Gas boiler - which is more efficient?
Gas boiler - which is more efficient?
Author
Discussion

Merlot

Original Poster:

4,121 posts

230 months

Sunday 10th January 2010
quotequote all
House with poor energy efficency (no insulation in walls or under floor, single glazed sash windows and tall ceilings). The once up to temperature, the house loses 1-2°c per hour if the heating is turned off and will fall back to 10-12°c.

Which is best?

1/ Running the boiler for 2 hours @ 50°c temperature. (Boiler cycles roughly 3 mins on, 4 mins off).
2/ Running the boiler for 1 hour @ 80°c temperature. (Boiler doesn't cycle, constantly burning gas).

I always thought running it cooler for longer would be more efficient - the radiators are always warm and the gas is being burnt only about 40-50% of the time.

However, I have been told that running the boiler on its max setting for a shorter period would be more efficient, as even though it is burning gas the entire time, this works out less than the constant starting cycles it has to do under example 1/.


bananapieface

403 posts

196 months

Sunday 10th January 2010
quotequote all
Or run the boiler 24/7

Stat set to 21degs 6am -9pm

18degs 9pm - 6am

Merlot

Original Poster:

4,121 posts

230 months

Sunday 10th January 2010
quotequote all
bananapieface said:
Or run the boiler 24/7

Stat set to 21degs 6am -9pm

18degs 9pm - 6am
Ah, but no stat (yet). It is a hypothetical question that boils down to:

Would a boiler that cycles 50% off, 50% on burn more gas than if it were on 100% of a fixed period of time.