car replacement time soon!
car replacement time soon!
Author
Discussion

mathmos

Original Poster:

770 posts

205 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
Hello PH massive! I am looking for some opinions on where I should go for a new car, I think I've narrowed it down to 3 realistic options, but I am interested in what you would go for and why....also if there are any other options I've just not thought of.

So my budget is about 20-25k, I'll be trading in my 54 plate Z4 3.0SE (total amount to spend include the trade in). 90% of my miles are done at about 40mph going back an forth on my daily 40 mile commute to and from work. So I would like something that costs no more than the z4 to run, something more economical would be great! But this is also a car that will spend weekends on motorways and I would like something that makes decent progress when I do get the opportunity to press the accelerator!

My shortlist so far is -

Audi A3 Sportback S3
Volkswagen Golf Hatchback 2.0 TSI 210 GT
Volkswagen Scirocco Coupe 2.0 TSI 210 GT

oh...also parking is limited so going the 2 car route isn't really an option.

Crusoe

4,126 posts

262 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
Similar situation just traded my z4 for an older M3 though and have some spare aside for fuel and running costs. Enjoy motoring while you can biggrin

Of the suggestions the Scirocco is probably the most fun, might be worth waiting for a nearly new R version though?

Edited by Crusoe on Friday 12th March 09:49

BAKS42

200 posts

200 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
r32, gti edition 30, 350z or boxster s wouldnt be new though

BAKS42

200 posts

200 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
Focus RS smile not sure how much they are going for though

mathmos

Original Poster:

770 posts

205 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
Thanks chaps...some good suggestions here....the M3 is an interesting one...though I must admit I am leaning away from buying BMW again because of the fairly crappy service dept at our local dealer.

When did the Scorocco R come out? I am in no rush...there is a summer of not stop sunny days coming up (ha!) that I will probably keep the Z4 for.

Boxster S is actually where my heart is telling me I really want to go...my issue with it is the running costs and the whole sitting at 40mph for most of it's life thing...just seems a waste to have such a nice car only to have it depreciate while I do the daily slog in it most of the time

Crusoe

4,126 posts

262 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
Nice boxer S are in the mid teens for older ones and plenty of spare then for running costs. Scorocco R on the web site for £28k with 265ps and most of the extras you would want, dsg might be nice for a commute. Couple of second hand ones with delivery mileage on the vw website, wanting £30k for them though presumably to bypass a waiting list.

Tallbut Buxomly

12,254 posts

247 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
Of your options S3 without doubt only one worth the money being asked. Otherwise a hot seat.

Depending on size spec and running costs of course you could go down the route of getting anaudi b6 s4 r s4 conv. Fuel bills wont be overly cheap but running costs (maintenance) will. Fuel costs could come out of money saved on purchase price.

mathmos

Original Poster:

770 posts

205 months

Friday 12th March 2010
quotequote all
I guess an Boxster S for mid teens money would be a 40k+ mile car? I did want something newer and with lower miles, but maybe I am thinking about it wrong and the S's are bullet proof enough not to have to worry about a higher mile example.

I was thinking more of a 20k car than a 25k car...so 28 for a Scirocco R may be stretching it a bit.

Cheers Tallbut....I'll check out some of those other Audi's and see if any take my fancy!