Sky vs Virgin - technology wise
Sky vs Virgin - technology wise
Author
Discussion

Puggit

Original Poster:

49,832 posts

279 months

Monday 11th January 2010
quotequote all
Well I've no idea where to post this. If I put it in the lounge, it will be moved to the wrong sub-forum. I've seen Sky threads in the TV, film and Radio forum and some threads moved to the Home cinema + Hifi section. Here goes...

We've received an enticing deal for Sky subscribers to move to Virgin (free HD box and free HD for a year). Sky aren't interested in keeping us, we've checked (well they offered a free HD box, but no free subscription).

But which box is better? I've no experience of the Virgin technology - but we have Sky+ at home.

Thanks smile

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Monday 11th January 2010
quotequote all
Bear in mind that if you wants Sports in HD you must be with Sky.

digitise

179 posts

242 months

Monday 11th January 2010
quotequote all
....or Sky movies HD. Virgin only have a handful of HD channels. On the upside, you can record two channels whilst watching a third, and the broadband (if you dont already have it) is more reliable

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Monday 11th January 2010
quotequote all
digitise said:
....or Sky movies HD. Virgin only have a handful of HD channels. On the upside, you can record two channels whilst watching a third, and the broadband (if you dont already have it) is more reliable
The three tuner thing seems handy, however I can usually get round that by recording two on the digibox and watching freeview.

boobles

15,251 posts

246 months

Monday 11th January 2010
quotequote all
hornetrider said:
Bear in mind that if you wants Sports in HD you must be with Sky.
confused Why? I have Virgin Media & all my sky sports channels are in HD.

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Monday 11th January 2010
quotequote all
boobles said:
hornetrider said:
Bear in mind that if you wants Sports in HD you must be with Sky.
confused Why? I have Virgin Media & all my sky sports channels are in HD.
Sky Sports HD? Want to check again?

okgo

42,373 posts

229 months

Monday 11th January 2010
quotequote all
boobles said:
hornetrider said:
Bear in mind that if you wants Sports in HD you must be with Sky.
confused Why? I have Virgin Media & all my sky sports channels are in HD.
They aren't.

Virgin have about 4 HD channels, none of them are movies or sport.

Mr Will

13,719 posts

237 months

Monday 11th January 2010
quotequote all
Biggest plus point to Virgin is that your box will do all the on-demand stuff (iPlayer, 4OD, etc) rather than having to use your PC.

Plus the internet connections can be rather quick.

The downside is that the menus on the box are far less slick and much slower to load than the sky ones.

BliarOut

72,863 posts

270 months

Monday 11th January 2010
quotequote all
Virgin isn't affected by the weather like Sky can be. The on demand is excellent yes

mouseymousey

2,642 posts

268 months

Monday 11th January 2010
quotequote all
okgo said:
boobles said:
hornetrider said:
Bear in mind that if you wants Sports in HD you must be with Sky.
confused Why? I have Virgin Media & all my sky sports channels are in HD.
They aren't.

Virgin have about 4 HD channels, none of them are movies or sport.
They do have ESPN HD which is handy for the occasional premiership match, but that's about it.

I have no first hand experience of Sky but I've often heard it said that the Virgin box does a better job of upscaling the SD channels.

Puggit

Original Poster:

49,832 posts

279 months

Monday 11th January 2010
quotequote all
We don't subscribe to Sports or Movies - we used to have Sports, but Mrs Puggit lost it when she tried to blag some free months by threatening to cancel it. They called her bluff banghead

The list of HD channels on V seems to be:

BBC HD
C4 HD
ESPN HD
FX HD
Living HD
MTVN HD
National Geographic HD

The Sky broadband router is the bane of my life, looking forward to ditching that!
Is the recorder reliable (Sky often cuts off the end of programmes), is there something like Series link?

pmanson

13,388 posts

284 months

Monday 11th January 2010
quotequote all
We've had it for a couple of years now..

Works well, occasionally the box is a bit unresponsive but most of the time it's fine.

Useful to be able to record two channels at once on the V+ service. We also have a second box (non v+) upstairs for an additional £5 per/month.

On-Demand is great and a lot of it is now in HD.

We don't bother with sports or movies. Although I did watch the Man U game in HD at the weekend and it looked great (50" LG)

boobles

15,251 posts

246 months

Monday 11th January 2010
quotequote all
Sorry guys, my mistake. So if you do have a HD box through VirginMedia, SkySports & such can not be viewed in HD?

pmanson

13,388 posts

284 months

Monday 11th January 2010
quotequote all
boobles said:
Sorry guys, my mistake. So if you do have a HD box through VirginMedia, SkySports & such can not be viewed in HD?
Not sure.

I'm hoping Virgin will do a deal and get ITV HD before the summer ready for the world cup.

Apart from that we've never really thought it was worth the money to get the Sports and Movie channels.

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Monday 11th January 2010
quotequote all
pmanson said:
boobles said:
Sorry guys, my mistake. So if you do have a HD box through VirginMedia, SkySports & such can not be viewed in HD?
Not sure.

I'm hoping Virgin will do a deal and get ITV HD before the summer ready for the world cup.

Apart from that we've never really thought it was worth the money to get the Sports and Movie channels.
Sky Sports HD is not available on the Virgin platform. Interestingly, ITV HD is available on Sky with a common hack.

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Monday 11th January 2010
quotequote all
V+ shuts the RF outputs down if you use HDMI, so if you're feeding remote televisions, that will stop working.

Puggit

Original Poster:

49,832 posts

279 months

Monday 11th January 2010
quotequote all
What about comparison of disk size?

And I believe Virgin fix the box, unlike Sky that make you own it!?

pmanson

13,388 posts

284 months

Monday 11th January 2010
quotequote all
Puggit said:
What about comparison of disk size?

And I believe Virgin fix the box, unlike Sky that make you own it!?
The V+ can take about 80hrs of SD programming. HD obviously takes up a lot more space.

With Virgin you rent the box (either by paying an upfront cost or by paying £10 a month subscription).

I had a problem with ours last year where it kept freezing up. Arranged for an engineer to come out to fix it and when he got there it was working fine. He still replaced it without question.

callyman

3,197 posts

243 months

Monday 11th January 2010
quotequote all
Plotloss said:
V+ shuts the RF outputs down if you use HDMI, so if you're feeding remote televisions, that will stop working.
That is true, but the only downside imo.
And as previously said the On demand (all free on XL pacakage) is brilliant.

aberdeeneuan

1,436 posts

209 months

Monday 11th January 2010
quotequote all
We've had V+ for about 5 months now, connected in full glorious HD (on the few channels they offer!)

Pros:
- Love the multiple tuners
- Upscaled picture quality is very good, miles better than my old freeview box and better than my folks SKY picture on a very similar quality TV
- On Demand and catch up TV is the real plus point for me though

Cons:
- Lack of Sky Sports in HD
- EPG isn't as good as the Sky HD one

Catch up TV is BBC iPlayer, 4OD and a few others all combined. Once you get used to the menu you can usually find what you want.

On Demand is a load of shows that are usually a bit older, but as it says, you can watch when you want. There is so much on there, and it's getting more HD stuff as well.

Overall, very pleased with it all. Would be better with some more HD content, but I've never felt like I'm missing anything without Sky Sports in HD as I get my "fix" of HD football via ESPN.