Which one?
Author
Discussion

squarepants

Original Poster:

305 posts

231 months

Sunday 31st January 2010
quotequote all
It's nearly time for me to start thinking about buying my first car. Can't decide between these two. They are both in the style I like, but can't decide which I like more. I think the polo would be easier to insure for an inexperienced driver and that is why I like the polo; it's nice to look at IMO and easy to insure and it has a good fuel consumption.

What do you think?




pitch3110

162 posts

213 months

Sunday 31st January 2010
quotequote all
Both look good and great first cars.

Some of my early cars were Golfs and last year I got wifey an ED30 GTI.
It was nice to be back in a VW.

Enjoy

T89 Callan

8,422 posts

224 months

Sunday 31st January 2010
quotequote all
You have the choice between those two actual cars?

Well it would help if we knew:

Price
Engine type
Insurance cost
Condition
Mileage
Your requirements


Just based on looks I would go for the Polo though.

Elroy Blue

8,852 posts

223 months

Sunday 31st January 2010
quotequote all
Cheap to insure until you tell them about all the mods (because you wouldn't even consider just insuring it as a standard Polo would you!)

bn9af

3,920 posts

211 months

Monday 1st February 2010
quotequote all
as difficult as it can be, you really shouldnt modify your first car;

chances are your going to be young, and the insurers will either refuse to cover, or charge an absolute fortune, failing to insure correctly could result in cover being revoked and 6 points for driving without insurance, and since your probably young, this means bye bye licence.

modified cars are stupidly expensive when your a 25+ YO with maximum no claims, but a 17/18 YO with zero NCB its just not worth it! For the same money it will cost in insuring a modified car you could get a better, standard car.

Tame Technician

2,467 posts

235 months

Monday 1st February 2010
quotequote all
Time saving technical tip.

Only change the wheels and stereo on your first car, a really nice set of alloys will make it look the part even without the body kit etc, you really want. Try to plan ahead what car you want next, so you can swap the wheels and stereo into the next car. For example if you get a polo but plan to upgrade to the golf a year or two later, find out if the wheels you buy for it will fit. Obviously head units amps and subs are interchangable.

I found way back when I was a boy, with the specialist brokers like Hyperformance and Adrian Flux If the car had alloys wheels as standard, and you own up to changing them for nicer ones, there wasnt even an increase in premium, just a foot note on the cover saying if they were damaged in an accident they would only be replaced with the standard items, yes if you crashed you loose your £1000 alloys, but given the premium might have gone up by that much anyway a risk worth taking.