£35k - What would you do?
£35k - What would you do?
Author
Discussion

g7jhp

Original Poster:

7,036 posts

269 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
OK currently have a 3.2 Carrera and Caterham 2.0 HPC.

Been doing more miles on the M25 than I'd like (60m day/300 week) so thinking about either.

a) Sell both and get one car e.g. 996 tt (current favoured route)
b) Sell the Caterham and get a daily e.g. 530/535d Touring + 3.2 Carrera
c) Sell the 3.2 and get a daily e.g. 530/535d Touring + Caterham

The single car route appeals to make like simpler (less to ensure/service etc), but the estate car route would be more practical and I could keep the second car for when the weathers nice!

What would you do/ get?

Rocksteadyeddie

7,971 posts

258 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
Get a 520d and keep the Caterham. You'll get at least another 10mpg out of it and it's plenty quick enough for Motorway drudgery. After the Caterham even a 535d is going to feel slow so you might as well save the cash.

Edited by Rocksteadyeddie on Friday 12th March 08:12

phib

4,520 posts

290 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
Ok So we have some similarities I had a caterham and a 997 and do 150 miles a day to work and back.

I had had enough of doing it in the 997 after 9 months so sold that and bought a 535d...... big mistake I thought this was the sensible option.

I sold it after 3 months as having had fun cars 911's,Tvr's, Ferrari's etc etc it was just so dull.

Now back to square one and I am either going to keep the caterham, 355 and buy a RRS TDV8 or sell the caterham and buy a 996 tip turbo.

Don't do the 535, I suspect after the 911 and caterham you will hate it.

Phib

MarJay

2,181 posts

206 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
I'd go with option C. Why have two mental fast cars when you can have something with lots of practicality and something with lots of speed and mentalness?

Tallbut Buxomly

12,254 posts

247 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
A friend did something similar. his solution was a proker 911 and an audi a4 tdi estate B6 variant. He was very happy with the compromise.

The audi is dead ordinary but very comfy and a great cruiser and tbh isnt a bad handling car.Does all the family duties as required buggies baby seats yada yada and is cheap and cheerful to run Then on weekends or days he simply feels the need he uses the porker and its a much more exciting/special experience.

g7jhp

Original Poster:

7,036 posts

269 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
Thanks Guys.

Main reason for looking at a one car route is I drive alot in the week, but get less time to drive at the weekend (due to family).

So it's nice to be able to have a bit of fun when the opportunity presents itself.

The idea of a quick daily (estate) would be still get some fun, but have a cherished car for when I can use it in the nicer weather (daily/weekend).

keep those suggestions coming smile

Edited by g7jhp on Friday 12th March 10:05

Mr Darcy

1,006 posts

203 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
Buy my M5. Its ... errr... well its a M5.

Gad-Westy

16,668 posts

244 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
I think it would depend on how you feel about the two cars you already have. Do you think that you could replace them if you thought you'd made an error or are they both a labour of love that you know inside out and have been pampered by yourself for years?

If neither of them fit into the latter, then I'd go with option 1 and see how you get on. The Turbo is an amazing car.

pilchardthecat

7,483 posts

210 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
g7jhp said:
Main reason for looking at a one car route is I drive alot in the week, but get less time to drive at the weekend (due to family).
I'm in this position - i spend 2 hours a day in the car Mon-Fri, and maybe 20 minutes a day at the weekend, and i usually have the wife, 2 kids & associated paraphenalia. The 2 car thing with "something mad for the weekend" just doesn't work.

I'd go for a fast saloon. You can get an 18 month old IS-F for £32k, or an almost new VXR8 LS3 for £25k. What about a 335i Touring? Jaguar XF SV8?

Not sure why you're looking at a 996tt and also thinking about diesel BMWs? Are you bothered about fuel economy or not?

Mr Darcy said:
Buy my M5. Its ... errr... well its a M5.
Is that the one you washed 5 times in your entire ownership, and openly admitted to not looking after it particularly well?

Mr Darcy said:
The M5 is now looking a bit shoddy. It has over 80K on it, the dogs been in it on numerous occasions, I have only ever washed 5 times since ownership (2004 and it was 3 months old when I got it) and its basically looking like a dog. So its time is up.
nono

Edited by pilchardthecat on Friday 12th March 10:19

Mr Darcy

1,006 posts

203 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
Errrr...could be. Actaully it does have a FSH and mechanically its sound it just looks a bit of a dog at the moment.

Will sell it at a decent price considering the condition its in.

Fittster

20,120 posts

244 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
Do you currently do any track days in the Caterham?

Thorny

1,076 posts

241 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
Option C does seem like the best bet but instead of getting a 530/5d why don't you get a range rover or soemthing similar a bit more interesting? No real point having a quite fast car and a very fast car, may as well have a slow but comfortable one and the caterham?

pilchardthecat

7,483 posts

210 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
Tallbut Buxomly said:
The first one sounds nice, but the SC on the second one is fking horrible. It's sounds like a Johnnycab on speed.

parapaul

2,828 posts

229 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
Do you do any track days?

If yes, swap the 3.2 for a 535d and keep the Caterham for proper track time.
If not, trade them both in for a nice compromise.

300bhp/ton

41,030 posts

221 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
MarJay said:
I'd go with option C. Why have two mental fast cars when you can have something with lots of practicality and something with lots of speed and mentalness?
Because 2 is better than 1?? biggrin

Chris71

21,549 posts

273 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
It depends on you and the driving you do.

As a general rule I'd say you want to make them as extreme as possible if you have two (or more) cars - take the opportunity to drive something really special at the weekends and keep something sensible, comfortable and frugal for the daily trudge.

That's the theory, but it depends how much time you get to play with the fun car. As you've probably noticed the opportunities to use a car with no roof, next to no boot, tiring motorway manners and limited security (like a Caterham) are actually pretty scarce. I think the solution is either to make the sensible car a little more exciting (keep your Caterham and pair it with a Corrado perhaps) or to make the fun car more useable and just keep a shed for when you need 4 seats or more luggage capacity (a TVR or Porsche complete with watertight roof and a boot for most of the time and an old diesel barge maybe).

In direct answer, right now I'd spend £20k on a TVR Tamora and however much (£8k?) on a smart first generation 330D, then keep the rest in the pot.

g7jhp

Original Poster:

7,036 posts

269 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
Gad-Westy said:
I think it would depend on how you feel about the two cars you already have. Do you think that you could replace them if you thought you'd made an error or are they both a labour of love that you know inside out and have been pampered by yourself for years?

If neither of them fit into the latter, then I'd go with option 1 and see how you get on. The Turbo is an amazing car.
I love both my current cars and have pampered them both, but don't really use the 7 due to family (i'm sure I could find another).

The 3.2 has had alot of love and would be hardest to replace (this is my second silver 3.2 and it was a b@gger to find).


g7jhp

Original Poster:

7,036 posts

269 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
pilchardthecat said:
g7jhp said:
Main reason for looking at a one car route is I drive alot in the week, but get less time to drive at the weekend (due to family).
Not sure why you're looking at a 996tt and also thinking about diesel BMWs? Are you bothered about fuel economy or not?


Edited by pilchardthecat on Friday 12th March 10:19
We have a family car we use to lug the kids around in (which saves my cars from a battering), plus have access to a bigger estate if needed.

I'm not that bothered about fuel, the 535d just seems like a nice fast place motorway car (pace, auto, practical) which would allow me to keep a fair weather car as well.

The 996 tt would probably be the best one car compromise (performance, reliability) and I spend 90% of my time with just me in the car going to work.

g7jhp

Original Poster:

7,036 posts

269 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
parapaul said:
Do you do any track days?

If yes, swap the 3.2 for a 535d and keep the Caterham for proper track time.
If not, trade them both in for a nice compromise.
No don't have time for trackdays at the moment. Thanks for the reply smile