2 xbox 360's , 1 router, numpty dad question
2 xbox 360's , 1 router, numpty dad question
Author
Discussion

siwil1

Original Poster:

1,022 posts

260 months

Saturday 26th December 2009
quotequote all
Hi guys... Help !

NO.2 son now has a 360 in his bedroom along with no.1 son also having one in his.

They are both complaining that the connection to xbox live is poor, Now is this our broadband which is struggling or is the poor old netgear 54mbps the weak link?

The xbox's are hard wired not wireless, we also have a ps3 which is hard wired aswell.

New broadband or new router? Any recommendations truely welcome so as to return to peace and harmony over christmas!!

Cheers

Salgar

3,285 posts

213 months

Saturday 26th December 2009
quotequote all
siwil1 said:
Hi guys... Help !

NO.2 son now has a 360 in his bedroom along with no.1 son also having one in his.

They are both complaining that the connection to xbox live is poor, Now is this our broadband which is struggling or is the poor old netgear 54mbps the weak link?

The xbox's are hard wired not wireless, we also have a ps3 which is hard wired aswell.

New broadband or new router? Any recommendations truely welcome so as to return to peace and harmony over christmas!!

Cheers
What speed is your current broadband (actual speed not what they sell to you speed)? Who from?
I doubt it is a problem with the router, especially as you are both hard wired. If only one of you is playing is it okay? What about if one is playing Xbox and one is playing PS3 (both online)?

if it is still a problem when one is xbox, one is ps3, it is definitely your internet connection.
It is probably your internet connection either way as your router should be able to handle the speed. If you do subsequently upgrade your internet you might need a new router anyway but that's a separate issue.

tim2100

6,288 posts

286 months

Saturday 26th December 2009
quotequote all
Is this only a problem since adding 2nd XBOX?

franv8

2,212 posts

267 months

Saturday 26th December 2009
quotequote all
Be careful with this one. Internet speed is only relevant for downloads, the real enemy for online play is lag (or 'ping' or 'latency')

I'm guessing your router plugs into a broadband modem of sorts via ethernet. One of my friends (Gixer) comes round sometimes armed with his 360, we got some lag using his 360 plugged into my Belkin router, which was in turn plugged into a BT Gnomehub. The solution was to plug both XBoxes into the two Ethernet ports provided on the Gnomehub.

Every item you put into the chain will increase lag. It could still be an external problem, but it might be worth trying to connect directly if the number of ports on your modem allows you to.

NTH

siwil1

Original Poster:

1,022 posts

260 months

Saturday 26th December 2009
quotequote all
cheers for the replies.

How do I check actual speed rather than sold speed? we are with AOL from years ago so not on contract or anything so could change easily enough. no AOL software is installed on any computers.

I think from reading above our problem could be that only one ethernet cable serves upstairs and is then split via a box of tricks to the 2 xbox's and a pc. I need to run a seperate cable for the 2nd xbox for best effect if i'm correct.

Cheers for the replies

scorp

8,783 posts

258 months

Saturday 26th December 2009
quotequote all
Try to avoid to many boxes (clients) using wifi at the same time, it adds a good 20ms or so latency to your connection which is significant for online action games, it also gets saturated very easily with 2-3 machines using wifi at the same time. I would say connection as many consoles via wired ethernet is the way to go.

Also you mention AOL, it's been a while since i used AOL (like 7 years or so) but back then they had horrible quality of service for online gaming...

Edited by scorp on Saturday 26th December 17:29

JamesNotJim

755 posts

215 months

Saturday 26th December 2009
quotequote all
http://www.speedtest.net/ Will give you your interent speed.

Have you not considered getting the wireless attachments for the 360s, makes life easier and no cable mess

siwil1

Original Poster:

1,022 posts

260 months

Saturday 26th December 2009
quotequote all
2.16 download 0.33upload ping 57

not sure what that all means tho!


edited to add that was whilst ps3 and 1 xbox playing plus this pc

Edited by siwil1 on Saturday 26th December 21:36

franv8

2,212 posts

267 months

Sunday 27th December 2009
quotequote all
Sounds very reasonable and with a low ping (that's the 52ms number) I don't think you'll have much trouble your end. What was the PC connected to? ( I.e was it a comparable connection method)

franv8

2,212 posts

267 months

Sunday 27th December 2009
quotequote all
Sounds very reasonable and with a low ping (that's the 52ms number) I don't think you'll have much trouble your end. What was the PC connected to? ( I.e was it a comparable connection method)

siwil1

Original Poster:

1,022 posts

260 months

Thursday 7th January 2010
quotequote all
Just like to close off threads in case someone uses it for reference.

I Ran a 2nd Ethernet cable upstairs to the second xbox and now all is well again !

Thanks for all your help

Tiggsy

10,261 posts

281 months

Thursday 7th January 2010
quotequote all
SOunds right - i run 2 xboxs and a PS3 all hard wired and get no issues.