Renaultsport Clio 172 & 182 - How good?
Renaultsport Clio 172 & 182 - How good?
Author
Discussion

Pommygranite

Original Poster:

14,472 posts

247 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
Just wondering how good the Clio 172 and 182 are. They seem quite cheap second hand and wondered how good they really are?

Also, how fast are they really, putting raw stats aside?

Stefan SRT8

3,620 posts

229 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
We ran an 04 182 full fat for a couple of years, it was a great car, quick, handled well and proved very reliable, not a single issue. Performance wise we found it to be around the book figures.

The 182 is a well spec'd fun car.

No experience of the 172 to compare unfortunately.

Stef

JQ

6,892 posts

210 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
Would be interested in views on this one myself, a 182 is definately a possibility as I'm thinking of getting rid of the MX5. Just not sure whether I could go back to a FWD car.

bluesntwos

91 posts

231 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
We had a black 54-plate Clio 182 for a couple of years. Was quick and handled superbly with very little body roll. We regularly took it across the Woodhead pass where it excelled. It was quite economical too if you drove it gently. I'm sure we got high 30's MPG regularly from A-road driving. Equipment levels were high too with climate, CD, cruise, etc.

Unfortunately, the panels dented easily, as per other Renaults. It had quite bad 'gravel rash' on the lower arches in front of the rear wheels by 60k miles. The timing belt went at about 53k but luckily do damage was caused. It was still under warranty so this was begrudgingly repaired by Renault after much arguing and about two weeks in the garage. I'm sure this was caused by not replacing the aux belt at 36k (car had full Renault history). The same dealer also filled the power steering reservoir with water, then tried to blame the previous owner, who was a friend of ours.

Another disappointment was the steering wheel which started to melt! I kid not. This is a common problem apparently. Renault build quality!

All in all, it was a fairly trouble free car. It definitely preferred Tesco Super Unleaded to standard unleaded, the engine running and idling smoother.

Tycho

12,298 posts

304 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
I have a 182 full fat with cup suspension and absolutely love it. On every journey I make I get a good few grins out of it even when commuting.

Reliability has been great although the OEM Renault exhaust has a reputation for rotting after about 4 or 5 years but I have replaced mine with a Janspeed one which has slightly larger pipes, is a touch louder and weighs 1/2 of the original. I need to get the cambelt done as it is 5 years old so that'll cost about £740 eek

It is anonymous to most people so I never feel worried about leaving it anywhere and isn't too bad on the motorway. (I do a commute of 40 miles and 35 are on the M3.) I get 34.1 mpg average and I don't hang about either.

The equipment level is great, Leather/Alcantara seats, climate control, auto wipers and lights, xenons etc.

sleep envy

62,260 posts

280 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
bluesntwos said:
Another disappointment was the steering wheel which started to melt! I kid not. This is a common problem apparently. Renault build quality!
same happened to my 172FF - they rot and flake away

had lots of electrical issues on mine - the connectors they use are ste so you're endlessly jiggling wires

had the idle control valve fail - £30 part but you have to change the AFM as Renault or GSF/ECPs don't sell just the valve so that's £280

ABS activated when I just looked at the brakes

rotting exhausts are very common

I wouldn't buy another 172 as I think they're over rated

freakynessless

473 posts

213 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
Quite simply immense! - As long as you buy a decent example, you'll look back in years to come and it will be in your top five cars ever owned. Its so much fun! It just grips and grips and just when you think its gunna let go... It grips some more!
Theres loads about so pick and choose carefully. I had a 55 plate low miler and she was a dream. The only issue I ever had was a lambda sensor went which is fairly common.
Make sure you get the cup suspension and spoiler pack - however be warned when driving up to kerbs that you dont damage the front splitter like I did and only having it two weeks. Its very cheap and brittle plastic however, K-tec racing do a carbon firbre replacement cheaper than Renault supply the original.
Also with the cup suspension pack, Renault supply Michelin Exalto II tyres which were made specially for the 182 and they are fantastic make sure you stick with them.
As previously said, gravel scab on the arches is a problem so dont go for black one! The front end chipped quite badly as well and I sold it before 40K.
Given the choice again, I'd go for red, blue or liquid yellow.
Make sure the aux belts have been dont at 36K. There is some debate over when this should be done but best to air on the side of caution then risk blowing up your engine.

Overall, just get on autotrader and buy one! you wont regret it.

andye30m3

3,501 posts

285 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
I has a phase 1 172 and it was a great little car.

Good fun, cheap servicing and consumables.

I did have a few silly little things break but nothing major or expensive, I'd have another one if I wanted another good value fun hot hatch.

I'd probably only buy and early one as the later ones are similar money to an Integra Type R which I'd have over the clio.

Tycho

12,298 posts

304 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
doogz said:
I had a FF 182.

3.5 years old when i got it, only previous owner was my cousin, a girly girl.

Had done less than 40k miles, and almost instantly when i bought it, the brake servo snuffed it, the rear shocks started leaking and the exhaust rusted through.

It handled well, but i'm confident mine made nothing like the 182bhp it was supposed to.

So overall, mine was slow, and broke a lot.
Sounds like a dog! My rear shocks were replaced at about 50K as it felt like the rear wheels were always on ice.

Risotto

3,934 posts

243 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
I've had experience of both and they're great fun, if a little flakey.

From memory, the issues to watch out for are the engine mounts (I think there are 3 or 4 and when they start to go there's a terrible thumping under acceleration. As others have said, steering wheel can melt and the thumb grips disintegrate. The airbag wiring for the seats can cause the warning lamp to light. Oh and the Renault exhausts can rot, particularly on the 172.

Make sure the belts have been done if age/mileage means they should have as it's a fiddly job that can cost a fair bit.

Having said all that, these cars don't cost much to buy, so a few niggles are par for the course. The alternative might be to spend a bit more on something like a Civic Type R which seems to have a better reliability record and may not cost as much to maintain.


Edited by Risotto on Monday 8th March 09:25

CampDavid

9,145 posts

229 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
doogz said:
Tycho said:
doogz said:
I had a FF 182.

3.5 years old when i got it, only previous owner was my cousin, a girly girl.

Had done less than 40k miles, and almost instantly when i bought it, the brake servo snuffed it, the rear shocks started leaking and the exhaust rusted through.

It handled well, but i'm confident mine made nothing like the 182bhp it was supposed to.

So overall, mine was slow, and broke a lot.
Sounds like a dog! My rear shocks were replaced at about 50K as it felt like the rear wheels were always on ice.
Yeah it was a friday afternoon car, but it still put me off them.

Oh, and i haven't seen it mentioned, i've been told the seats in the Cup version are better, but in the FF version, the seating position is terrible, way too high, and the steering wheel is huuuuge!
The cup and the FF seat are the same, for a decent driving position you need the optional Recaros, which are rare and pricey. Good car but with classic French hatch faults

Edited by CampDavid on Monday 8th March 11:05

Tycho

12,298 posts

304 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
freakynessless said:
Also with the cup suspension pack, Renault supply Michelin Exalto II tyres which were made specially for the 182 and they are fantastic make sure you stick with them.
TBH I bought the Goodyear Eagle GSD3s and have found them to be just as good in every way but have slightly less tyre noise and take some of the bigger bumps better.

Tycho

12,298 posts

304 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
doogz said:
Yeah it was a friday afternoon car, but it still put me off them.

Oh, and i haven't seen it mentioned, i've been told the seats in the Cup version are better, but in the FF version, the seating position is terrible, way too high, and the steering wheel is huuuuge!
Fair enough.

I find the seating position to be strange at first but after a few weeks, it's fine. Just make sure you drop the seat down as low as you can.

My steering wheel is slightly melting but not too bad.

CampDavid

9,145 posts

229 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
doogz said:
CampDavid said:
doogz said:
Tycho said:
doogz said:
I had a FF 182.

3.5 years old when i got it, only previous owner was my cousin, a girly girl.

Had done less than 40k miles, and almost instantly when i bought it, the brake servo snuffed it, the rear shocks started leaking and the exhaust rusted through.

It handled well, but i'm confident mine made nothing like the 182bhp it was supposed to.

So overall, mine was slow, and broke a lot.
Sounds like a dog! My rear shocks were replaced at about 50K as it felt like the rear wheels were always on ice.
Yeah it was a friday afternoon car, but it still put me off them.



Oh, and i haven't seen it mentioned, i've been told the seats in the Cup version are better, but in the FF version, the seating position is terrible, way too high, and the steering wheel is huuuuge!
The cup and the FF seat, for a decent driving position you need the optional Recaros, which are rare and pricey. Good car with classic French hatch aults
Say what?
Odd keyboard fault, now edited

Edited by CampDavid on Monday 8th March 11:08

v15ben

16,234 posts

272 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
I've had mine for getting on a year now. A relatively cheap 5 year old 182FF when I bought it. Prepare for the cost of the cambelt service or even better get a car with it already done. The OEM exhaust will fall apart - mind failed it's MOT due to this, but the Janspeed items sound much better anyway hehe

Great fun to throw down a B-road but has enough equipment to be a nice place on long motorway journies. MPG expect 33-36 depending on how much you thrash it! I've been round the Alps, the Nurburgring, hooned with all manner of supercars and cruised up and down the M1 more times than I can remember and it does all of them with aplomb.

LukeBird

17,170 posts

240 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
I've driven a 172 Cup, absolutely loved it! thumbup
My mum has a 182 for about 3 years or so, one previous owner and 30-odd thousand miles on it, nothing has really gone wrong. Cracking little car! thumbup

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
If you fold the rear seats down and drop the glovebox door they handle like they're on rails.

v15ben

16,234 posts

272 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
Tycho said:
It is anonymous to most people
wavey Depends what spec you go for - Racing Blue with stripes and a loud exhaust isn't the most subtle option rofl However in black gold with a quiet exhaust it is relatively subtle!


v15ben

16,234 posts

272 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
Nope bought it from a council estate in Birmingham so living up to the chav reputation wink

Chris71

21,549 posts

273 months

Monday 8th March 2010
quotequote all
How easy is it for someone of normal stature to get comfortable in one? Are they noisy at motorway speeds?

Probably won't ever get one, but they've always quite appealed.