guesstimates please
guesstimates please
Author
Discussion

x5x3

Original Poster:

2,437 posts

283 months

Tuesday 19th January 2010
quotequote all
low speed skid on ice into kerb - guess is 10-15mph, cost of repair?

Neil.D

2,878 posts

236 months

Tuesday 19th January 2010
quotequote all
Whats damaged? Wheel? Bumper? Suspension?

x5x3

Original Poster:

2,437 posts

283 months

Tuesday 19th January 2010
quotequote all
well visually, scraped front alloy and tyre, scraped real alloy, and front wheel not pointing straight ahead!

mmm-five

12,385 posts

314 months

Tuesday 19th January 2010
quotequote all
At the thin end you'll probably need two alloy repairs and a track rod - £200 approx.
At the other end it'll be 2 new wheels, a wheel bearing, track rod, new suspension on the front, etc. - £1500?

It'll also depend where you take it and where you source the parts - i.e. can you get / will you be happy with 2nd hand wheels or will you require new ones?

I did something similar, but only hit the front, and at 5mph, so it looks like I've gotten away with just a wheel repair as the car drives & brakes straight and there are no vibrations.

Edited by mmm-five on Tuesday 19th January 21:03

TheEnd

15,370 posts

218 months

Tuesday 19th January 2010
quotequote all
track rod and/or front wishbone/"tension arm"

http://www.realoem.com/bmw/showparts.do?model=FA51...

6 and 10 (10 is the complete bit, not just the ball joint) are the tension arms and wishbones.

There are designed as a little bit of a mechanical fuse, and impact on the wheel will bend the arms rather than twist anything bigger.

Your best bet will be going for 4 wheel alignment, as they will be able to tell you if the front wheel has any "set back"

Most of the bends and knocks are often pretty hard to see, and i'd bet they could adjust the tracking to remove the effects of whatever is bent, but if there is still a set-back after that, than an arm is bent also.


x5x3

Original Poster:

2,437 posts

283 months

Tuesday 19th January 2010
quotequote all
mmm-five said:
£1500?
higher, higher

again I hit a kerb, not a wall and not another car....

physprof

996 posts

217 months

Tuesday 19th January 2010
quotequote all
ahhhh a quote from a dealer not shifting too many x1s etc.... and some numpty in service who did pricing.... I'd say 2500-3000 nearer 3 tho' on basis that early in 2009 dealer reckoned i'd stump up 2000 for service related suspension work on a 124k mile 528i worth say 1700.....

2 sMoKiN bArReLs

32,034 posts

265 months

Tuesday 19th January 2010
quotequote all
£4,501.64

x5x3

Original Poster:

2,437 posts

283 months

Tuesday 19th January 2010
quotequote all
2 sMoKiN bArReLs said:
£4,501.64
closest so far! do you work for the dealer?

still waiting for the itemised list - will be interesting!


mmm-five

12,385 posts

314 months

Tuesday 19th January 2010
quotequote all
Insurance claim then I guess.

sparks_E39

12,738 posts

243 months

Wednesday 20th January 2010
quotequote all
physprof said:
ahhhh a quote from a dealer not shifting too many x1s etc.... and some numpty in service who did pricing.... I'd say 2500-3000 nearer 3 tho' on basis that early in 2009 dealer reckoned i'd stump up 2000 for service related suspension work on a 124k mile 528i worth say 1700.....
I have had most of the major suspension components replaced in my E39 528 for less than £500.