A4 engines.
Author
Discussion

BCA

Original Poster:

8,651 posts

288 months

Friday 12th February 2010
quotequote all
May be getting another, we've had two 1.8T's and they've both been unreliable... what engines do you recommend? Performance doesnt matter, mpg is preferred to be reasonable and reliability is the priority. Which engines are most reliable for approx 12k miles a year, mostly commuting through a city, but also the occaisional motorway run up and down the country.

The 1.8T has had issues with coil packs, coolant lights, head replaced, clutch issues (repeatedly - Dual mass flywheel related??) - so we'd rather not another.

Any thoughts?

magpies

5,209 posts

213 months

Saturday 13th February 2010
quotequote all
large diesel and then chipped - as quick as the 1.8T but twice the mpg and should cover 300k with correct maintenance

Tame Technician

2,467 posts

235 months

Saturday 13th February 2010
quotequote all
1.9 TDI is most reliable.

Avoid the 2.5TDI.

If performance doesnt matter and reliabilty is the main thing, have you considered a Honda?

Whats your budget, what year of car are you after??

Dr G

16,014 posts

273 months

Saturday 13th February 2010
quotequote all
On the other hand my 1.8T has been absolutely reliable. Rarely see much wrong with these or the 2.0T.

BCA

Original Poster:

8,651 posts

288 months

Saturday 13th February 2010
quotequote all
Tame Technician said:
1.9 TDI is most reliable.

Avoid the 2.5TDI.

If performance doesnt matter and reliabilty is the main thing, have you considered a Honda?

Whats your budget, what year of car are you after??
Has to be an Audi as part of a goodwill gesture in taking in our current 1.8T which has been a pain.

The salesman said something to mum about Diesel being the wrong choice "due to particals build up or something" - I've reckon that means particulate filters or something blocking?? A real concern??

Do any of the Audis have different clutch types? - I assume the diesel is different?

Budget is around 20k.

Duncansnelling

37 posts

202 months

Saturday 13th February 2010
quotequote all
Why avoid the 2.5 v6 tdi hope you don't mind me butting in as I am thinking of on when I change mine .

Tallbut Buxomly

12,254 posts

247 months

Saturday 13th February 2010
quotequote all
BCA said:
Tame Technician said:
1.9 TDI is most reliable.

Avoid the 2.5TDI.

If performance doesnt matter and reliabilty is the main thing, have you considered a Honda?

Whats your budget, what year of car are you after??
Has to be an Audi as part of a goodwill gesture in taking in our current 1.8T which has been a pain.

The salesman said something to mum about Diesel being the wrong choice "due to particals build up or something" - I've reckon that means particulate filters or something blocking?? A real concern??

Do any of the Audis have different clutch types? - I assume the diesel is different?

Budget is around 20k.
I think tametech missed the 12k mile bit. The problem with the diesels is they can clog the engine up if not driven hard enough and if mostly town driving that may end up being the case however i suspect the 1.9 tdi which i have should be ok and is bullet proof mostly.

Edited by Tallbut Buxomly on Saturday 13th February 22:57

Tame Technician

2,467 posts

235 months

Saturday 13th February 2010
quotequote all
Duncansnelling said:
Why avoid the 2.5 v6 tdi hope you don't mind me butting in as I am thinking of on when I change mine .
An ok lump when its working, mix of slightly and very old technology, makes it a bit noisey, but ok. All engines have there issues (Ford vauxhall VAG who ever) its just the things that go wrong on the 2.5 are very expensive and you tend to have alot of expensive failures in a short time. We look after a car thats done 250,000 miles, so they can go on, but in the last 4 years its had, 2 turbos, a set of manifolds, two oil filter housings, and injection pump, and a load of other minor bits and bobs too.

I know of a 120k alroad thats had a cylinder head on 1 bank and a pair of cams in the other bank. That was a £3000+ repair bill. damaged caused by camshaft failure.

The 2.0TDI has a few problems, but repair bills are hundreds not thousands.



Tame Technician

2,467 posts

235 months

Saturday 13th February 2010
quotequote all
BCA said:
Tame Technician said:
1.9 TDI is most reliable.

Avoid the 2.5TDI.

If performance doesnt matter and reliabilty is the main thing, have you considered a Honda?

Whats your budget, what year of car are you after??
Has to be an Audi as part of a goodwill gesture in taking in our current 1.8T which has been a pain.

The salesman said something to mum about Diesel being the wrong choice "due to particals build up or something" - I've reckon that means particulate filters or something blocking?? A real concern??

Do any of the Audis have different clutch types? - I assume the diesel is different?

Budget is around 20k.
As Dr G points out, the 2.0TFSI is pretty good too, I was think older and cheaper and didnt think of that. Sounds like the sales bod you spoke to was talking about DPF's. Yes they are a problem for some people, depends how you drive. We've had to buy a few back, from people who poter about arround town and clog them up and then sold the same car to other people who have had no problems at all. But its really only the PD engines (2.0 TDI) that suffer, the common rail ones dont.

One thing to remember all cars have there issues, Apart from the plug coils (which are only £25 each and 4 new ones should go 100,000 miles) none of the problem you have had are common for the 1.8T and purly bad luck. Only other real comon problems with that engine are MAF sensors, and oil pump strainser getting blocked.

Nearly all mordern cars have duel mass flywheels these days. Dont take this the wrong way but a large percentage of clutch judder (I'm assuming thats what was wrong) is caused by the driver of the car. Mine is juddering like mad, since I'd been sliping it lots to get my car unstuck from the recent snow. That said, if a car need a new clutch and flywheel and only the clutch is done, its only a matter of time before the judder comes back.

In short the most reliable engines in an A4 at arround £20k are the 2.0TFSI or the 2.7/3.0 TDI.

The 1.9TDI is generally considered the bullet proof lump, but at that money your probably looking at newer cars with the 2.0TDI engine, which I wouldnt have thought would be as reliably as the FSI or common rail diesel's.

skymaster

731 posts

238 months

Sunday 14th February 2010
quotequote all
I think a lot of the A4 lumps are not designed for pottering around town. I guess the A4 itself isn't either!

My old 1.9 TDI 130 was super reliable until the turbo blew... but that the was only engine related issue. Probably due to too many short trips, not enough long runs and a double helping of bad luck...

The Clutch and Dual Mass also needed doing at about 70k..... Not sure if the more up to date ones have better flywheels in them? Or if they are all vulnerable?

BCA

Original Poster:

8,651 posts

288 months

Sunday 14th February 2010
quotequote all
Tame technician, we're on our fourth clutch in 40k. It is not how the car is driven, we own several cars that Mum uses and they're all fine - shes never had a clutch problem on any of her previous cars either and has been driving for maybe 30years.

This is why we're changing it and it has to be Audi. I'll look into the 2.0TFSI, out of interest - have you ever had any issues with this engine in relation to direct injection (which I believe it has, feel free to correct me if I am wrong!)

Tame Technician

2,467 posts

235 months

Sunday 14th February 2010
quotequote all
If it says FSI or TFSI on it, yes its direct injection.

Very early FSI A3's 2.0FSI used to burn out there valves because the early true FSI cars effectivly ran too lean. They used to hesitate on and off teh throttle a bit too. Since about 2005 there have been no more problem like that, engine management software was changed problem solved.

We went through a stage of changing lots of high fuel pressure sensors a year or two ago, we were doing 1 or 2 a week and some cars were recalled for a proactive replacement (but not all) thats pretty much stoped now, havnt done one for months, and we see 60 or so cars a day.

I've had the manifolds off to change a fuel injector or 2, very few not a common problem, and when you look down the ports they do look a litle black and gunky, but never had a problem with engine as a result of this. Nearly all new petrol cars are now direct fuel injection and without the fuel cleaning the back ofd the valve you can see they do build up a layer of gunk but as yet, I've seen no evidence this has any effect on the running of the engine.

I cant imagine why you need a clutch every 10k miles, is it juddering or sliping. If its judder maybe it should have had a flywheel and the clutches wouldnt go. Only other customer I know who has wanted clutches that often was complaining about a natural vibration of the engine, he thought was clutch judder. I could take him out in a number of other cars and they all did it. We put a clutch in his car just to show willing to help although we thought it would make no difference. It improved the vibration for about 10k miles then he wanted another free one, waranty already rejected the first one we sent back so we couldnt aford to do another.

BCA

Original Poster:

8,651 posts

288 months

Monday 15th February 2010
quotequote all
Complete clutch failure, everytime... each one totally burnt out. To say we are/ have been furious is an understatement. Its a new one every 15k-ish, I am calling it four as it had one from new - it has needed three replacements now though.

Tame Technician

2,467 posts

235 months

Monday 15th February 2010
quotequote all
Never heard of that before.

Either they arent replacing the plate and cover and just putting a plate in (highly unlikely, you wouldnt try that again after one failure) or there is something wrong with the hydraulic side of things making it slow to return causing to much slip.

Or the driver is slipping it. Lots of town work, heavy trafic crawls, hill starts, towing a large caravan.

BCA

Original Poster:

8,651 posts

288 months

Monday 15th February 2010
quotequote all
Never towed anything, very rarely even driven with more than one person in it. It does spend time in a city centre, but it also does longer trips too, its mixed really - and as I stated earlier, mum has never had any clutch issues with previous cars that have been used the same.

Perhaps we are ridiculously unlucky, but it has dented my confidence in the clutch/engine combination. We've had a 2009 1.8T suggested to us as a possible replacement, but my immediate thought is to ask them to locate a 20TFSI instead... What are your thoughts on this? The clutches may be the same, but I am thinking of the irritating coolant light wobblies, necessitating a new head amongst a million other attempted "fixes" previously.

Tame Technician

2,467 posts

235 months

Monday 15th February 2010
quotequote all
2009 is the new shape A4, I didnt know you could get them within your budget, very sorry I dont have anything to do with sales, have no idea what things cost.

Its a completely different 1.8T engine, (chain driven for a start, so no cambelt change interval) and a comletely different gearbox and clutch/flywheel assembly. We have had very litle in the way of trouble with them much as the 2.0TFSI.


BCA

Original Poster:

8,651 posts

288 months

Monday 15th February 2010
quotequote all
Ooo interesting, its a touch over our budget, but we'll see how it goes... probably worth considering then. Many thanks Tame Technician, you have been a great help, I do hope Audi reads this thread/forum and realise that people like you are infact invaluable customer service assets... I agree they probably should be paying you more too from the profile info. thumbup

Dr G

16,014 posts

273 months

Tuesday 16th February 2010
quotequote all
Had very positive feedback on the new 1.8T so far, Revo tell me new software is on the way too that will take you north of 2.0T power levels with a massive slug of torque.

Been a bit slow coming to market as Audi have messed around a lot with diagnostic comms on the new model.

Tallbut Buxomly

12,254 posts

247 months

Tuesday 16th February 2010
quotequote all
TT quick question. I have a b6 tdi.

The obc oil check light is it trggered through pressure?

By that i mean if there is an issue with the turbo will it upset the oil pressure reading meaning i could run lower on oil than the car believes me to be meaning it doesnt give a low oil warning at normal pressure ?

Tame Technician

2,467 posts

235 months

Tuesday 16th February 2010
quotequote all
Tallbut Buxomly said:
TT quick question. I have a b6 tdi.

The obc oil check light is it trggered through pressure?

By that i mean if there is an issue with the turbo will it upset the oil pressure reading meaning i could run lower on oil than the car believes me to be meaning it doesnt give a low oil warning at normal pressure ?
Call me stupid but I'm not sure I understand the question.

There is one warning for low oil "level", meaning put some oil in. You wont see this, because you check it every week with the dip stick, right?

There is another warning for low oil "pressure", which if you did see, you would have turned the engine off within 2 or 3 seconds, right?

Only an absolutely masive turbo failure would cause a sudden drop in oil pressure, you would likely see major smoke from the rear of the vehicle just before the light came on.

An oil pressure failure (for what every reason) would definatly result in turbo failure if the engine wasnt switch off straight away.