Scrap or save?
Author
Discussion

sleep envy

Original Poster:

62,260 posts

280 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
Mrs envy's car has a suspected head gasket failure. Mayo under the cap, no water in the expansion tank and creamy oil on the dipstick.

It's an m reg astra 1.4 with 29k miles. She rarely uses it, only did 700 miles last year, the majority of which were on a trip to Glastonbury.

It's worth nothing and it's not worth her getting scrapage scheme trade in for it as she doesn't do enough miles to warrant a new car.

So, scrap it, new head gasket or replacement engine?

Defcon5

6,479 posts

222 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
What kind of condition is the rest of th car in?

sleep envy

Original Poster:

62,260 posts

280 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
It's sound - no major rust issues, has the odd bubble but nothing that couldn't be sorted in an afternoon

paintwork is dull as it lives outdoors all year round and has never been polished

rockandrollmark

1,181 posts

254 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
If it's only got 29k under it's belt has got life in it yet I'd repair. The cost of replacing it is going to be much higher, and even then it'l bee somewhat of an unknown quantity.

sleep envy

Original Poster:

62,260 posts

280 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
I poured in 8 litres of water into the expansion tank which is now in the sump


Def broken

LHD

17,002 posts

218 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
Scrap it IMO.

Should get between £50-100.

VPower

3,598 posts

225 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
sleep envy said:
I poured in 8 litres of water into the expansion tank which is now in the sump


Def broken
Sorry miss read your OP. Yep just replace head gasket, simple job really.

Has it frozen up at all?

rallycross

13,763 posts

268 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
M reg astra, bet its got no power steering.

CRUSH it.

sleep envy

Original Poster:

62,260 posts

280 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
VPower said:
Has it frozen up at all?
that's what I fear, was driven by her father in the cold snap in jan, he let it runinto the red...

Wasn't inthe country at the time

the water hardly collects in the tank...

sleep envy

Original Poster:

62,260 posts

280 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
rallycross said:
M reg astra, bet its got no power steering.

CRUSH it.
you'd have lost your money wink

CDP

8,062 posts

285 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
If she does 700 miles per year it's much cheaper to hire a car on the days she needs one.

MOT, Insurance and tax are at least £400 per year, you could get ten days rental for that.

Judging by the dearth of cheap cars at the moment you may still get some money for it from somebody who's good engine is surrounded by a crusty car.

Shaw Tarse

31,904 posts

234 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
LHD said:
Scrap it IMO.

Should get between £50-100.
For that I'd sell it for parts via an onlie auction site.

CDP

8,062 posts

285 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
VPower said:
sleep envy said:
I poured in 8 litres of water into the expansion tank which is now in the sump


Def broken
Sorry miss read your OP. Yep just replace head gasket, simple job really.

Has it frozen up at all?
Don't forget to remove the sump and clean it. That's a pretty easy job too. Those SOC GM engines are really basic so it shouldn't give you a lot of trouble.

sleep envy

Original Poster:

62,260 posts

280 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
CDP said:
If she does 700 miles per year it's much cheaper to hire a car on the days she needs one.

MOT, Insurance and tax are at least £400 per year, you could get ten days rental for that.

Judging by the dearth of cheap cars at the moment you may still get some money for it from somebody who's good engine is surrounded by a crusty car.
not really, gets used for short trips to the dump, garden centre, shops, etc

Car works out at £265 / yr

farrendahl

1,248 posts

205 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
If I had the time to make it sound again I'd have it off you. Would make a good pressie for my youngest sister who starts learning to drive later in the year. 1.4 perfect for a new driver IMO

sleep envy

Original Poster:

62,260 posts

280 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
It's an auto

sleep envy

Original Poster:

62,260 posts

280 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
It's an auto

farrendahl

1,248 posts

205 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
sleep envy said:
It's an auto
Okay then, scrap that lol

CDP

8,062 posts

285 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
sleep envy said:
CDP said:
If she does 700 miles per year it's much cheaper to hire a car on the days she needs one.

MOT, Insurance and tax are at least £400 per year, you could get ten days rental for that.

Judging by the dearth of cheap cars at the moment you may still get some money for it from somebody who's good engine is surrounded by a crusty car.
not really, gets used for short trips to the dump, garden centre, shops, etc

Car works out at £265 / yr
Are you sure?

Tax £120, MOT £50 (if no trouble) so the insurance would have to be around £100 to get near that figure.

Still if you do the gasket yourself you could probably do the job for £50.

KRIMZONQUATTRO

7 posts

201 months

Sunday 28th February 2010
quotequote all
Get a haynes manual for it then give it a try....you couldn't make it worse.
strip the head, check the cylinders, give it and all round proper check and clean (spend time on this bit and you can't go wrong), and at the same time replace all belts plus a full service.

not much for parts £12 for headset (includeds new oil seals) belts around £20 and then your standard prices to do for the service!

Not much money and you'll be suprised how short'a time it takes to do...plus you'll then have knowlegde of that engine inside out!