'd have paid some income tax on un-necessary dividends since I have tended to dip in and out of higher rate over the years.