Ford Puma or Three Door Mk1 Focus Phase 2
Ford Puma or Three Door Mk1 Focus Phase 2
Author
Discussion

Driver Rider

Original Poster:

606 posts

223 months

Sunday 14th February 2010
quotequote all
Hi,

im getting one of these cars in a couple of weeks time and wanted to know which one you would recommend and why.

I am quite a tall guy and from time to time the car will be fully loaded four up. I also want to improve the ICE a little and so a more "solid car" would be good tp prevent rattling. My first car was a fiesta as much as I loved the car it felt a little too small and not stable enough on the motorway especially on crosswinds. Im afraid the puma as it's based on the fiesta would be pretty much more of the same thing?

anyways i was looking at the 1.7 for the puma and the 1.6 for the focus. one last question does rust affect the focus the way if afflicts the puma?

many thanks in advance!

Frik

13,667 posts

269 months

Sunday 14th February 2010
quotequote all
Based on your criteria, I'd go for the Focus. I'd choose the 1.8 over the 1.6 though.

Driver Rider

Original Poster:

606 posts

223 months

Sunday 14th February 2010
quotequote all
Frik said:
Based on your criteria, I'd go for the Focus. I'd choose the 1.8 over the 1.6 though.
thanks for quick response. what makes you think i should go for the focus given the criteria i gave?

T66ORA

3,474 posts

283 months

Sunday 14th February 2010
quotequote all
4 up in a Puma!!! 2+2 in reality.
Tall? You will hit your head getting out of the Puma, due to the shape of the door orifice. Shame because as a drivers car they are superb, ignore all the hairdresser/Girl comments.I have a Puma as a daily runner and a Tamora for weekends, the Puma will give the TVR a run for its money on a bumpy B road.

Frik

13,667 posts

269 months

Sunday 14th February 2010
quotequote all
What he said. The Puma is fiesta based and so small as you suspected. Visibility isn't great either.

Driver Rider

Original Poster:

606 posts

223 months

Sunday 14th February 2010
quotequote all
Thank you for the comments. I guess it'll be a focus then. I was looking at the st170 they look tasty but i haven't got any no claims as i've been insured under my parents on their policies.

AMST09

570 posts

206 months

Sunday 14th February 2010
quotequote all
Have a look at insurance anyway....I'm young and manage to insure my foci RS so just have a look
As insurance companies are mysterious things the quotes can be completely different to what you think

Driver Rider

Original Poster:

606 posts

223 months

Sunday 14th February 2010
quotequote all
i looked online the best i can find is 1740 for a 24yo with two years exepeience and a clean record. do you think this is reasonable?

eta for a puma 1.7 1699.10 is asked of me!!?? im baffled!

Edited by Driver Rider on Sunday 14th February 23:22

Frik

13,667 posts

269 months

Sunday 14th February 2010
quotequote all
Go for the 1.6/1.8 Focus, will be considerably cheaper. In a year's time, you'll have a years no claims and you'll be 25 when the price will drop considerably.

Don't piss that kind of money up the wall on insurance.

Driver Rider

Original Poster:

606 posts

223 months

Sunday 14th February 2010
quotequote all
I have to say im inclined to agree with you on that one! I will leave the ST for another year! Thanks for the post it is much appreciated.

blackburn

2,339 posts

224 months

Tuesday 16th February 2010
quotequote all
FWIW, my wife runs a '53' reg 1.6 Focus Zetec. It's a black 3 door car and what I'd call a 'face-lift', i.e. the front indicators are inside the headlamps. I think it's still a good looking car and every time I drive it I'm impressed by it. The steering is really direct and it somehow feels as it really wants to go where you point it. We only put budget tyres on it but it handles way, way better than my '06 Focus Estate daily driver. Her indoors didn't like me moaning about the estate's handling until she was giving it some 'round a local rounabout and it refused to hold a tight line (I won't go into details...). She suddenly realised just how good her car handles in comparison. About the only thing I can criticise about the car is the overly light throttle pedal, but even that is ok compared to the overly servo'ed brakes on the estate car.

Sorry, drifted off topic there!

ETA - I'm 6'2" and have no head-room issues with the Focus.

Edited by blackburn on Tuesday 16th February 21:11

Rich's Granny

75 posts

197 months

Wednesday 17th February 2010
quotequote all
I have to admit to having had a 1.7 Puma and a number of Foci, All company cars mind.

The Puma was a great little car for zipping about in but totally impractical. I certainly wouldn't have chosen it but unfortunatley I inherited it when I joined the company. I had a hell of a job getting rid of it cos no one wanted it. LOL.
I couldn't fit anything in the boot and the rear seats were none existant even too small for small kids, there's actually a lot more room in the back of a Fiesta (we've got one of those too), the wife loved driving it though.

I had few Foci after that admittedly all estates but from 51 reg onwards 1.8 petrol and 1.8 tdci. The Focus is a much better car and I would go for the tdci over the petrol any day. easily as quick and much more economical. Don't go for the 90bhp tddi though. My Dad's got one of those, won't pull the skin off a rice pudding in comparison.

Diesel will be cheaper road tax too 'cos of lower emmissions.

Edited by Rich's Granny on Wednesday 17th February 20:13

Driver Rider

Original Poster:

606 posts

223 months

Wednesday 17th February 2010
quotequote all
thanks for the help guys. im going for a focus now. any help on what engines to go for....

mondayo

1,837 posts

289 months

Thursday 18th February 2010
quotequote all
My mum had a 1.8 zetec and from memory the new price and insurance group were pretty much the same for both the 1.6 and 1.8 but the 1,8 was quite a bit nipper and was a cracking drive for what is what.

In this case...big is best! smile

Yorkshirepadd

4 posts

196 months

Saturday 27th February 2010
quotequote all
I'd go for a 1.6 Focus as its not really any slower and its cheaper to tax if you get a newer one.
Also there are many tuning options for the 1.6 sigma engine, its a cracking little motor.

Puma isn't that practical at all, I've got one and came from a Pug 306.
Its a great drive and puts a smile on my face all the time, but they're small.