Range Rover Or Range Rover Sport ?
Range Rover Or Range Rover Sport ?
Author
Discussion

phib

Original Poster:

4,520 posts

290 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
So I have decided to buy either a Range Rover TDV8 2007 28k Black / Ivory no privacy ( dont like it) or a Range rover Sport similar money / similar spec.

However I am really having issues deciding which to buy, originally I set out to buy a RRS TDV8 black / Light interior with a sunroof and no privacy but they just dont seem to exist !!!

Hence why I ended up with the potential deal on the range rover, has anyone owned both ? or mnoved from a 535d or 997 to either of them ( hence why I put it in general gassing hope thats ok)

Or have any helpfull advice, planning on keeping it for a while so want to get it right

Thanks
Phib

Edited by phib on Monday 15th March 18:24

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
Neither, get the Vogue.

amir_j

3,579 posts

232 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
joshc said:
Neither, get the Vogue.
yes If I ever got a RR, would have to be the RR Vogue. Those I know who have had a RRS say its not as good as the full fat version, and if you are getting one would be madness not to get the vogue.

phib

Original Poster:

4,520 posts

290 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
Sorry the Range rover is the vogue

Phib

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
I would go for the Range Rover over the fake Range Rover (the sport) any day.

okgo

42,408 posts

229 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
phib said:
Sorry the Range rover is the vogue

Phib
I think he normal range looks 100% more adult and elegant than the sport. smile

useyourdellusion

5,648 posts

221 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
By 'privacy' I suppose you mean the tinted windows?

I thought the film was quite easy to remove...

David911RSR

1,446 posts

241 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
FFRR every time

belleair302

7,015 posts

238 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
Always buy the fullest fattest model available. There is no substitute for size!

dugt

1,657 posts

238 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
Full fat every time, the sport is "just" a pumped up disco.

It's a 2.5 ton car so your obviously not buying it hoping it will handle like a lotus so you may as well go for all the comfort.

phib

Original Poster:

4,520 posts

290 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
useyourdellusion said:
By 'privacy' I suppose you mean the tinted windows?

I thought the film was quite easy to remove...
Most have factory glass which is in the glass not just a film and its £1450 to change all the glasss, not something I really want to do

Phib

ian_c_uk

1,453 posts

234 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
Drove the 2010 RR and RRS at Gaydon (high speed track, not off-road) recently.

Preconceptions before / on getting into them:

RR: Big inside, feels like a luxury MPV, great visibility.

RRS: Tries too hard, big outside but not so great inside.

Drove the RR first, jaysus it leans.... felt like I was going so slowly and hanging onto the wheel. Didn't feel comfortable using the power until it had levelled off again. I'm sure it's capable but it didn't give me any confidence at all, in fact scraped all the confidence away and left me uncomfortable in the stomach!

Then I drove the RRS, what a difference. Yes, it's big, yes it leans, but it "settles" into a corner much quicker, will carry more speed with ease, and felt comfortable using the power before exiting the same corner as above.

In summary, RR, destroyed the image I had of them, RRS, was checking autotrader when I got home to see how used prices were doing.


amir_j

3,579 posts

232 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
ian_c_uk said:
In summary, RR, destroyed the image I had of them
Epic Fail

Whaton earth are you on about FFS, you took a RR on a high speed, non-off road track and complained it leaned?

FFS, its a wafting barge and meant to be driven at a leisurely pace.



Edited by amir_j on Monday 15th March 18:54

phib

Original Poster:

4,520 posts

290 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
amir_j said:
ian_c_uk said:
In summary, RR, destroyed the image I had of them
Epic Fail

Whaton earth are you on about FFS, you took a RR on a high speed, non-off road track and complained it leaned?

FFS, its a wafting barge and meant to be driven at a leisurely pace.


Edited by amir_j on Monday 15th March 18:54
As much as it pains me that is my issue I think to be honest, I do about 35k per year mostly motorway but some a road etec etc

When I drove the RR today it was pretty wallowy, where as the sport was far more composed on A roads / round roundabouts however the RR was a far nicer place to be and was quieter on the motorway

Descisions descisions

Phib

amir_j

3,579 posts

232 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
phib said:
amir_j said:
ian_c_uk said:
In summary, RR, destroyed the image I had of them
Epic Fail

Whaton earth are you on about FFS, you took a RR on a high speed, non-off road track and complained it leaned?

FFS, its a wafting barge and meant to be driven at a leisurely pace.


Edited by amir_j on Monday 15th March 18:54
As much as it pains me that is my issue I think to be honest, I do about 35k per year mostly motorway but some a road etec etc

When I drove the RR today it was pretty wallowy, where as the sport was far more composed on A roads / round roundabouts however the RR was a far nicer place to be and was quieter on the motorway

Descisions descisions

Phib
Out of interest- what height setting was the suspension on- curious as to wether it made a difference when it was lower.

But find it strange, I have driven a 03 vogue diesal as a mate had one. Didn't find it an issue as only pushed it on straights.

Flanders.

6,442 posts

239 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
FFRR. You won't look like a tt that way.

Trommel

20,667 posts

290 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
If the proper Range Rover had the Sport's active anti-roll bars it would be pretty much perfect.

They are a much nicer thing to travel in than a Sport (although the facelifted Sport is great inside).

V8mate

45,899 posts

220 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
I'd buy a fully-loaded Disco - late 3 or 4 - and spend on the rest on life's delights.

Stu R

21,701 posts

246 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
V8mate said:
I'd buy a fully-loaded Disco - late 3 or 4 - and spend on the rest on life's delights.
Same here.

stewy68

1,826 posts

274 months

Monday 15th March 2010
quotequote all
I have never given the RRS a second look, but I always seem to notice the FFRR. Since the Rangie was launched, they have always had something about them that made them special.
The RRS, on the other hand hasn't got that factor.