Looking for a new car, questions about which one and stuff?
Looking for a new car, questions about which one and stuff?
Author
Discussion

smartercleaning

Original Poster:

13 posts

200 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
Hi, firstly I am quite new and do not know an awful lot about cars, so please cut me some slack. I currently have a pug 206 with a mighty 1.1 litre engine. Given that this was my first car it has been ok. However now I am having to drive long motorway trips for work I need something which is: a) More comfortable, 2) More powerful, I find it worrying when I have to wait a considerable time to get from 40 to 70.

Now I have been looking at two cars: Audi A3, and the BMW 1 series. I would prefer a diesel and wouldnt want to have anything older than a 2005 car. What are your opinions on these cars? I have looked on the classifieds and see that they range from 4k to 10k, why is there such a big discrepancy? Are there alot of scammers on the classifieds parts?

Also I know I am going to be raped with insurance given I'm male and 20 and also that I have 0 no claims and 3 points on the license (not looking good!). I would maybe willing to drop to a 1.6 but I think anything else would be pointless as I do want something which can do motorways.


LuS1fer

43,572 posts

276 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
smartercleaning said:
I do want something which can do motorways.
How about a Roller?


SEriously though, you'll just have to check the insurance first otherwise you're wasting your time even thinking about it. Plenty of cars can do motorways even with 1.6 engines. I even had a Corolla 1.3 once that dealt with them reasonably well. Drive a few. Skoda Fabia VRs possibly?

smartercleaning

Original Poster:

13 posts

200 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
Lol very funny with the roller - I know that a 1.6 will be ok. However insurance is a big deal, but not a deal breaker. I can offset the insurance and car against my tax (self employed) and was told that I was looking at about an extra £700 when I called my insurers about the A3. Also I feel that a respectable car will help me career wise.

So back to topic. Are the classifieds on this site reliable? Is there a reason why some off the cars seem to be marked up at about £3-4k less than other similar ones.

I would also like to know what people think of the A3 and the 1 series? Thanks

TheHitman

17 posts

214 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
I drive an 54 reg A3 2.0tdi paperbag

Any questions I will try and answer from a day to day living point of view. I will admit I know absolutely nothing mechanical.

smartercleaning

Original Poster:

13 posts

200 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
Hi Hitman,

Thankfully I know very little about mechanics as well so will not ask you anything about that! However I would be interested to know what you think of the car? Have you found it reliable? Is there anything about running the car which you don't like? thanks

TheHitman

17 posts

214 months

Saturday 13th March 2010
quotequote all
smartercleaning said:
Hi Hitman,

Thankfully I know very little about mechanics as well so will not ask you anything about that! However I would be interested to know what you think of the car? Have you found it reliable? Is there anything about running the car which you don't like? thanks
I have only owned the car for about 8 month or so. Bought from a main dealer approx 44k on the clock. It has been totally reliable in that (small) amount of time.

Bad points;
It is boring to drive; I have not drove a huge amount of cars but the Focus I had before was far superior.
It was awful in the snow at pulling away (maybe it was me but I'm blaming the tyres)

Good points;
MPG can be good depending on your commute, 50mpg+ and keeping up rolleyes with traffic is the norm.
Interior quality is a huge step above the Focus, the owner before specced all the required mod cons and WBAC are offering above what I paid for it to buy it off me rolleyes.

Overall I had the Focus for 5 years and it never let me down once and cost peanuts to run, took the 'gamble' and bought the Audi and do not regret it.




smartercleaning

Original Poster:

13 posts

200 months

Sunday 14th March 2010
quotequote all
Thanks hitman. It might be boring to drive but tbh I am not a driving lover (I know I shouldnt be on this forum). At the moment I am doing about 500 miles a week in a tiny car, and being tall and a gym monkey it is bloody uncomfortable. All I looking for is something which will allow me to get to jobs in comfort, and also something which isnt going to kill me when it comes to putting petrol in the way prices are going. Also as silly as this sounds I need something which is going to make me look professional.

I really like the audi's and am told that they have good engines (not that I would really know), I also love the audi interior (but the only car's I have ever driven have been a ford fiesta and a pug 206 so I don't have a high benchmark).

I think I will go and test drive the audi and the bmw and then I will have a better way of comparing. Again thanks.

jdwoodbury

1,372 posts

237 months

Sunday 14th March 2010
quotequote all
I can vouch for the Audi, I prefer the looks over the 1 series although the BMW is the more dynamic drive. Interior looks and quality on the Audi win it for me and top MPG great for the motorway, the only think I would say is steer clear of the 18" wheels as they dont give the most comfortable ride.