Derv v Petrol. Tight v Thick?
Derv v Petrol. Tight v Thick?
Author
Discussion

heebeegeetee

Original Poster:

30,267 posts

279 months

Saturday 20th February 2010
quotequote all
Right. On one of the hourly 'Derv drivers are wkers' threads, I've made the slightly controversial statement that people who buy the petrol option of ordinary cars do so because they don't know jack st about cars. smile

Currently in What's New/Audi VAG board is this thread http://www.pistonheads.com/xforums/topic.asp?h=0&a... from the 29th December 2005 yikes which features this beauty of a post smile
raceboy said:
baz1985 said:
I'd go GT TDI and AMD remap+ Milltek exhaust
I know it would probably be as quick, etc, etc.......but it's a Diesal and I'm just not sure I'm ready for people thinking I'm a tight wad (that don't even know me paperbag) just yet, and although I do a search based on 'GT' a few are on budget but for some reason the penny pinching Diesal buyers don't seem to spec the Recaros, so it's looking pretty unlikely I'll lower myself to new depths, you don't even save at the pumps as it's more than propper petrol and who gives a stuff about fuel economy anyway, drivings about having fun, whether it's sideways around the island on the way to Asda or going down the Cranners driving
The thread was somehow revived by a pilot of a 170 brake Bora looking to sell his car to someone who started a thread 5 years ago.

So... if it's true that diesel drivers are tightwads, might it not also be true that petrol drivers are just a little bit thick?

I mean, take the first post of this thread http://www.pistonheads.com/xforums/topic.asp?h=0&a...

You see more and more of this stuff on PH, and it's barking, isn't it? Pure Clarkson. But you never see this stuff from the diesel drivers.

So I put it to you, ladies and gentleman, that the diesel driver only appears to be tight to the thick. In reality the diesel driver is the epitome of wisdom and maturity, and is far more likely to be an utter driving god than someone who thinks he doesn't look a tightwad when pushing his lardy Golf down the Cranners. smile




Scuffers

20,887 posts

305 months

Saturday 20th February 2010
quotequote all
how can you be a petrol-head with a dismal?

Also, like for like, a dismal will always be slower.

Simples!


ewenm

28,506 posts

276 months

Saturday 20th February 2010
quotequote all
When we were buying the C30, the type of fuel was irrelevant to us. It's just not important on our boring daily car. For the fun cars, it's a different matter but for normal dull cars, I don't see why people get so upset/excited about the type of fuel.

Edited by ewenm on Saturday 20th February 09:28

Biker's Nemesis

41,487 posts

239 months

Saturday 20th February 2010
quotequote all
I love going fast, that's why I have bikes, I also like diesel cars. Don't know what that makes me.

eltax91

10,796 posts

237 months

Saturday 20th February 2010
quotequote all
Scuffers said:
how can you be a petrol-head with a dismal?

Also, like for like, a dismal will always be slower.

Simples!
Two cars in my household, both VAG TDi's, does that mean I can't be a petrol head? Last car was an MX5, a car that is given much praise on here. We have simply had to go Derv due to mileages done for work. Me 35k and SWMBO 28k pa.

I'm sorry I'm not worthy of your petrol head standards because my circumstances make it far more sensible to drive a diesel.

daemon

40,169 posts

228 months

Saturday 20th February 2010
quotequote all
Scuffers said:
how can you be a petrol-head with a dismal?

Also, like for like, a dismal will always be slower.

Simples!
Classic 'thick' response.

Scuffers

20,887 posts

305 months

Saturday 20th February 2010
quotequote all
daemon said:
Scuffers said:
how can you be a petrol-head with a dismal?

Also, like for like, a dismal will always be slower.

Simples!
Classic 'thick' response.
Sorry?

go on then, explain how that's 'thick' as you call it?

should you not be called a dismal-head of you have a oil burner?

point is, as the post above said, he runs dismals for economic reasons, nothing wrong with that but it's hardly the modus operandi of a true petrol-head is it?

apply this to the OP's comments.


Munter

31,331 posts

272 months

Saturday 20th February 2010
quotequote all
Scuffers said:
how can you be a petrol-head with a dismal?

Also, like for like, a dismal will always be slower.

Simples!
like for like. As in cars with identical performance.

So a diesel that can do 6 seconds 0-60 and say 155 top end will somehow be slower than a petrol car that can do 6 seconds 0-60 and 155 top end.

What was that about people being bright again....


daemon

40,169 posts

228 months

Saturday 20th February 2010
quotequote all
Scuffers said:
how can you be a petrol-head with a dismal?

Also, like for like, a dismal will always be slower.

Simples!
Just as an FYI -

BMW 320d M Sport 0-60 = 7.9s, top speed = 143
BMW 320i M Sport 0-60 = 8.2s, top speed = 142

So another myth smashed.

Scuffers

20,887 posts

305 months

Saturday 20th February 2010
quotequote all
Munter said:
Scuffers said:
how can you be a petrol-head with a dismal?

Also, like for like, a dismal will always be slower.

Simples!
like for like. As in cars with identical performance.

So a diesel that can do 6 seconds 0-60 and say 155 top end will somehow be slower than a petrol car that can do 6 seconds 0-60 and 155 top end.

What was that about people being bright again....
deeerrr....

Like for like means compare a 2L turbo dismal with a 2L turbo petrol, now tell me they perform the same.

daemon said:
Just as an FYI -

BMW 320d M Sport 0-60 = 7.9s, top speed = 143
BMW 320i M Sport 0-60 = 8.2s, top speed = 142

So another myth smashed.
LOL! so adding the turbo to only a dismal is a like for like comparison then?

Edited by Scuffers on Saturday 20th February 09:44

pbirkett

20,663 posts

303 months

Saturday 20th February 2010
quotequote all
Personally for a fun car I'd always choose a petrol.

But then, if I wanted a fun car, it probably wouldn't be a car where a diesel was an option anyway.

Having said that though, I've gotta be honest, unless I had a REALLY short commute, if I needed a "boring" car then I'd always choose diesel. TBH, something like, for example, a DCI Clio is a lot more fun to drive than a small petrol engined variant. The petrol one will be slow, gutless, and not sound that great. At least the DCI will have some poke to it.

Each to their own though, obviously.

pbirkett

20,663 posts

303 months

Saturday 20th February 2010
quotequote all
Scuffers said:
how can you be a petrol-head with a dismal?

Also, like for like, a dismal will always be slower.

Simples!
So its not possible that the owner of something like, say, a Fabia vRS or an Ibiza Cupra TDI, or a 330/335d, for example, can be a petrol head (as in, interested in cars and driving)? I'd disagree there.

Munter

31,331 posts

272 months

Saturday 20th February 2010
quotequote all
Scuffers said:
Munter said:
Scuffers said:
how can you be a petrol-head with a dismal?

Also, like for like, a dismal will always be slower.

Simples!
like for like. As in cars with identical performance.

So a diesel that can do 6 seconds 0-60 and say 155 top end will somehow be slower than a petrol car that can do 6 seconds 0-60 and 155 top end.

What was that about people being bright again....
deeerrr....

Like for like means compare a 2L turbo dismal with a 2L turbo petrol, now tell me they perform the same.
But why would you compare cars with different performance characteristics. That's like saying NA cars are crap because turbo cars are faster.

It's nonsense.

heebeegeetee

Original Poster:

30,267 posts

279 months

Saturday 20th February 2010
quotequote all
Scuffers said:
daemon said:
Scuffers said:
how can you be a petrol-head with a dismal?

Also, like for like, a dismal will always be slower.

Simples!
Classic 'thick' response.
Sorry?

go on then, explain how that's 'thick' as you call it?

should you not be called a dismal-head of you have a oil burner?

point is, as the post above said, he runs dismals for economic reasons, nothing wrong with that but it's hardly the modus operandi of a true petrol-head is it?

apply this to the OP's comments.
We all run everything for economic reasons. If money was not an issue, you wouldn't have any of those cars in your profile.

On the petrolheadism level, I don't think you have to be a marketing/Clarkson victim to be a petrolhead. Quite the opposite in fact.

daemon

40,169 posts

228 months

Saturday 20th February 2010
quotequote all
Scuffers said:
Munter said:
Scuffers said:
how can you be a petrol-head with a dismal?

Also, like for like, a dismal will always be slower.

Simples!
like for like. As in cars with identical performance.

So a diesel that can do 6 seconds 0-60 and say 155 top end will somehow be slower than a petrol car that can do 6 seconds 0-60 and 155 top end.

What was that about people being bright again....
deeerrr....

Like for like means compare a 2L turbo dismal with a 2L turbo petrol, now tell me they perform the same.

daemon said:
Just as an FYI -

BMW 320d M Sport 0-60 = 7.9s, top speed = 143
BMW 320i M Sport 0-60 = 8.2s, top speed = 142

So another myth smashed.
LOL! so adding the turbo to only a dismal is a like for like comparison then?

Edited by Scuffers on Saturday 20th February 09:44
So find me a 2.0Turbo 3 series then, if the like for like comparison of a 320d isnt a 320i? They're even identical spec.

Do you really think people buying a 1.8TDI Zetec Focus, think 'oh i can only compare this to a 1.8 Turbo petrol car? Or will they compare it to a 1.8i petrol?

D'uh.

CDP

8,062 posts

285 months

Saturday 20th February 2010
quotequote all
My elderly parents are buying a small car. In the case of the Fabia the diesel is about £1500 more than the petrol and it's got a cam belt that adds another £200 to replace.

I worked out it would take at least 80,000 miles to get back the extra cost. They won't be covering that kind of distance. OK if the sell at 3 years they will get some of the extra back but they'll probably keep this until my father stops driving.

That's before you remember the petrol car is quieter, 100Kg lighter and filling up a diesel is a much nastier experience than petrol (that's one of his main complaints).

So petrol v. diesel really does depend on circumstances. When I was doing 20K+ diesel made more sense but took the pleasure out of driving. It runs through everything: noise, lack of revs, turbo lag and that extra weight dumbing down the chassis.

Imagine John Prescot sitting on the end of your bonnet; just think what that would do to the ride and handling?

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 20th February 2010
quotequote all
If you do lots of motoray miles get a derv

..otherwise get a petrol


daemon

40,169 posts

228 months

Saturday 20th February 2010
quotequote all
heebeegeetee said:
Scuffers said:
daemon said:
Scuffers said:
how can you be a petrol-head with a dismal?

Also, like for like, a dismal will always be slower.

Simples!
Classic 'thick' response.
Sorry?

go on then, explain how that's 'thick' as you call it?

should you not be called a dismal-head of you have a oil burner?

point is, as the post above said, he runs dismals for economic reasons, nothing wrong with that but it's hardly the modus operandi of a true petrol-head is it?

apply this to the OP's comments.
We all run everything for economic reasons. If money was not an issue, you wouldn't have any of those cars in your profile.

On the petrolheadism level, I don't think you have to be a marketing/Clarkson victim to be a petrolhead. Quite the opposite in fact.
Exactly. i think.

Hence, why wouldnt 95% of the buying public, who are buying Focuses, astras, meganes, mondeos, entry to mid price german stuff even, buy the 'better' car? ie, the diesel variant?

Edited by daemon on Saturday 20th February 09:53

daemon

40,169 posts

228 months

Saturday 20th February 2010
quotequote all
CDP said:
My elderly parents are buying a small car. In the case of the Fabia the diesel is about £1500 more than the petrol and it's got a cam belt that adds another £200 to replace.

I worked out it would take at least 80,000 miles to get back the extra cost. They won't be covering that kind of distance. OK if the sell at 3 years they will get some of the extra back but they'll probably keep this until my father stops driving.

That's before you remember the petrol car is quieter, 100Kg lighter and filling up a diesel is a much nastier experience than petrol (that's one of his main complaints).

So petrol v. diesel really does depend on circumstances. When I was doing 20K+ diesel made more sense but took the pleasure out of driving. It runs through everything: noise, lack of revs, turbo lag and that extra weight dumbing down the chassis.

Imagine John Prescot sitting on the end of your bonnet; just think what that would do to the ride and handling?
Yes, and thats a prime example of why people, including petrol advocates need to look at the bigger picture. In this case whereby the car is going to be kept indefinitely, then the extra cost of the diesel isnt worth it. But for the bulk of people who keep a car maybe 3 years, then they're going to get the bulk if not all of their extra outlay back come resale time, plus moreoften the diesel variant will be easier sold too.

DAVEVO9

3,469 posts

298 months

Saturday 20th February 2010
quotequote all
Biker's Nemesis said:
I love going fast, that's why I have bikes, I also like diesel cars. Don't know what that makes me.
Pretty smart I would say

smile