Gen 2 997 C4S Cab PDK Review
Gen 2 997 C4S Cab PDK Review
Author
Discussion

Callughan

Original Poster:

6,313 posts

223 months

Wednesday 3rd February 2010
quotequote all
I've been driving around in C4S PDK Cab last few days and thought I would share my experience with my PH buddies.

To start of with lots of expectations from the new model, this one was £90k out the showroom. From the outside it is a very handsome car, the led lights really make it stick out at night, however what was not good for a new car is that the rear lights had condensation all the time. The gap between tyre and arch is bigger than I am used to and could do with lowering imo, and the rear tyres on this are huge 315's on a C4S! Think the car could do with a front lip but it was quite nice not to have to crawl over speed bumps.lol


I'm not cabriolet type of guy but the roof is quick and slick which can be operated when driving at low speeds, like the fact you could put the rear windows down, looks nice when the roof is up and all windows down. The interior was rather plain compared to what I am used to, the leather is rather coarse compared to my 996 but have noticed other 996's with this leather too? At times it does not feel like a Porsche and remindes me of my old CLK, in my view it would need a lot of customisation with wood/carbon/ali whatever your preference to a)make it feel like your in £90K car & b)a Porsche. Perhaps compared to a stock 996 interior it is better? Also in the 993/6 the interior is instantly recognisable as a Porsche where as a BMW badge would be at home here. Nevertheless car was comfortable and maybe slightly bigger than a 996 inside.

I found the steering over-assisted and not as direct as the 996 nor does it gives the same amount of feedback again similar to my clk that I had.

The PASM was great, in normal mode was about the same as my car and in sport mode provided little or no roll, very stable but would be pleased with a harder settingsmile the handling is excellent and in coupe format I imagine would be even better.

The brakes felt the same as my car and again in the coupe would probably be more effective due to less weight.

The PDK box (unfortunately without sports chrono) for me is excellent, it should not be thought of as a replacement for a manual car, but as an auto it really is the business from standstill it is so responsive not many manual drivers would be able to obtain such a clean start, there on it shifts very quickly, sometimes it shifts before you think you should shift and 90% of time is in the right gear, occasionally it will get confused while you are doing 30mph and it will be 7th gear. The shift buttons as discussed many times are not the best but coming from a tiptronic it wasn't too bad and you get used to it, most of the time it was in D. In traffic it stutters a bit and tiptronic is more sure-footed in that scenario.

The engine note is terrible and for those of you who know me understand how important this is in a car for me. I am sure PSE will resolve this, however from inside the car after 5k rev it's not too bad.

The mpg has been surprisingly good usually my car does 15mpg in town and 18mpg overall, I've been achieving around 16 in town but 23 overall.

So to summarise it is a very capable car, the gearbox I feel is the only reason you should move to a Gen 2 if you have a manual Gen 1 then be content. The car to me had no soul which is alot of what a Porsche is about, if it was a coupe with PSE, Sports Chrono and a customised interior then maybe, but that would then be in 997 Turbo territory, so the question is if you were looking for an auto would you buy a Gen 2 PDK or 997 Turbo Tiptronic?

All the best,

Cal










Edited by Callughan on Wednesday 3rd February 20:04

ZeroH

2,922 posts

220 months

Wednesday 3rd February 2010
quotequote all
Good write up Cal !

totally agree with you that the steering is anethesised compared to the 996, which detracts a lot for me. Its still accurate of course, but then again, i'm sure this is what 993 owners said about the 996 ! Still, its a step backwards imo.

the pdk buttons were specifically designed to be intuitive to use for customers coming from tip cars so good to hear they work for you. When i drove pdk on track and was wheel twirling i was constantly shifting gear accidentally due to their positioning... paddle shift option is a must tick box on pdk.

Your car is very stable and puts its power down unbelievably well in crap conditions.

Agree that the car sounds pathetic to 5k rpm, and barely makes up for it to the redline from there.... top down helps a bit, but pse is another must tick option - as is SC.

Again, I can't but agree that gen 1 man owners should forget about changing to a gen 2 man - theres no gain imo... pdk is the be all and end all of gen 2 cars - without it, theres nothing much to shout about.

Badjwa

610 posts

208 months

Wednesday 3rd February 2010
quotequote all
Ace write up Geez, might be an ok motor but a turbo is another league!!!!!


IMI A

9,997 posts

232 months

Wednesday 3rd February 2010
quotequote all
yep good car but turbo blows it away - mine still amazes me when lighting it up on a fav road 3 years on - off tom 2 Silverstone tom to try a Gen 2. Anyone experienced a turbo there?

ZeroH

2,922 posts

220 months

Wednesday 3rd February 2010
quotequote all
IMI A said:
yep good car but turbo blows it away - mine still amazes me when lighting it up on a fav road 3 years on - off tom 2 Silverstone tom to try a Gen 2. Anyone experienced a turbo there?
Was scheduled to do this last wk but couldnt make it so waiting to resched. Post up your thoughts once you've done it
thumbup

Callughan

Original Poster:

6,313 posts

223 months

Saturday 6th February 2010
quotequote all

Callughan

Original Poster:

6,313 posts

223 months

Saturday 6th February 2010
quotequote all


kbf1981

2,351 posts

231 months

Saturday 6th February 2010
quotequote all
Nice pics, it's a good looking car!!

Callughan

Original Poster:

6,313 posts

223 months

Saturday 6th February 2010
quotequote all
Thanks here's another one with a tuned Cayman S;)

ZeroH

2,922 posts

220 months

Saturday 6th February 2010
quotequote all
Callughan said:
Thanks here's another one with a tuned Cayman S;)
hmm... this looks familiar !! wink

Everyone I know thats driven pdk has the same opinion - simply not as involving or enjoyable as the manual. Still - it actually suits the (non GT model) 911's GT character quite well I think which is why its the only choice for the new turbo.

98C4S

2,943 posts

221 months

Saturday 6th February 2010
quotequote all
Callughan said:
Looking shiney, what polish do you use?

Badjwa

610 posts

208 months

Saturday 6th February 2010
quotequote all
wot would you choose cal???

Callughan

Original Poster:

6,313 posts

223 months

Wednesday 7th September 2011
quotequote all
Just a follow up on this thread. This time i've been driving a gen 2 997 C2S with sports chrono, which makes a huge difference. It's like night and day with sports plus and fits in nicely with PASM in that it enables you to have two cars in one dependent on use. However the car really needs PSE as these DFI engines do not sound nice when stock.

What is the largest difference for me is having 2WD, I appreciate there are advantages in terms of weight and feel, but you have to have a drive with a different approach compared to the C4S especially in the wetyikes

Car is very playful and noticed there is a significant difference with having a full tank of petrol when at high speed as the front tends to become light, in corners where in the C4S I am flat out here the back starts to slide, on heavy braking the front starts to sway. It really keeps you on your toes and I can see it's use on track but for road use I think you need to be slightly more cautious.

Further to my previous question whether PDK C4S or 7t tip? Now I have experienced both the turbo's torque and pull cannot be replicated and is a big enough difference to change where as I am not sure it is with a newer version of the same car.


TonyB66

243 posts

201 months

Thursday 8th September 2011
quotequote all
Callughan said:
What is the largest difference for me is having 2WD, I appreciate there are advantages in terms of weight and feel, but you have to have a drive with a different approach compared to the C4S especially in the wetyikes

Car is very playful and noticed there is a significant difference with having a full tank of petrol when at high speed as the front tends to become light, in corners where in the C4S I am flat out here the back starts to slide, on heavy braking the front starts to sway. It really keeps you on your toes and I can see it's use on track but for road use I think you need to be slightly more cautious.
Odd that you feel the front getting light with a full tank of fuel - more weight in the front should make it sit better and reduce the tendancy to lift at speed.

I think you are used to your car with its 4WD and extra confidence that that brings to you. 2WD is a drivers car and even with all the electronic gizmo's available still needs to be used with a little more respect.

Koing

442 posts

204 months

Thursday 8th September 2011
quotequote all
Thanks for writing your experiences down. It's always interesting to hear from a non journalist.

Koing

Callughan

Original Poster:

6,313 posts

223 months

Thursday 8th September 2011
quotequote all
TonyB66 said:
Callughan said:
What is the largest difference for me is having 2WD, I appreciate there are advantages in terms of weight and feel, but you have to have a drive with a different approach compared to the C4S especially in the wetyikes

Car is very playful and noticed there is a significant difference with having a full tank of petrol when at high speed as the front tends to become light, in corners where in the C4S I am flat out here the back starts to slide, on heavy braking the front starts to sway. It really keeps you on your toes and I can see it's use on track but for road use I think you need to be slightly more cautious.
Odd that you feel the front getting light with a full tank of fuel - more weight in the front should make it sit better and reduce the tendancy to lift at speed.

I think you are used to your car with its 4WD and extra confidence that that brings to you. 2WD is a drivers car and even with all the electronic gizmo's available still needs to be used with a little more respect.
Hi Mate, sorry didn't explain it well, I mean't when the tank is full it doesn't feel as light, however when empty there is a noticeable difference.

rimkah

1,057 posts

197 months

Thursday 8th September 2011
quotequote all
Ta

Every 911 has a different purpose......

PDK Turbo Scloud9

TonyB66

243 posts

201 months

Thursday 8th September 2011
quotequote all
Callughan said:
Hi Mate, sorry didn't explain it well, I mean't when the tank is full it doesn't feel as light, however when empty there is a noticeable difference.
Ok. I have felt that lightness to, but only at speed.

Cobnapint

10,197 posts

182 months

Thursday 8th September 2011
quotequote all
TonyB66 said:
Ok. I have felt that lightness to, but only at speed.
I ran a Gen 1 C2S man for a year and now have a Gen 2 C4S PDK, and the C2S definitely keeps you on your toes at high speed and in the wet. The C4S is alot more stable at speed and nowhere near as scary in the wet. It doesn't wear you out like the 2 does - but it all depends whether you want to drive on the edge all the while or enjoy the pace and get out relaxed at the end of it.

Callughan

Original Poster:

6,313 posts

223 months

Friday 9th September 2011
quotequote all
Cobnapint said:
TonyB66 said:
Ok. I have felt that lightness to, but only at speed.
I ran a Gen 1 C2S man for a year and now have a Gen 2 C4S PDK, and the C2S definitely keeps you on your toes at high speed and in the wet. The C4S is alot more stable at speed and nowhere near as scary in the wet. It doesn't wear you out like the 2 does - but it all depends whether you want to drive on the edge all the while or enjoy the pace and get out relaxed at the end of it.
Agree, I now think about my actions especially when there is a car either sideheadache