How much space is saved by a space saver tyre?
How much space is saved by a space saver tyre?
Author
Discussion

movilogo

Original Poster:

58 posts

223 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
Is it really about space saving or cost saving?

Balmoral Green

42,561 posts

279 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
Both.

I have a full size spare, but it's a steel rather than an alloy, it has the usual yellow sticker with the same speed restrictions as a space saver confused

The Nur

9,168 posts

216 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
I imagine that there is an element of weight saving to be considered aswell (depending on type of car obviously)

i.e in an A8 I would expect a full size spare, but in a 911 I wouldnt mind a space saver in the nose

ETA: My 172 cup had no spare, just 2 cans of tyrefoam stuff. Thankfully never had reason to use it

Edited by The Nur on Saturday 13th March 17:21

Magictrousers

268 posts

205 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
In my car it's a nonsense. It came from the factory with a silly bicycle wheel, it now has a full size 19" spare nestled under the carpet, no modifications or changes needed.


chris1roll

2,069 posts

275 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
The owners manual for my wifes V40 reckons it is to stop people putting a tyre into regular service that has been sat in the boot for possibly 10+ years.

TomM

662 posts

226 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
In some cars the design of the spare wheel hole doesnt allow for anytthing else.

When I bought my Mk4 R32 I was told that as the car was an afterthought they were not about to re-design it to allow for an 18" wheel.

It just came with a "repair kit" instead of any spare at all.....always made a me a little uneasy.

jon-

16,534 posts

247 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
The Nur said:
I imagine that there is an element of weight saving to be considered aswell (depending on type of car obviously)
+1. A full width 17" wheel + tyre could top 20kgs where as a space saver can come in at just a few kgs.

chris1roll said:
The owners manual for my wifes V40 reckons it is to stop people putting a tyre into regular service that has been sat in the boot for possibly 10+ years.
+2. Another sensible way of looking at it. How many people outside of PH know that tyres go off, and how many of those that do understand the date code on the sidewall?

leeeeshad

1,480 posts

218 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
chris1roll said:
The owners manual for my wifes V40 reckons it is to stop people putting a tyre into regular service that has been sat in the boot for possibly 10+ years.
Thats a good point, how bad do they get? Iv got a 17 year old space saver assuming its the original, i wouldnt like to use that, maby there made out of thicker/different compound rubber because of this confused

Jazzer77

1,533 posts

225 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
A space saver also allows greater depth in the boot.

jamiebae

6,245 posts

242 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
It's partly to do with weight (less weight means less CO2 emissions), partly space and partly cost. Very few people will choose not to buy a car because it has a space saver, but if the boot is significantly reduced in size by the 235/50 19 on the spare wheel then some will.

beanbag

7,346 posts

272 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
At least you got a space-saver! I got a pressurised container full of goo with my BMW 1 series (I did get run-flats).

However, on a plus note they did give me a pretty good quality cigarette socket powered air compressor....

topless_mx5

2,763 posts

249 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
Why not save space and weight by just carrying some tyre weld? That and AA membership...

Colin 1985

1,936 posts

201 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
I would imagine it is easier to change a light weight space-saver in a car park or at the side of the road than a heavy 19" alloy.

jbi

12,700 posts

235 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
tyre weld?

your local wheel fitter is going to love you

GKP

15,099 posts

272 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
The rear tyres on my car are 285/35/18. I'm quite glad there isn't a full size spare stuffed in the boot. There'd be no room for anything else.

G0ldfysh

3,318 posts

288 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
I had a can of goo, but removed it for hehe weight saving. Just carry a card for the AA so much simpler.

Engineer1

10,486 posts

240 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
It also means that the manufacturer fits 4 alloys to a car not 5, so there is a saving there. Then if there is a range of wheels they will all have a similar overall radius of wheel and tyre, but the space saver means that 1 spare wheel is required across the range, most cars now days offer a range of alloys generally of different sizes. The stupidest is the spare on my car which has space for a full size under slung spare but they fitted a very dished space saver that must have a similar depth to a real spare except the rim and tyre are narrow.

Drive Blind

5,801 posts

208 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
chris1roll said:
The owners manual for my wifes V40 reckons it is to stop people putting a tyre into regular service that has been sat in the boot for possibly 10+ years.
so do space savers have a longer shelf life than a normal tyre?

or are they just working on the assumption you wont go hooning about on a space saver?

busta

4,504 posts

264 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
Colin 1985 said:
I would imagine it is easier to change a light weight space-saver in a car park or at the side of the road than a heavy 19" alloy.
What, and discard the heavy 19" alloy you've just removed on the roadside?

Bowler

915 posts

242 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
My Daily Driver came to me with a cost space saver, that I didn't fancy having (facing the possiblity of a 250 mile round trip with in a pram wheel doesn't appeal) so I invested in a full sized (steel) spare.

It's too high to fit into the wheel well....



My Weekend Toy was designed for Run Flats, but I've opted for P Zero's for a softer ride. I carry a can of tyre weld and an electric pump as I'd rather fk the sensors and give the tyre fitter a crappy job, than get mugged on the side of the motorway for a 245/45/18