Have car manufacturers lost the plot?
Have car manufacturers lost the plot?
Author
Discussion

bill bob

Original Poster:

133 posts

241 months

Tuesday 9th March 2010
quotequote all
I can see the reasoning behind having an engine management system controlling the ignition and fuel systems, but why the lights? What happened to the good old manual switch?
When a blown lamp is replaced why do we then have to take the car to the main dealer for the computer to be reset to repower the circuit.
Is it technological madness or have I missed something?

Bill Bob

petersLUFC

372 posts

211 months

Tuesday 9th March 2010
quotequote all
Depends how much they charge to reset the computer. There's your answer smile same deal with some cars needing the front bumper removing to change the bulbs. It makes the cars non user-servicable on even the bits joe public could do easily, hence the dealers make a packet!

checkmate91

861 posts

204 months

Tuesday 9th March 2010
quotequote all
Sorry, no, you're missing the point. This is an important safety feature. Firstly the ECU will capture the fault and by returning the car to the dealer to have half the front (or back) bodywork removed, the faulty bulb replaced, the removed bodywork replaced and the ECU reset ensures that the necessary (and important) safety features of the car are maintained. And, whilst you are several hundred pounds poorer, you can continue to drive the car without a care in the world.

Regards,
Andy

Orb the Impaler

1,881 posts

221 months

Tuesday 9th March 2010
quotequote all
It's all got a bit out of hand now, IMHO.

I look back on the 80s when me and my mates used to change clutches, CHGs etc, weld bits, change windscreens - you name it. These days I can't even figure out how to get the fking door trim off.

I've seen the face of progress and its ste!

Benjybh

1,937 posts

210 months

Tuesday 9th March 2010
quotequote all
But why is it necessary to take half the car apart to access a bulb? Why not make it so you can pop the bonnet, unscrew take out an 'service access panel' like you have on aircraft, and replace the offending bulb from there.

Orb the Impaler

1,881 posts

221 months

Tuesday 9th March 2010
quotequote all
And another thing that REALLY pisses me off!
When a garage does work and then charges £50 (or whatever) for using the diagnostic machine - what the fk! It's a tool - no different than a wheel balancer, spanner or whatever. Without it you cannot do your job in the same way that a builder cannot do his job without a cement mixer. Does the builder stick an extra £50 on his bill for use of his cement mixer?

No doubt someone who likes to rob people - probably old grannies - will be along shortly to tell me this is not in fact the case. Well it is, ok. And I'm not listening - just go rob some grannies instead. Thief!

wink

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Tuesday 9th March 2010
quotequote all
bill bob said:
When a blown lamp is replaced why do we then have to take the car to the main dealer for the computer to be reset to repower the circuit.
Which car does this?

JensenA

5,671 posts

261 months

Tuesday 9th March 2010
quotequote all
Orb the Impaler said:
And another thing that REALLY pisses me off!
When a garage does work and then charges £50 (or whatever) for using the diagnostic machine - what the fk! It's a tool - no different than a wheel balancer, spanner or whatever. Without it you cannot do your job in the same way that a builder cannot do his job without a cement mixer. Does the builder stick an extra £50 on his bill for use of his cement mixer?

No doubt someone who likes to rob people - probably old grannies - will be along shortly to tell me this is not in fact the case. Well it is, ok. And I'm not listening - just go rob some grannies instead. Thief!

wink
Good Point - It pisses me off too. I'm going to use that 'It's a Tool' argument next time.

Strawman

6,463 posts

238 months

Tuesday 9th March 2010
quotequote all
I think it is a product of canbus technology, makes wiring a car much cheaper and simpler, rather than each component having an individual wire going to it, now components can share wires like in a small computer network, each component has an identifying address on the network, so if components are changed/replaced then they need to be registered on the network. (or something).

petersLUFC

372 posts

211 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all
hornetrider said:
bill bob said:
When a blown lamp is replaced why do we then have to take the car to the main dealer for the computer to be reset to repower the circuit.
Which car does this?
I'm thinking Renault, sounds about right after some strange things i've heard about them

eybic

9,212 posts

205 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all
Orb the Impaler said:
And another thing that REALLY pisses me off!
When a garage does work and then charges £50 (or whatever) for using the diagnostic machine - what the fk! It's a tool - no different than a wheel balancer, spanner or whatever. Without it you cannot do your job in the same way that a builder cannot do his job without a cement mixer. Does the builder stick an extra £50 on his bill for use of his cement mixer?

No doubt someone who likes to rob people - probably old grannies - will be along shortly to tell me this is not in fact the case. Well it is, ok. And I'm not listening - just go rob some grannies instead. Thief!

wink
Is it not a labour charge? I know we charge labour time for diag, the dealer might say it is £50 to use the machine but if they charge £100 per hour and he spends ½ an hour on the diag machine, that's where your £50 comes from. A builder does charge you for using a cement mixer, it's called labour.

Jonny671

29,904 posts

220 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all
eybic said:
Orb the Impaler said:
And another thing that REALLY pisses me off!
When a garage does work and then charges £50 (or whatever) for using the diagnostic machine - what the fk! It's a tool - no different than a wheel balancer, spanner or whatever. Without it you cannot do your job in the same way that a builder cannot do his job without a cement mixer. Does the builder stick an extra £50 on his bill for use of his cement mixer?

No doubt someone who likes to rob people - probably old grannies - will be along shortly to tell me this is not in fact the case. Well it is, ok. And I'm not listening - just go rob some grannies instead. Thief!

wink
Is it not a labour charge? I know we charge labour time for diag, the dealer might say it is £50 to use the machine but if they charge £100 per hour and he spends ½ an hour on the diag machine, that's where your £50 comes from. A builder does charge you for using a cement mixer, it's called labour.
Correct.

We charge £40 for our Diagnostics, that takes half an hour or so.. And use of our computer.. Its not some rubbish one either, so if it costs us £1000 for it.. We have to make that money back don't we? Or is that just absorbed into the costs..

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all
It should be part of the EU Type Approval scheme that all mandatory lamps should have bulbs that are replaceable without tools at the roadside.

It's a nonsense that you could be in the middle of a journey, many miles from home, and you have to drive illegally as you can't replace the bulb.

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all
petersLUFC said:
hornetrider said:
bill bob said:
When a blown lamp is replaced why do we then have to take the car to the main dealer for the computer to be reset to repower the circuit.
Which car does this?
I'm thinking Renault, sounds about right after some strange things i've heard about them
No idle speculation please (although I realise this is the internet) I want FACTS!

petersLUFC

372 posts

211 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all

Jonny671

29,904 posts

220 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all
Deva Link said:
It should be part of the EU Type Approval scheme that all mandatory lamps should have bulbs that are replaceable without tools at the roadside.

It's a nonsense that you could be in the middle of a journey, many miles from home, and you have to drive illegally as you can't replace the bulb.
How many people do you honestly think will change a bulb at the side of the road?

Really..

1 out of 10?

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all
Jonny671 said:
Deva Link said:
It should be part of the EU Type Approval scheme that all mandatory lamps should have bulbs that are replaceable without tools at the roadside.

It's a nonsense that you could be in the middle of a journey, many miles from home, and you have to drive illegally as you can't replace the bulb.
How many people do you honestly think will change a bulb at the side of the road?

Really..

1 out of 10?
In some countries it's required that you carry a bulb kit - what's the point of that if it's not physically possible to use it?

I think a fair number of people who were away from home would make some effort to change a bulb (if they knew it had failed).

hornetrider

63,161 posts

236 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all
petersLUFC said:
just found this

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/motoring/road-safety/27...

and this..

http://www.meganeownersclub.co.uk/changingmeganebu...

scratchchin

Edited by petersLUFC on Wednesday 10th March 10:42
Yes yes, that's all very well. We know it's difficult to change the bulbs on some cars. Blah blah.

I was specifically referring to the OP where he states a car needs an ECU reset after changing the bulb. Which, incidentally, is poppycock in my opinion.

Munter

31,331 posts

272 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all
Jonny671 said:
Deva Link said:
It should be part of the EU Type Approval scheme that all mandatory lamps should have bulbs that are replaceable without tools at the roadside.

It's a nonsense that you could be in the middle of a journey, many miles from home, and you have to drive illegally as you can't replace the bulb.
How many people do you honestly think will change a bulb at the side of the road?

Really..

1 out of 10?
I changed a rear bulb in the MX5 after parking in a ferry. Clip Clip bulb out, bulb in clip clip done. People were still getting out of the car behind me by the time I'd changed a bulb. If it was that easy for every bulb...people would.

Jonny671

29,904 posts

220 months

Wednesday 10th March 2010
quotequote all
Munter said:
Jonny671 said:
Deva Link said:
It should be part of the EU Type Approval scheme that all mandatory lamps should have bulbs that are replaceable without tools at the roadside.

It's a nonsense that you could be in the middle of a journey, many miles from home, and you have to drive illegally as you can't replace the bulb.
How many people do you honestly think will change a bulb at the side of the road?

Really..

1 out of 10?
I changed a rear bulb in the MX5 after parking in a ferry. Clip Clip bulb out, bulb in clip clip done. People were still getting out of the car behind me by the time I'd changed a bulb. If it was that easy for every bulb...people would.
I change my own bulbs, I think most PH'ers do.. If its possible.

But, we're a minority really compared to the amount of people who won't do it themselves.