Battle Of Britain
Author
Discussion

HOGEPH

Original Poster:

5,249 posts

216 months

Friday 8th January 2010
quotequote all
Just watched the film. And the question presents itself.

How many of today's 18 and 19 year olds could have done that?


V8mate

45,899 posts

219 months

Friday 8th January 2010
quotequote all
HOGEPH said:
Just watched the film. And the question presents itself.

How many of today's 18 and 19 year olds could have done that?
All the ones who are currently out in war zones?

mickk

30,476 posts

272 months

Friday 8th January 2010
quotequote all
None of them, due to the snow.

Balmoral Green

42,561 posts

278 months

Friday 8th January 2010
quotequote all
Given the circumstances, the training and the opportunity, lots!

Just like the 18 and 19 year olds currently losing their lives for a far less worthy cause in the middle east.

DJC

23,563 posts

266 months

Friday 8th January 2010
quotequote all
You mean fly?

With suitable training...er most of them.

The_Burg

4,853 posts

244 months

Friday 8th January 2010
quotequote all
WFH today, watched 'Reach for the Skies', if it's even vaguely true Douglas Bader was one hell of a cool bloke in his day.

grumbledoak

32,571 posts

263 months

Friday 8th January 2010
quotequote all
The_Burg said:
WFH today, watched 'Reach for the Skies', if it's even vaguely true Douglas Bader was one hell of a cool bloke in his day.
He was a "mixed bag", from what I've read. Losing his legs was pretty much an act of stupidity, and he was stubborn and opinionated. A hero, undoubtedly, but in real life it was not that simple.

The Hypno-Toad

13,310 posts

235 months

Friday 8th January 2010
quotequote all
The_Burg said:
WFH today, watched 'Reach for the Skies', if it's even vaguely true Douglas Bader was one hell of a cool bloke in his day.
Urban legend is that he was such a good fighter pilot because he had no legs. He didn't suffer so much from the g forces & the blood rushing away from his brain in tight turns.

750turbo

6,164 posts

254 months

Friday 8th January 2010
quotequote all
grumbledoak said:
The_Burg said:
WFH today, watched 'Reach for the Skies', if it's even vaguely true Douglas Bader was one hell of a cool bloke in his day.
He was a "mixed bag", from what I've read. Losing his legs was pretty much an act of stupidity, and he was stubborn and opinionated. A hero, undoubtedly, but in real life it was not that simple.
Read his biog a few times when I was younger, cracking read.

But as you say he seemed to be a bit of a tosser, given what he went through, surely still a top bloke though?

grumbledoak

32,571 posts

263 months

Friday 8th January 2010
quotequote all
750turbo said:
surely still a top bloke though?
A hero, undoubtedly, as I said. But it would be a mistake to imagine him as a real life 'Ace' Rimmer.

V8mate

45,899 posts

219 months

Friday 8th January 2010
quotequote all
grumbledoak said:
750turbo said:
surely still a top bloke though?
A hero, undoubtedly, as I said. But it would be a mistake to imagine him as a real life 'Ace' Rimmer.
More like Hairspray; a novice rimmer?

The_Burg

4,853 posts

244 months

Friday 8th January 2010
quotequote all
750turbo said:
grumbledoak said:
The_Burg said:
WFH today, watched 'Reach for the Skies', if it's even vaguely true Douglas Bader was one hell of a cool bloke in his day.
He was a "mixed bag", from what I've read. Losing his legs was pretty much an act of stupidity, and he was stubborn and opinionated. A hero, undoubtedly, but in real life it was not that simple.
Read his biog a few times when I was younger, cracking read.

But as you say he seemed to be a bit of a tosser, given what he went through, surely still a top bloke though?
No idea of the truth behind the legend, but if it was even partly true he deserves respect.
Arrogant cock? Fair play, the reality lived up to the legend so justified.

(Any way was a damn good film truth or not, makes you wonder why modern films are so st, quite liked the rusty rivets etc, probably very close to the truth of how real fighter planes were).

cazzer

8,883 posts

278 months

Friday 8th January 2010
quotequote all
Now guy gibson on the other hand....
Bloody Decent Chap.

mattmoxon

5,026 posts

248 months

Friday 8th January 2010
quotequote all
HOGEPH said:
Just watched the film. And the question presents itself.

How many of today's 18 and 19 year olds could have done that?
With modern Jet fighters lots of them.

Matt

Wacky Racer

41,363 posts

277 months

Friday 8th January 2010
quotequote all
In my opinion "The Battle of Britain" film was crap...naff acting, but a few very good dogfight scenes

Far better "Angels one five" from 1952 with Jack Hawkins and John Gregson......

silverthorn2151

6,400 posts

209 months

Friday 8th January 2010
quotequote all
The Battle of Britain is brilliant and Bader has always been one of my heros.

Don't forget he ended up in Colditz for pissing off 'Ze Germans'. That scores points in my book!

Skywalker

3,269 posts

244 months

Friday 8th January 2010
quotequote all
silverthorn2151 said:
The Battle of Britain is brilliant and Bader has always been one of my heros.

Don't forget he ended up in Colditz for pissing off 'Ze Germans'. That scores points in my book!
My Bold.

EFA - It's "The Boche" or "The Hun".
Thank you.

Eric Mc

125,709 posts

295 months

Friday 8th January 2010
quotequote all
Wacky Racer said:
In my opinion "The Battle of Britain" film was crap...naff acting, but a few very good dogfight scenes

Far better "Angels one five" from 1952 with Jack Hawkins and John Gregson......
I think it's quite a good film actually. There are a few things that grate - like the Susannah York/Chritsopher Plummer sub plot - but it essentially tells the true story of the battle.

And the bulk of pilots who flew in the Battle were not 18/19 year olds. Most of them were 21 to 27 years old or thereabouts - many of them (like Bader) pliots who had joined the RAf in the 1930s.

Crafty_

14,140 posts

230 months

Friday 8th January 2010
quotequote all
silverthorn2151 said:
The Battle of Britain is brilliant and Bader has always been one of my heros.

Don't forget he ended up in Colditz for pissing off 'Ze Germans'. That scores points in my book!
I read a great story, after the war some of the most famous RAF fighter pilots were invited to some sort of luftwaffe reunion, one couldn't make it so a couple of them (I think Sailor Malan and Al Deere) persuaded Bader to go, who was somewhat reluctant.. eventually he gave in. There were in a hotel bar on a balcony above the main bar, Bader wandered over to the railing, looked over, shook his head and said "My god, I never realised how many of the buggers we missed" hehe I don't think he ever made his peace with his former opponents.

Edited by Crafty_ on Friday 8th January 22:54

Athlon

5,916 posts

236 months

Friday 8th January 2010
quotequote all
J.E.Johnson was the man, Bader was a hero no doubt but was out of the war for a long time due to getting shot down, Johnson was in the thick of it right through, try and find a copy of his book, it is a fantastic read and very candid, it was refreshing to hear a combat pilot speaking about his opponant with such high regard, especially Galland(sp?)